I thank Mr Findlay for that intervention. I agree with his sentiments.
Each one of us knows how the expenses system in the Parliament works. When we incur a cost, we all have to sign a declaration saying that expenses were properly incurred on parliamentary or constituency business. Michael Matheson must have made that declaration—indeed, we know that he did—and he did so fraudulently. The most generous interpretation that can be put on his behaviour is that he did not know when he signed that declaration how the roaming costs were incurred. However, either he knew that it was not a legitimate parliamentary expense or he should have made appropriate inquiries. He did not, and he induced the parliamentary authorities to pay £11,000 of taxpayers’ money that should not have been paid by refunding him costs that should have come out of his own pocket.
Better lawyers than I have already argued that that sequence of events amounts to a fraud on the public purse. That is a matter for the police, and not for the Parliament, but it illustrates the seriousness of the matter that we are dealing with and why nothing less than Michael Matheson’s resignation from the Parliament is appropriate as an outcome.
Earlier, we heard the Deputy First Minister’s defence that the money was repaid, as if that is an excuse for Mr Matheson’s behaviour. Yes, the money was repaid, but it was repaid only after the matter was publicly exposed. A thief who returns the stolen goods does not escape punishment in law.
This Parliament has agreed an unprecedented 27-day suspension and a 54-day loss of earnings but, astonishingly, the SNP members did not support any sanction against Mr Matheson. They could have amended the motion that is before us this afternoon with an alternative sanction, but they chose not to do so. They regarded him as somebody who should get off scot free.
That will be the end of the matter for Mr Matheson, as matters currently stand. As we have heard during the debate, had he been a Westminster MP, he would potentially face a recall petition, and I would not give much for his chances of re-election in a by-election in those circumstances.
We have no such mechanism here. Graham Simpson, who we heard from earlier, is bringing forward a member’s bill to bring a right of recall to this Parliament, but that is still at an early stage. If Michael Matheson were an honourable man, he would do the right thing and step down at this stage. As Willie Rennie said, he can always contest any subsequent by-election and seek the confidence of his constituents for re-election.
I have no personal animus against Michael Matheson. When he was a minister, I worked co-operatively with him on a number of issues, including lodging amendments to the Transport (Scotland) Bill to address the issue of private parking, and I always found him congenial and helpful to deal with. However, in acting in the way that he did on this matter, he has brought the Parliament into disrepute, and he needs to bear the consequences for that.
The point has already been made that, in any other workplace, Michael Matheson would have been sacked long ago for his actions. It is inconceivable that, in any private sector organisation or, for that matter, in much of the public sector, anyone who made a false claim for expenses of £11,000 would still be in a job. The Parliament should not hold itself to a lesser standard than that which applies to those who pay our wages. For those reasons, Michael Matheson should resign.
None of what has happened over the past few weeks reflects well on either the previous First Minister, Humza Yousaf, or the current one, John Swinney. John Swinney’s response to the decision of the standards committee to sanction Michael Matheson was not to support that decision or to recognise that Matheson deserved punishment but, rather, to launch a disgraceful attack on my colleague Annie Wells. As we know, that has led, in a totally unacceptable fashion, to social media abuse of a female member of this Parliament.
In the 27 pages of evidence that John Swinney submitted to the standards committee, there was just one reference to a social media post by Annie Wells. She was expressing an opinion on Michael Matheson’s wrongdoing, as she was quite entitled to do. As our well-respected former colleague, Andy Wightman of the Scottish Greens, said on Radio Scotland this morning,
“everyone and their dog had an opinion”
on Michael Matheson when the news broke about the scandal last year. Politicians are asked for—and freely express—opinions on matters in the news, and the idea that expressing an opinion means that Annie Wells’s role in the committee was inappropriate, is simply grasping at straws from a desperate First Minister who is determined to undermine the integrity of the Parliament in order to protect a political colleague whom he described as a friend.
In any event, Annie Wells’s comment was on the question of the guilt of Michael Matheson, not on what the appropriate sanctions should be, and the guilt of Michael Matheson has never been in doubt. His guilt was accepted by the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body even before the issue came to the standards committee. What Annie Wells did was adjudicate on the punishment, not on the question of guilt, and she should not be criticised for that. Had there been concerns about Annie Wells’s behaviour, that was properly a matter for the committee convener, and not for the First Minister.
We always hear from the First Minister and others about the need to show respect for this Parliament. However, here we have had the First Minister showing contempt for this Parliament and its institutions. SNP members always like to claim some sort of moral superiority over Westminster, but this whole episode has exposed the fact that they are prepared to engage in tawdry politicking and undermine the Parliament when it suits them in order to defend one of their own.
I was in this Parliament in 2008 when SNP members of the standards committee insisted on an inappropriate and unduly harsh punishment on the former Labour leader, Wendy Alexander, for what was a technical infringement of the rules on declaring interests at that time. Who voted for that punishment at that time? John Swinney did, Nicola Sturgeon did and—yes—Michael Matheson did. They did not complain about the process then, and they did not demand a review of the process, but now, when it is one of theirs in the firing line, they take a different stance. It is the most egregious of double standards.
I will leave the last word on this to Andy Wightman, who said last week, in response to comments from Michael Matheson complaining about the process:
“Straight out of the Nicola Sturgeon playbook. Smear Committee members undermine and discredit a Parliamentary Committee—all to save your own career. Scottish Parliament standards now hugely undermined.”
That is why Michael Matheson should go, and that is why we should support the motion this afternoon.