I thank members from across the chamber for their measured contributions, both during the amendment stage and, latterly, during the debate. Indeed, I thank them for their constructive engagement throughout the process over the past year. I am extremely grateful, and I think that the process that we have undertaken—even when there has not necessarily been agreement on the general principle of the bill—and the desire to work together show Parliament at its best. I think that the bill is stronger as a result. I agree with what Ross Greer said: it is a model of working whereby, in this era of minority government, we can effectively legislate and ensure that all views are reflected to the greatest extent possible.
I will turn to matters that members have raised during the debate momentarily, but at this stage I offer my sincere thanks to all those who have contributed to enabling the legislation to get to this stage. As has been touched on, the bill was first mooted back in 2019 through an agreement between the Scottish Green Party and the Scottish Government during the budget. I am very grateful for Green colleagues’ engagement throughout the process, both during and following the end of the Bute house agreement.
I am extremely grateful, in particular, to COSLA and to industry, which provided me and my officials with invaluable insight and expertise to ensure that what we have brought to Parliament as a bill, and the amendments that we have passed at stage 2 and stage 3, are generally additive and ensure that the legislation is the best that it possibly can be. I am particularly grateful to the range of industry bodies, including the STA and many others, for the dialogue that they have facilitated for the individual businesses that have taken time to engage directly with me and my officials as we have taken the process forward. That model is consistent with the new deal for business. For me, it is of the utmost importance, when we are dealing with any legislation, whether it be in the fiscal or regulatory domains that impact on business, that we bring to bear the lived experience and expertise of business. It is because of that engagement that we have been able to achieve legislation and to achieve what I think is a broad consensus at stage 3.
I also put on record my sincere thanks to my bill team, in particular to the bill team leader, Ben Haynes. The contribution of Scottish Government officials is outstanding across every area of policy, and I have been incredibly privileged to be supported by such a fantastic range of officials. They have played no small part in getting the bill to the stage that it has reached today.
I also pay tribute and thanks to my ministerial colleagues, including the Deputy First Minister, the Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Local Government, Ivan McKee, Richard Lochhead and Ben Macpherson, who, in previous roles, have had responsibility for the legislation and are directly accountable for its progress in getting to where it is today.
I turn to some of the individual issues that have been raised. I sincerely thank Miles Briggs for the way in which he lodged his amendments. I very much appreciate the sentiment and the intent that motivated the national exemptions that he brought forward. I reiterate my commitment—I hope that it was implicit, but I want to make it explicit—to continued engagement. Powers in the legislation allow for the introduction of national exemptions and, clearly, consideration of such exemptions will be a part of the statutory guidance. He made very important points.
I want to clarify that there is no inevitability that certain groups or categories of accommodation will be subject to a visitor levy. There is local discretion. Of course, any local authority that looks to introduce a visitor levy will be able to do so only following consultation not just with business and tourism organisations but with communities. The fact that there will be on-going engagement through the visitor levy forum provides an effective vehicle for ensuring that the voices of communities are represented. As we continue to monitor how the legislation is implemented, ministers’ doors will remain open for further engagement on issues of national exemption.
I recognise the points about variation. That is ultimately inevitable in any situation in which we seek to further empower local government. Throughout the process, I have sought to ensure that we can provide as much administrative consistency as possible between respective local authorities, while allowing for the policy flexibility to respond most effectively to the needs and assets of a particular area. That is extremely important.
I thank Liam McArthur for his contribution. I recognise the important issues that he has raised on a cruise ship levy. I reiterate the commitments that I made earlier. I recognise the particular importance of a cruise ship levy to his constituents and, indeed, to the constituents of other members who have a particular interest in how such a levy would be applicable to their area. Ministers remain committed to continued engagement in that area.
On the point about motorhomes and their impact, and a potential motorhome levy, which both Liam McArthur and Murdo Fraser raised, I reiterate my commitment to work and engage constructively. There are particular practical challenges—it is a multifaceted issue, as members appreciate, and I am sure that we all agree that a small minority of irresponsible users contribute directly to some of the issues that have arisen. However, I recognise the concern, and it is important that we continue to work constructively to identify what measures we can take forward in that regard.
A key issue that was raised by Daniel Johnson, Michael Marra and Murdo Fraser is the question of the overall economic, fiscal and regulatory environment in which accommodation providers and businesses in the wider visitor economy operate. I recognise that they are in a challenging environment. That is why requirements on consultation and engagement are at the heart of the bill, and why we have an expert group that is convened by VisitScotland, with industry and local government representation, to produce statutory guidance, with the Parliament and ministers being able to specify what that guidance will cover. That will be extremely important in ensuring that visitor levies, when being considered by local authorities in engagement with their communities, are proportionate and additive.
Fundamentally, as has been set out by the STA and others, if a visitor levy is implemented effectively by local authorities, it can be a force for good: it can promote economic growth and wealth creation; it can support entrepreneurship; and it can ensure that Scotland continues to maintain, grow and diversify that world-class tourism offering of which we are all, rightly, proud.