Before I sum up on behalf of the committee, I must say, from a personal angle, that this is one of the best debates that I have participated in, because it is looking at the way in which the Parliament works, and that should concern us all.
On behalf of the committee, I say to Jeremy Balfour, Colin Smyth and Sarah Boyack that we do not in any way underestimate the passion, integrity and commitment with which they have represented the interests of the groups that are associated with the bills that they have brought to Parliament. It is important to say, on behalf of the committee, that our approach is not about the contributions of individual members or the issues that have been brought to us.
We must understand the issue in the context of where we are starting from. As Michael Marra set out, the evidence that was presented to us was pretty much unanimous. That is an important point, because there was a recognition that the structure has evolved over time on an ad hoc basis rather than through a coherent approach, and that that has been a problem.
Obviously, there have been significant pressures on the public finances, and, in his very good speech, Ross Greer made an important point—I hope that I do not trash my reputation by agreeing with him again this week—about the fact that we started this week in the chamber by looking at fiscal sustainability, and that this debate is also part of that debate on fiscal sustainability.
The debate is also about concerns around the delivery of some public services that have been seen to be deficient. We could take from what Jeremy Balfour, Colin Smyth and Sarah Boyack were saying that they have naturally been very disappointed that the public services that should have been looking after the groups that they have chosen to represent have not been doing that. Some of the witnesses noted that, when it comes to the Scottish Government’s commitment to public sector reform—the minister was enthusiastic about the need for that to happen—there is a concern about the amount of time that that is taking.
All that context is important to the committee, as it helps us understand what has been driving the substantial increase in the number of proposals to create new SPCB-supported bodies, following a period of relative stability in the commissioner landscape before that.
It is clear from the evidence that the Finance and Public Administration Committee took that the current model is no longer fit for purpose, as it lacks clarity, coherence, sufficient accountability and transparency over budget setting. That combination is something that could produce a very bad cocktail—bad for the stakeholders and potentially bad for the reputation of the Parliament.
The committee was clear that we need to look at why we are seeing greater demand in relation to the advocacy type of commissioner. The Scottish Information Commissioner said to us that
“a lot of the desire for future commissioners is a bellwether to the lack of trust and confidence in a lot of public services.”—[Official Report, Finance and Public Administration Committee, 30 April 2024; c 16.]
My goodness—that is quite a strong comment, and it concerns something that matters to all MSPs. Similarly, Age Scotland commented that the SPCB-supported model is
“an established way of getting more effective action on particular issues.”—[Official Report, Finance and Public Administration Committee, 7 May 2024; c 3.]
That is particularly the case because the model provides for more independence, which implies that the best route might not always be via ministers.
That said, other groups such as the Health and Social Care Alliance Scotland took a very different view, namely that commissioners might act as a “sticking plaster”, but without really solving the problem.
In reflecting on those points, the committee was struck by the evidence that was presented to us by two former MSPs, Alex Neil and David Stewart, who, in the previous session, had been very enthusiastic about introducing members’ bills for new advocacy commissioners, but had completely changed their minds about the wisdom of doing so, because they felt that it was a bit of buck passing, whereas the legislation should have been pursued by ministers or by committees.
As some members have said, the Finance and Public Administration Committee had concerns that the rise in the demand for advocacy commissioners was probably related to the weak delivery of too many public services across Scotland—in other words, that there were inherent failures within the existing system—and to the fact that the Government finds it too easy simply to say that the work could be done by a commissioner, rather than by it. We should all reflect upon that. Several members asked us whether it would be better to target the money at public services to ensure that all the demands that we are making are met through those public services.
As Michael Marra rightly said, we found too much duplication within the system and too little awareness among the public about the role played by each commissioner. To the committee’s astonishment, some commissioners told us that they did not really feel that they were providing sufficient evidence to parliamentary committees on the matters that they were being asked to account for. In fact, one commissioner told us that, despite writing seven different reports, he had been called before a committee only once. That tells us something.
I will now raise what I think is quite an important issue about the working of the Parliament—a matter that has come from a lot of the debate on this subject. It is whether we have the appropriate structures in place in the Parliament for accountability, to deal with the kinds of decision making that the debate has thrown up. This is about the workings of Parliament; it is not a party-political issue. It is about how effective we are in putting such decisions to the members of the Parliament.
One of the great things about the debate is that there has been very considerable consensus right across the political spectrum that the Parliament is not working well enough when it comes to dealing with a lot of the advocacy issues. I say that with some experience, having worked on the Eljamel case for 10 years. I understand why a patient safety commissioner has been called for, because I do not feel that the existing system was dealing with the concerns of the former patients of Eljamel. I understand where people are all coming from in wanting individual commissioners. That said, there is a big issue around the lack of consistency, about the lack of coherence and about public money.
I can say on behalf of the committee that we very much welcome the debate, which has given the Parliament an awful lot of food for thought, including about how we work and how we disburse public money. As I say, it has given us a lot to think about. We have to take stock and think about what we are going to do for the future, and the committee is calling for a moratorium in order to allow us to do that. I welcome the Green amendment, which puts a timescale on that—which is very important.
I finish by thanking all the witnesses from whom we took evidence; the SPCB, for its very positive contributions; members of the Parliament, for their positive contributions; the Scottish Government, for responding to our report; and, as always, our first-class team of clerks, who I see are seated up at the back of the chamber. I call on members to support the committee’s motion.