To ask the Scottish Government how it plans to support the retention of Scotland’s public libraries. (S6O-03722)
Official Report · Chamber
Public Libraries (Support)
Portfolio Question Time Constitution, External Affairs and Culture, and Parliamentary Business
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Angus Robertson SNP 6
- Annabelle Ewing SNP 3
- Richard Leonard Lab 2
- Clare Haughey SNP 1
- Alexander Stewart Con 1
- George Adam SNP 1
The record
14 contributionsScottish Government officials work closely with the Scottish Library and Information Council, which provides leadership and advice to Scottish ministers, local authorities and the wider libraries sector.
In 2022-23, 2023-24 and 2024-25, we provided funding of £665,000 to the SLIC in recognition of the importance of our public libraries and as an expression of our support for the excellent services that libraries provide. That is on top of the Scottish Government’s general revenue funding to local authorities and includes the public library improvement fund, which supports creative, sustainable and innovative public library projects throughout the whole of Scotland.
I thank the cabinet secretary for his reply. Since the Government came to power, spending on our public libraries is down, book stocks are down, the number of library staff is down, and more than 120 public libraries have closed for good. Does the cabinet secretary accept that libraries matter, that they are a vital part of our children’s education, that they combat social isolation, that they can help to regenerate our towns and cities, that they represent a world beyond the market—a safe space, run not for profit but for enlightenment—and that, in a digital society, libraries are not needed less but are needed even more? If he does accept that, what does the Government intend to do about it?
I agree entirely with everything that we just heard about the importance of libraries for both individuals and communities. That is why—Richard Leonard heard my initial answer—the Scottish Government has committed the resources that it has committed to protect and support the provision of library services across Scotland. There is also an onus on local government to maintain provision—he knows that as well I do—and we need to work in partnership to ensure that we maintain libraries as a service the length and breadth of Scotland.
If Richard Leonard wishes to highlight any particular issues, I ask him to get in touch with me. Perhaps at the next vote on the Scottish Government’s budget he might wish to exercise his vote to support the resources that are being put into libraries.
I hope to take all three requests for supplementary questions, but I need co-operation in the form of brief questions and brief answers.
link
Local authorities have a statutory duty to provide adequate public library services, and the Labour administration of South Lanarkshire Council is overseeing the closure of three libraries in my constituency in Cambuslang, Halfway and Blantyre, which represents 75 per cent of the main libraries in my constituency. That is happening despite residents’ deep concern about the impact that the closures will have.
Does the minister agree that it is crucial that local authorities maintain the strategic overview of library services, even if they are commissioned by arm’s-length bodies, and that meaningful consultation with communities must precede any service changes?
Given the rhetoric that we heard a moment ago, it is very disappointing to hear that Labour local authorities, such as Clare Haughey’s own, are cutting library services and closing libraries. Public libraries in Scotland are devolved to local authorities, and they have a statutory duty to ensure that there is adequate provision of library services for residents. However, the Scottish Government recognises the significant financial pressures and community-level impacts that flow from 14 years of Westminster austerity. The Labour Government has confirmed that it is to continue that austerity, with £22 billion-worth of public spending cuts.
With all roads leading back to Westminster, as we hear and as the Labour Government acknowledges, the First Minister has been clear that we need an injection of investment in our public services, not more cuts.
SNP Government cuts have led to a 14 per cent reduction in Scotland’s public libraries, with the public library improvement fund addressing only a fraction of the funding problems that they face. What specific action will the cabinet secretary take to address the on-going impact of those cuts, beyond the scope of that fund?
I will tell you what, Presiding Officer, I am certainly not going to take any lessons on supporting public services from the party of austerity. It really does take a—[Interruption.] It really does take—[Interruption.] It really does take a brass neck—[Interruption.]
Mr Stewart! Cabinet secretary—please resume.
It really does take a brass neck to do that, and no matter how much one shouts on the issue, it does not get us beyond the fact that it was the UK Conservative Party that implemented austerity. The impact on public spending has been felt the length and breadth of the UK, including Scotland, so I encourage Alexander Stewart to recant on the austerity that his party has been responsible for and to, at least, acknowledge that that might have some impact on the level of public funding in the UK—not least in England, where, under his party’s responsibility, cuts to the Department for Culture, Media and Sport have been vast.
link
Is it not the reality that since the Conservatives came to power in 2010, the number of UK libraries has fallen dramatically under the austerity agenda? What assessment has been made of the impact of Tory-led budget cuts on public libraries in Scotland, as well as of the future impact and consequences of the continued austerity measures that the Labour Party supports?
If people did not already understand, it is becoming ever clearer that the austerity politics—the reduction of and constraints on public funding in the United Kingdom—have an impact—[Interruption.] I do not understand why Conservative members are shaking their heads. That is a matter of financial fact. UK Government austerity is having a significant impact on public spending in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland. That is a fact.
It would be good if Conservative members and others at least recognised that austerity has an impact on public services, including libraries. I and my colleagues will not cease pointing that out to the Parliament and the public, given that that is why people voted to get rid of the Conservatives and believed that change was coming with Labour—which, sadly, it did not.
I can squeeze in question 7, but I need co-operation to have brief questions and answers.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 18 Sep 2024 →- Constitution, External Affairs and Culture, and Parliamentary Business Questions · 1
- Channel 4 (Production Outside England) Questions · 4
- Programme for Government (Arts and Culture) Questions · 11
- Youth Culture (Investment) (Cunninghame South) Questions · 7
- Relations with European Union (Discussions with United Kingdom Government) Questions · 4
- Built Heritage and Listed Buildings (Protection) Questions · 6
- Public Libraries (Support) Questions · 14
- Constitutional Policy and Strategy Questions · 5
- Police Scotland (Officer Numbers) Questions · 11
- Introduction of Domestic Abuse Register Questions · 6
- His Majesty’s Prison and Young Offenders Institution Stirling Questions · 11
- Antisocial Behaviour (Lothian) Questions · 7
- Sam Eljamel (Discussions with Police Scotland) Questions · 7
- E-bikes and E-scooters (Illegal Use) Questions · 4
- His Majesty’s Prison Highland (Cost and Completion) Questions · 6
- Creating a Modern, Diverse and Dynamic Scotland Debate · 139
- Business Motion Business motions · 25
- Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 2
- Decision Time Decision time · 28
- Independence Referendum (10th Anniversary) Members’ business · 34
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.