Good morning, convener. As the committee knows, the Coronavirus (Recovery and Reform) (Scotland) Act 2022 includes a range of temporary justice measures, which were introduced to make sure that our justice system had the necessary flexibility to respond to the impact of the pandemic.
Since then, justice agencies have made significant progress towards recovery, and the need for some of the temporary measures has disappeared or reduced. Last year, the Scottish Government made regulations that expired several measures. Our continuing determination to reduce the number of temporary measures is shown by the expiry regulations that the committee is considering today, which expire two further measures because those are deemed no longer necessary or proportionate—including one of the extended time limits that were put in place at the start of the pandemic.
The proposed extension regulations would extend the remaining temporary measures so that those stay in force until the end of 30 November 2025. My decisions on which measures to extend are based on consultation with justice agencies, the legal profession, the judiciary, local government, and victim support organisations and other third sector bodies. The statement of reasons, which I laid alongside the regulations, sets out in some detail the findings of that consultation and review. For now, I will outline briefly why we need to retain the provisions.
We continue to see the impact of the pandemic on criminal court backlogs. Considerable progress is being made on reducing those backlogs. The total number of outstanding scheduled trials fell by more than 40 per cent between January 2022 and August 2024. However, modelling by the Scottish Courts and Tribunals Service predicts that backlogs of solemn trials will persist above the target baseline until 2026-27.
The measures in the extension regulations will continue to help in the effective use of court resources. For example, the availability of higher maximum fines will mean that more summary cases can be diverted from prosecution, which will reduce the number of cases that need to go to court.
The two extended time limits—which, under the extension regulations, would continue for one final year before reverting to their pre-pandemic level—will increase the courts’ capacity to hear trials rather than spend time on procedural matters. That will help the throughput of cases and protect victims’ access to justice.
I am committed to the reversion of the time limits next year; indeed, there is no ability under the 2022 act to extend them any further, and ministers have no intention of legislating to make them permanent, so they will end no later than 30 November 2025. However, justice agencies are clear that the extended time limits will continue to play an important role in helping the courts to manage the current solemn case load. The data that I offered shows the progress that has been made so far, but we should allow the justice agencies to continue their work to reduce the backlog. Their view is that, without the provisions, the timescale for reducing the solemn case backlog would be extended, and that there would be a risk that some cases would not proceed at all.
I am sure that none of us wants to jeopardise the courts’ capacity to focus on the throughput of trials. It is plain to me that the two remaining extended time limits must be continued for one final year, after which they will expire.
The other measures in the extension regulations include the conduct of business by electronic means, attendance at court by electronic means, and a national jurisdiction for callings from custody. Although the pandemic was a catalyst for introducing those measures, they have shown their value in modernising our justice processes and making those more efficient. They deliver better outcomes and experiences for people who use Scotland’s justice services. It is right that we look to extend the use of those valuable measures, which will promote the on-going recovery of the justice system and ensure the continuation of modernised practices that were much needed and welcomed.
Permanent reform will require primary legislation. Last month, we introduced the Criminal Justice Modernisation and Abusive Domestic Behaviour Reviews (Scotland) Bill, which proposes making permanent those measures that have a proven broader and longer-term benefit. To be clear, convener, that bill does not make any provision to continue extended time limits. As I said, those cannot be retained beyond the end of November 2025.
It is clear that, collectively and as a package of temporary measures, the extension regulations are vital in supporting our justice system’s continued recovery and resilience in the coming year.