As the convener of the Delegated Powers and Law Reform Committee—the lead committee for the Judicial Factors (Scotland) Bill—I am delighted to speak in the stage 1 debate on the bill.
I thank the minister for her helpful response to the Delegated Powers and Law Reform Committee’s stage 1 report and recommendations. The minister touched on that in her comments. This is the third Scottish Law Commission bill in this session of Parliament for which the committee has acted as lead committee. It is worth reiterating that that is a part of the committee’s role and remit that members appreciate and find very much worth while. I want to make the minister aware of a point that I put to the Minister for Parliamentary Business this morning: our committee is always happy to look at SLC bills. We have touched on that in the past.
For the vast majority of the population, Scottish Law Commission bills are, by design, rarely the most eye-catching pieces of legislation. They are less political by nature, but they are all crucial in ensuring that we have a statute book that is fit for purpose. We believe that the commission’s role in ensuring that the law keeps pace with the way we live and work in Scotland is very much worth while. The resulting legislation, such as the Judicial Factors (Scotland) Bill, is hugely important, even if quietly so. I pay tribute to the commission for its work on the bill.
Judicial factors are an ancient, pre-union institution of the Scottish courts. The minister explained what a judicial factor is, so I do not have to reiterate that. The bill updates the main current law on judicial factors, which is Victorian, dating from 1849 and 1889. It also repeals some even older acts of sederunt from the Court of Session, the oldest of which dates from 1690. That perhaps gives members a flavour of the age and background of the office of judicial factor and why it was an appropriate subject for the Scottish Law Commission’s attention.
The commission’s work in the area began back in the 1970s, but it stepped up a gear in the early 2010s with its 2013 report, on which the bill is based. We were very grateful to the Scottish Law Commission—including its chair, Lady Paton, former commissioner Patrick Layden, who led on the report, and the now former interim chief executive, Charles Garland—for giving evidence to the committee. We were grateful to all the organisations that engaged with us on the bill.
I pay tribute to my committee colleagues for the way in which they worked on the bill. All our recommendations were unanimous, and the committee agreed with the general principles of the bill. I also thank the Delegated Powers and Law Reform Committee clerking team for its crucial assistance during the stage 1 process.
There are only around 65 active judicial factories in Scotland. Those are open cases where a judicial factor has been appointed to manage the estate. The number of new appointments is also low, with only about seven applications for appointment a year. However, we agree with the consensus among witnesses and those who responded to the call for views that the role of a judicial factor is a necessary one that should be continued.
Of course, as with any bill, we identified a number of areas where more work may be worth while. I will briefly touch on a couple of the main points.
In her response to the committee’s stage 1 report, the minister agreed with a number of the committee’s recommendations. I also thank the Scottish Courts and Tribunals Service for its helpful response to the report.
One area that we must get right is when a judicial factor is appointed to help manage the estate of a missing person. The bill presents an opportunity to help the families and loved ones of people who go missing and will perhaps make an inevitably stressful and difficult situation slightly easier.
The charity Missing People gave compelling evidence to the committee, raising important issues such as how practical it would be for a lay person who is a family member or friend to be appointed as a judicial factor. The charity supported such a proposition, given the cost of having a professional—such as the solicitors and accountants who make up the majority of judicial factors at present—looking after the best interests of a missing person. It also asked what those “best interests” might mean in different situations and what evidence would be required for a court to accept that a person is missing.
It is encouraging that the minister has committed to creating guidance specifically on judicial factors in relation to missing people. We are assured that that will cover many of the issues raised by the committee, and that the Government will engage further with Missing People, which will be crucial in getting that area right.
The committee made a specific recommendation that the bill should include
“an explicit statement ... that it is competent to appoint a judicial factor to the estate of a missing person.”
We thought it important to ensure clarity on that point, and I would be grateful if the minister could say more in her summing up about how that could be addressed.
During our stage 1 scrutiny, we were encouraged by the willingness of both the Government and the Scottish Courts and Tribunals Service to adapt and review processes—including those for making complaints about a judicial factor—to make them easier for lay people to navigate. We hope that the implementation of changes will follow in a similar spirit.
In its report, the committee also raised the issue of how judicial factories are advertised, via a register, to those who need to know about them. Our report discusses data protection and the extent to which that area of law has sometimes been cited as a reason why information is not shared with judicial factors. The report also refers to the need to obtain a section 104 order from the United Kingdom Government to ensure that the bill gives judicial factors the powers that they need if they are to operate effectively.
I do not have time to go into those important issues in depth, but I am hopeful that the committee’s scrutiny will lead to positive differences between the bill as introduced and what the eventual act will look like.
Members will be aware that section 104 orders are, understandably, a recurring theme with SLC bills, so I would be grateful if the minister could provide an update in her summing up regarding any communication that the Scottish Government has had with the new UK Government on that matter.
My final point is about why no judicial factor was appointed in the case of McClure Solicitors. Committee evidence on that matter was helpful, and the Regulation of Legal Services (Scotland) Bill, which is also going through Parliament, may actually be of more assistance than the Judicial Factors (Scotland) Bill in ensuring that future clients do not experience anything similar.
As I said, although this might not be the most eye-catching bill, it covers a hugely important part of the legal landscape, and it is time for that to be modernised.
15:53