I thank Martin Whitfield for securing this important members’ business debate. As Ben Macpherson has said, it is a pleasure to follow on from him.
Like Mr Whitfield, I have had the pleasure of meeting the team from Edinburgh Children’s Hospital Charity on two occasions, the first being here in the garden lobby of the Parliament, and then this week at the haven. When I visited the team at the haven in their home at the Fraser centre, Fiona O’Sullivan illustrated to me at first hand how committed the staff were to delivering innovative early intervention and family-focused services for young people who, as Mr Whitfield has said, are struggling with their mental health—often anxiety, but also depression and self-harm.
Since Covid, there has been a much greater focus on the mental health of children and young people and on the pressures faced by the CAMHS system. Much of that coverage has been negative in nature—about, for example, how the system is stretched, long waits and rejected referrals. Those problems should, can and, hopefully, will be addressed by ministers over time. However, solving them will, I suspect, never address the needs of every young person, which is why we need services such as the haven.
The haven does not work in isolation. Where it needs to, as it frequently does, it integrates seamlessly with the CAMHS system. It uses the same language and techniques, creating a continuum of care that ensures that children and young people receive the support that they need.
However, we must remember that the haven is a pilot, which I was acutely aware of when visiting this week. Although early-stage evaluation underlines its positive impact, its future is not a given, even in the microclimate that it occupies, in one town in one part of Scotland. At the moment, Edinburgh Children’s Hospital Charity is entirely funding the facility; in the long term, however, it will need Scottish Government funding to make it sustainable and scalable across the country.
As Mr Whitfield’s motion makes clear, 1,264 visits have been made to the haven since it opened, with 274 made by unique visitors whom the service supported directly. If we think in a cumulative way of those 274 individuals in a single town, we can just imagine the impact of such a service if it had reach across the whole of Scotland.
As the motion also makes clear, without places such as the haven, there is a risk that the mental health problems of Scotland’s children today will become the mental health problems of the adults of tomorrow. There is also a risk that, in the absence of alternative pathways and without early intervention, the problems of too many children and young people will reach such levels of acuteness that they will require in-patient CAMHS services, which are in very short supply in Lothian. Having visited the haven and spoken to the team, I know how committed they are to the principle of early intervention and non-time-sensitive care.
The service is open to young people themselves, which is important, but it is open to their families, too. Having talked to constituents as well as friends and family who have experienced their children going through such services, I know that they often feel locked out of the process of treatment, counselling and recovery.
With CAMHS, young people go into a service that generally has a deadline for each stage of the process; however, the facility at the haven does not and instead allows each child to go at their own pace. Another point that came out of the recent discussion that I had with the service was that families do not need to keep telling their story time and time again, which is traumatic for them. I got the impression that it is literally seeking to get it right for every child.
I know that Mr Whitfield has visited the haven, and I encourage the minister and others to do so. I know that it is very keen to invite politicians and other stakeholders, because it is only through that collaboration that it will be able to get the pilot on a long-term and sure footing. I also encourage senior representatives of East Lothian Council—the chief executive, the head of education and other senior officers—to visit and engage with the service, because only through council collaboration will it be able to drive change on the ground.
I will close not with my own words, but with those of the haven, which sum up what it offers and what I hope that it could offer right throughout Scotland, if we managed to put it on a sustainable financial footing. It says:
“We offer support in a fully accessible, relaxed and informal setting. We do this through a range of activities we know young people will enjoy. Or, if all you need is a cup of tea and a listening ear, we’re here to help you cope. Our team is there on the good days, the bad days, and everything else in between.”
That is the kind of service that we need at the heart of our communities, and I hope that the Government, local authorities and the third sector can work together to deliver projects out of the haven right across Scotland.
17:38