The principles of the bill are really important. What it seeks to do is key to delivering on the Promise and on our promises to young people. That is why my party—and the Parliament—voted for those principles at stage 1. However, as Roz McCall succinctly put it, the issue is not about the direction of travel but about the way in which we get there. As Martin Whitfield put it in an article today,
“this is yet another well-intentioned ... government bill that is incompatible with the situation on the ground.”
The Government has a concerning tendency to propose legislation that in principle is laudable yet in execution is utterly unworkable, is subject to legal challenge or has unintended consequences.
Yesterday, I raised the removal of sections 12 and 13. I shall not rehearse the arguments, but what is key is that the stage 1 report missed the issue. At stage 2, when I asked about restrictions on press freedom, the minister reassured the Education, Children and Young People Committee that she had “no concerns” at all. I asked whether she had taken legal advice, and she reassured us that she had taken legal advice on every section. However, yesterday, she removed sections 12 and 13, saying that she had been unaware of how prejudicial the original drafting was, because, basically, no one told her.
Leaving aside what the minister is suggesting about the legal advice that she was given, and the fact that surely the Government is responsible for thinking through the consequences of what it drafts, it is a fair point. The first report missed the fact that the Government had drafted a shocking and utterly unworkable clause, which the minister had not understood sufficiently to remove at stage 2. Had it gone through, it would have likely contravened the European convention on human rights and prevented the bill from operating.
This afternoon, we have heard that huge concerns remain about the bill and its implications, because it does not exist in a silo. Roz McCall said:
“The children’s hearings panel ... needs to embark on a massive recruitment drive of volunteers. ... Hundreds more social workers”
are also needed and
“We are in need of more foster carers.”
She told us, in powerful testimony, of the current capacity of social services.
Russell Findlay talked powerfully about the victim’s view and picked up on Victim Support Scotland’s submission that people who are harmed by 16 or 17-year-olds will have their rights to information and support removed by the bill.
We heard evidence that social workers support the principles and—like us—they want this to happen, but social work faces a huge turnover of staff. The bill will pass while providing no more money, leaving them to patch things together.
The fact is that years of Scottish National Party cuts to vital services mean that many of the changes that are proposed in the bill will not be able to be put into practice while Scotland’s local authorities and social work departments struggle with cuts to services. Michael Marra called their position “precarious”, and Pam Duncan-Glancy also picked up on that point. The finances are hugely important, and I am not convinced that any of us has confidence that they will be forthcoming—but they are not even the sole concern. Pam Duncan-Glancy also has the worry, which I share, that the system simply does not have the capacity to do what the bill aims to do, and therefore it will put more stress on the workforce.
Martin Whitfield picked up a process point. He told us that substantive amendments around the UNCRC were brought forward at stage 3. That is a fundamental change that was laid before the Parliament because something—that is, something else—seems to have been missed at an earlier stage. That worries me. What else might have been missed and not been picked up by the minister?
Parliament is supportive of the principles of the Children (Care and Justice) (Scotland) Bill. I think that I speak for us all when I say that we want those principles to be enacted. Stephanie Callaghan rightly reminded us that we all want to make Scotland the best place for young people to grow up in. However, member after member has warned Parliament, at the end of a very long process, that they do not have confidence that the bill is drafted in such a way that, as an act, it will achieve that. The minister assured us at the start that the bill that she proposes today shows what can be achieved with good will, but good will does not an effective and robust law make.
Stakeholders and speakers have made strong representations that effective and robust law is not what is being presented here, and that the bill will not achieve the principles that we all want. In fact, the unintended and negative consequences might well be considerable. Accordingly, I will not vote for what I think will prove to be an unworkable, flawed bill that will ultimately let down those who we all want to protect and that will fail to deliver the principles that we all want.