I thank Willie Rennie for bringing this important debate to the chamber. He shares with me a belief in the catchment management approach, which I have been advocating for a number of years now.
We all understand the significant impacts of the flooding events that have had such a devastating effect on the safety and livelihoods of those who live in flood-hit communities across Scotland. Over the years, that has included those in my constituency in areas such as Hawick and Newcastleton, as well as events such as storm Arwen in November 2021, and storm Babet—and, most recently, storm Gerrit—in 2023. Every major flooding event has an utterly devastating effect on local communities, and that is why each and every one of us is in the chamber tonight.
Although flooding itself is not preventable, our preparation has to be much better. We cannot afford to lose any further housing stock or key food-producing land, and we cannot afford to let our salmon stocks become extinct, which can happen as a result of not only flooding but drought. Yesterday, I met representatives of the Tay Ghillies Association in Blairgowrie. They are concerned that climate change is bringing significant droughts in late spring and summer, causing extremely low flows in our rivers and tributaries and having a significant effect on salmon spawning grounds. It seems ridiculous that we cannot get it right; sometimes we have too much rain, and not enough at others.
I agree with what Willie Rennie said about Government initiatives to mitigate the risks of flooding—so far, it appears that it is all just talk. We know that the words from the Scottish Government have been fairly hollow so far, and its pledges have been lost in a vacuous echo chamber. Sadly, communities have suffered as a result of what the Scottish Government has not done. It has been wholly unprepared for the flooding events and, with each storm, there is another stark reminder of the shortcomings of what it is doing.
The SNP might say that flood prevention schemes have taken time to develop and construct. I do not dispute that point, but the party has been in power since 2007. Of the 42 formal flood protection schemes that were proposed from 2016 to 2021, only 15 have been completed, with an overspend of £25.8 million as of January 2024.
However, that overspend pales in comparison to the estimated overspend on the remaining projects that are still under development. Striking examples include an estimated overspend of £87 million in Musselburgh, £59.4 million in Stirling and £308.5 million in Grangemouth. At what point will the Scottish Government admit that its current plan is not working? That is why the motion before us is important: the Government is failing to deliver a coherent plan to mitigate the risks and protect residents and vulnerable species, and it is leaving our flood-prone rural communities in the dark.
In its 2021 manifesto, the SNP pledged to tackle flooding by ensuring
“that trees, woodlands and natural resources play a key role in flood prevention schemes”,
but this year’s budget shows that agri-environment climate scheme funding to farmers has been cut by £17.6 million. That leaves farmers without that key support, and unable to be part of the solution.
In response, in February, the Cabinet Secretary for Rural Affairs, Land Reform and Islands outlined in the chamber the Scottish Government’s commitment to considering flood prevention “in the round”. I would like it if the Cabinet Secretary for Wellbeing Economy, Net Zero and Energy were able, if possible, to update members on Mairi Gougeon’s commitment to hold a meeting with key stakeholders, regulators and farmers, which she said was taking place in March. I would welcome an update on that.
I welcome the calls to explore the benefits of a regional catchment management approach to flood mitigation, as stated in the motion. Such an approach utilises both local and expert knowledge to deliver a sustainable plan, tailored to what is needed, with amazing projects such as the Eddleston water project, led by the Tweed Forum, and the Findhorn catchment project shining examples of natural flood management.
I do not believe that the Government is taking the right approach. The expected costs of physical flood defences are close to £1 billion. Natural flood defences can provide a real—and, as Michael Marra said, holistic—alternative; indeed, Roger Crofts, formerly of Scottish Natural Heritage, believes that the concrete-based approach is ineffective and out of date. On that note, we need to ensure that we protect communities, our endangered species and biodiversity, and that the Government delivers meaningful protection for those communities.
17:26