I do not have time at the moment, but I might give way later, once I have made more points.
According to Mr Marra, there will be an additional £3.4 billion in the block grant. We will see the detail of that in due course but, if that is true, it will give the Scottish Government more wriggle room in the choices that it can make.
However, the UK budget is bad news for business, because it includes a hike in national insurance to 15 per cent and a staggering increase—to 78 per cent—in the windfall tax on oil and gas, which is doing enormous damage to the oil and gas sector and to the economy of north-east Scotland. There is also an increase in spirits duty and a hit on farmers passing on land. This afternoon, the National Farmers Union described it as a “disastrous budget” for family farmers and especially for tenant farmers.
What really galls people is the broken promises that we have had from Labour. In the run-up to the election, Keir Starmer said 50 times that Labour had no plans to increase taxes, but the truth has been revealed today.
The winter fuel allowance has been withdrawn from pensioners, and 900,000 pensioners across Scotland are impacted by that. There is no U-turn on that, and there is no sign of the £300 cut to fuel bills that was supposed to be promised.
Keir Starmer also said that he was going to back the Scotch whisky industry to the hilt. He has not done that today—he has increased the duty on whisky and taxed the industry to the hilt instead.
I agree with what Michelle Thomson, who is in the chamber this afternoon, said yesterday about the need to put economic growth first. That ambition is shared by most parties across the chamber, although perhaps not by the Greens.
As Liz Smith said, we cannot ignore the impact on growth of differential tax rates in Scotland. We hear that from the finance sector, the hospitality sector and those who are involved in manufacturing. We hear that businesses are now having to pay a Scottish supplement in additional wages because of the higher taxes. That has an impact not only on the private sector but on the public sector, as we know that high earners in the health service, for example, are deliberately choosing not to work full-time hours because of the impact of higher tax.
In a survey that was done by the Fraser of Allander Institute last month, two out of three Scottish businesses said that the tax issue was having an impact on their businesses. It was the single biggest concern for Scottish businesses, with 27 per cent of the construction businesses that responded saying that it had a lot of impact on what they were trying to do and was, of course, impacting on recruitment.
What should the Scottish Government do with its budget? It has to start to address tax rates. In a speech earlier this week, my colleague Russell Findlay said that the 21p rate was one of the rates that could be removed to set a direction of travel in trying to equalise tax rates in Scotland with those in the rest of the UK.
The Scottish Government has to do something about its reputation with business. Alexander Stewart reminded us of another survey that was done by the Fraser of Allander Institute. Just 9 per cent of Scottish firms agree that the Scottish Government understands the business environment in Scotland, whereas 64 per cent disagree. Just 6 per cent of businesses agree that the Government engages well with their sector. The figure was a dismal 8 per cent in 2023, and it is now down to 6 per cent—so much for the new deal for business.
However, there is now an opportunity, because Barnett consequentials will be coming as a result of the UK budget. For the past two years, I have been calling for the Scottish Government to pass on to businesses that are struggling with rising costs in the retail, hospitality and leisure sectors the 75 per cent rates relief that has been available south of the border last year and in the current year. Such businesses will struggle even more now because of the increases in employer national insurance.
Today, the Chancellor of the Exchequer, Rachel Reeves, announced not that she would extend the 75 per cent rates relief but that she would introduce a new 40 per cent relief for retail, hospitality and leisure businesses in England and Wales for the next financial year. I do not think that that goes far enough, but it is a welcome measure that will generate Barnett consequentials for the Scottish Government. If Scottish ministers are serious about supporting Scottish businesses, it is time for them to help our struggling hospitality businesses, and they have the choice to do so now that the funds are available to them.
I am nearly out of time. I welcome the change in the Scottish Government’s rhetoric, now that the Greens are no longer part of the Administration, with it talking again about economic growth. That is very welcome, but it is time for the Government to put its money where its mouth is. It now needs to start to address the impact of tax on the Scottish economy. That point is made in Craig Hoy’s motion, which I am delighted to support.