Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Local Authority (Capital Finance and Accounting) (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2024 [Draft]

Tuesday 5 March 2024 Local Government, Housing and Planning Committee About 10:45–11:45 Subordinate legislation 34 contributions · 9 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

34 contributions
Ariane Burgess Green The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

The next item on our agenda is an evidence-taking session on the Local Authority (Capital Finance and Accounting) (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2024 with Tom Arthur, Minister for Community Wealth and Public Finance. Mr Arthur is joined for this item by Scottish Government officials Elanor Davies, who is head of local authority accounting, and Susan Robb, who is a solicitor.

I welcome the minister and his officials to the meeting and invite him to make an opening statement.

Tom Arthur SNP The Minister for Community Wealth and Public Finance · Renfrewshire South
link

Thank you, convener, and good morning, committee. With your permission, convener, I will just take a bit of time to explain what I appreciate is potentially a complex set of regulations.

In 2016, regulations were introduced to provide greater flexibility to local authorities to ensure that both current and future taxpayers are charged for their share of the capital expenditure costs of public assets that are used to deliver services.

Perhaps I can briefly explain the nature of statutory accounting arrangements. Accounting standards require depreciation to be charged against revenue to reflect the cost of the capital expenditure for an asset, such as a school, as it is used over the term that it will be used for—in other words, its useful life. The 2016 regulations replaced the requirements of accounting standards with an annual charge against revenue in the form of loans fund repayments, to recognise the costs of capital expenditure to be financed from borrowing over the term for which the expenditure is expected to provide benefit to the community.

The aim of both accounting standards and statutory arrangements is to accurately and transparently reflect the costs of capital expenditure to acquire an asset over the period during which the asset will be used. The 2016 regulations permit local authorities greater freedom to choose the term over which to charge the costs of capital expenditure against revenue, known as the repayment of loans fund advances, and to vary the period and pattern of such charges. The intention is to allow local authorities to more accurately align the period of loans fund repayment—and therefore recourse to taxpayers—with the period over which the asset will benefit the community.

However, a review of local authority financial data shows that, since 2019, local authorities have been significantly reducing their on-going annual revenue provision to meet long-term borrowing costs, despite increasing external debt, and have been deferring a substantial proportion of capital financing costs to future years. That approach has been taken as a solution to meet affordability challenges and address budget gaps instead of allocating more fairly the cost of the capital expenditure to taxpayers. That is not in keeping with the spirit of the statutory accounting arrangements, which are intended to ensure adequate provision from revenue to meet debt financing costs and an equitable charge to taxpayers for the use of the asset for which the capital expenditure has been incurred.

Furthermore, such an approach creates financial risk, as deferred repayments will have to be met in the future. Rising demand for public services and the prolonged impact of UK Government austerity on the public finances, along with economic and inflationary pressures, increase the risks that local authorities might find it difficult to service their increasing capital financing commitments. Deferring provisions to meet such commitments further exacerbates an already challenging longer-term financial outlook. The committee will not need me to draw its attention to the situation in England and the stark evidence of the outcome of such accounting practices in English councils.

We agree entirely with the evidence that I know you will have heard from local authorities that authorities in Scotland are neither borrowing excessively nor borrowing for the purposes of commercial investment, but the fact is that the practice of reversing debt financing costs and deferring those costs to future years, which has contributed significantly to the financial collapse of a number of local authorities in England, is being adopted in Scotland. I point out for information and context a House of Commons research briefing that was published last month that states that the financial collapse of Thurrock Borough Council stemmed from “two principal causes”: not only the loss of value of its assets, but a failure to make “sufficient ... revenue provision” to meet its debt repayments.

The briefing also states:

“a major cause of Slough’s financial difficulties was its failure to make sufficient ... revenue provision in its accounts to repay”

its debts. Moreover,

“Woking issued a section 114 notice”

in

“June 2023”,

highlighting inadequate minimum revenue provision since 2007-08 as a key contributor to the local authority’s significant financial challenges.

In 2020, the UK Government took steps to amend equivalent statutory arrangements for England and Wales to prohibit exactly those accounting practices that continue to be adopted in Scotland—namely to prevent local authorities from reversing costs incurred in previous years as a means of increasing reserves, and to prevent the deferral of debt repayments to future years as an affordability measure.

Although our situation and the situation in England are not identical, the amendment regulations simply align Scotland with the improvements that have been made to the statutory framework for England and Wales. Contrary to the suggestion that the regulations have been rushed through in some way, the need for a review of statutory capital financing and accounting was identified in 2019 and confirmed in the resource spending review in 2022. Despite that, local government has resisted any such review and has requested successive delays over the past two years. The committee might be aware that we consulted on a number of other reforms in late 2023, but in the light of the valid feedback from respondents, we wish to take more time to consider the implications of those reforms before bringing them forward.

No specific concerns were raised over the amendments that are being taken forward at this time, and although the UK Government intervened reactively, we are intervening proactively to protect Scotland’s public finances from risks such as the outcomes that we have seen in England. I therefore consider it to be important to deliver that alignment as soon as possible.

In summary, the amendment regulations will more clearly articulate the policy intent of the 2016 regulations and will harmonise statutory arrangements not only with accounting standards but with England and Wales, to better ensure an equitable charge to current and future taxpayers over a period that is commensurate with the benefit that an asset provides to the community.

With that, convener, I conclude. Thank you.

Ariane Burgess Green The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Thanks very much, minister, and thank you, too, for taking the time to lay things out in quite a bit of detail and for the work that you have been doing on the regulations.

I would be interested to understand why the Scottish Government feels that regulations are needed now, given that the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities has stated that

“there is no requirement for a review of capital accounting”

and that, during last year’s consultation, directors of finance said that

“no clear rationale for this review has been provided to support the proposed changes.”

11:45

Tom Arthur SNP Renfrewshire South
link

The case for the action that we are taking is underlined by the point that I made about the need to be proactive. I touched on the situation in which some local authorities in England have found themselves, and I am sure that no one at this table would want that to befall our local authorities. It is important to ensure that accounting practices are consistent with the standards that we all expect. The Scottish Government and the Scottish ministers have an important role, as stewards of the public finances, in ensuring that there is an appropriate regulatory environment to facilitate the standards that we seek.

As I touched on, the issue has been given careful consideration over a considerable period. That goes back to 2019, when some practices that caused concern became evident. In the resource spending review, we signposted our intention to take this action. We have consulted and, where valid points and concerns were raised, we have not taken forward the relevant measures in the amendment regulations.

We recognise that we have a responsibility to ensure that accounting practices are consistent with what is required to provide long-term stability and transparency in the public finances. Ultimately, that is the reason that underpins introduction of the amendment regulations.

Miles Briggs Con Lothian
link

Good morning, minister and officials.

Not for the first time, we have heard concerns from COSLA and local authorities, which are unhappy about the short period of time that was allocated for consultation on the measure. It was held in December for just four weeks. In the spirit of the Verity house agreement, what consideration has been given to that issue?

Tom Arthur SNP Renfrewshire South
link

I have two points to make on that. The first, which goes back to my previous answer and my introductory remarks, is about the timelines and the signalling of our intent. Secondly, on the consultation, a consultation that is just with local government will typically be around two weeks. My officials will correct me if I am wrong, but I think that the consultation in this case was four weeks, so it was more than the normal time.

We have consulted in a way that is consistent with how we normally engage with local government. More generally, the context in which the consultation was undertaken was that there had been extended engagement over a period in which we had indicated our concerns.

Stephanie Callaghan SNP Uddingston and Bellshill
link

I put on record that I was a councillor at South Lanarkshire Council until 2022. I remember the information sessions and the intense scrutiny from councillors across the board when we looked at reprofiling loans fund repayments.

I have a few questions. What assessment has been made of the extent to which local authorities have used the 2016 flexibilities? It would be helpful if you could put a number on that, if that is known. Do you have a figure for the amount by which council reserves have been boosted across the country?

Tom Arthur SNP Renfrewshire South
link

I ask Elanor Davies to come in on those specific points and provide some additional information.

Elanor Davies Scottish Government
link

I apologise—I am just looking for the values. I had them to hand, previously.

The local authority budget reports for 2023-2024 and 2024-2025 show that many local authorities have applied the flexibilities in the statutory regulations to defer the revenue provision for capital financing to future years. We have seen, in the local financial returns and the statistics that we capture, that revenue provision to meet borrowing costs has been declining since about 2018-19. At 31 March 2022, which is the most recent point for which we have data, the all-Scotland balance for the loans funds was £16.9 billion. Comparing the loans fund repayments, which are required by statute, against accounting standards, we find that the loans fund repayments that have been made account for only 30 per cent of the costs that would have been charged if local authorities were required to apply accounting standards and charge depreciation. If, year on year, 70 per cent of the costs are being deferred to future years, that represents a significant future sustainability risk.

Stephanie Callaghan SNP Uddingston and Bellshill
link

Do you have the figures for how many councils have taken that step?

Elanor Davies Scottish Government
link

I apologise—I do not have a note of the number of councils, but I can certainly provide that.

Stephanie Callaghan SNP Uddingston and Bellshill
link

If you could send that on to us, that would be really helpful.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

Good morning, minister, and your colleagues. The regulations apply only to new loans; they do not apply retrospectively. Why did you make that decision if the extent of the problem is as described by Ms Davies?

Tom Arthur SNP Renfrewshire South
link

The regulations are a product of engagement and will help to provide clarity and certainty going forward, as well as the consistency with accounting standards that we want.

Elanor might want to provide some more detail on the process and consideration regarding potential retrospectivity.

Elanor Davies Scottish Government
link

The regulations will not have retrospective effect. Given that the provisions will be introduced only from the point at which the regulations come into force, which will be 1 April 2024, we cannot ask local authorities to consider decisions that have already been taken. Most local authorities have already applied the flexibility to their existing loans fund advances, so we are instead making sure that that cannot be applied subsequently.

Mark Griffin Lab Central Scotland
link

You set out some of the financial challenges that have resulted in this flexibility being used in England, which are well documented. What assessment has the Government carried out of the financial health of local authorities in Scotland that have used this flexibility and of whether that has put any of them at risk of going down the same road as the English local authorities that you mentioned?

Tom Arthur SNP Renfrewshire South
link

As I touched on in my earlier remarks, there are differences between the circumstances in Scotland and those in England. I sought to be clear about that, as I did not want to suggest that there is full equivalence. However, on the specific point around the accounting practices, that is an area of concern that we can address.

We recognise that, across the public sector, public finances are creating significant challenges and pressures. We have embarked on broader process of engagement with local government through the Verity house agreement and the commitment to developing a fiscal framework. The local government budget settlement for 2024-25 represents a greater percentage of ministers’ discretionary spend than there was in previous years’ budgets.

Elanor Davies might wish to comment on the specific aspects of the health of local government finance compared with what we have seen in England.

Elanor Davies Scottish Government
link

It is an on-going piece of work. We are reviewing the financial health and resilience of local authorities. I could certainly provide further information to the committee when that work is complete.

Mark Griffin Lab Central Scotland
link

In advance of that work being completed, does the Government have any concerns about the risk of financial failure of any particular Scottish local authority?

Tom Arthur SNP Renfrewshire South
link

Specific roles and responsibilities are exercised by the Accounts Commission, for example, in assessing the performance and financial management of local authorities. We recognise the challenges that local authorities are facing, but we are in a different set of circumstances than certain local authorities in England were in because of some of the decisions that were taken by individual local authorities. However, as I highlighted in my earlier remarks, a contributing factor was the particular approaches around accounting that we are discussing, and the way in which they were taken in England. The United Kingdom Government reacted to that; we are getting ahead of the situation by being proactive. We are ensuring that we are not creating a situation in which, over time, the level of risk increases and starts to present long-term sustainability challenges.

On this particular point, we are taking proactive action to align with the situation in England and Wales. Indeed, the action is prospective—to answer Mr Coffey’s question, there will be no retrospective effect.

Marie McNair SNP Clydebank and Milngavie
link

I declare an interest, in that I was a councillor in West Dunbartonshire Council until 2022.

Good morning, minister and officials. The consultation in December included other proposals that are not being taken forward at this time, and COSLA has concerns that the Government still intends to do further work on those. What are the Scottish Government’s plans on those proposals and on any wider review of capital finance accounting?

Tom Arthur SNP Renfrewshire South
link

We will continue to engage constructively with local government on those matters but, as I touched on earlier, we in the Government have an obligation in the broader stewardship of the public finances and in assuring that there is an appropriate regulatory environment.

Elanor Davies may be able to provide more detail on the other elements that were consulted on and the work that is on-going.

Elanor Davies Scottish Government
link

We have already had discussions with local government and have suggested a collaborative working group. We have also provided assurance that any further amendments would not be introduced before 2027, so that there will be time to give due consideration and reflect them in longer-term financial plans.

Pam Gosal Con West Scotland
link

Good morning, minister and officials.

COSLA has raised concerns that creating additional administrative burdens on local authorities and their auditors is an unnecessary risk and an unnecessary additional burden. Have you discussed how that might impact on local authorities, and the best way in which to support it to deal with any additional administrative burdens?

Tom Arthur SNP Renfrewshire South
link

As has been touched on, we have consulted. The regulations are published subject to parliamentary scrutiny, and we will continue to engage with local government and monitor the situation. Should any particular unanticipated issues arise, we would, of course, want to engage with local government constructively to remedy those.

Pam Gosal Con West Scotland
link

Given that COSLA has raised that concern, are you doing any work to help councils with that additional administrative burden?

Tom Arthur SNP Renfrewshire South
link

As I said, if local authorities want to work with the Government on particular points in addressing any of their potential concerns, or other issues that could arise, we want that to happen.

I touched on the areas that we consulted on that we are not taking forward. We have taken a constructive approach to that with the establishment of a joint working group and the deferring of any further changes to 2027 at the earliest. That demonstrates the Government’s balanced and proportionate approach. It is very much in the spirit of constructive partnership.

For the reasons that we have set out, we believe that we have to take forward these regulations at this time, given the significant risks that could ensue if we did not do so.

Pam Gosal Con West Scotland
link

Does the Scottish Government believe that it would be worth its while to clarify the rules that relate to council capital loans and the economic assessments of the value and sustainability of such loans?

Tom Arthur SNP Renfrewshire South
link

If local authorities would welcome clarification on specific areas of, or any matter in, the broader regulatory environment, we would want to engage on that constructively. I ask Elanor Davies whether she has a response to any specific points in that area.

Elanor Davies Scottish Government
link

Yes. Those rules will be clarified. Statutory guidance will be issued in support of the regulations, which will set out clearly how local authorities are to account for loans fund advances and repayments.

Ariane Burgess Green The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

That concludes our questions in that evidence session. I appreciate the minister’s and officials’ provision of information.

We turn to agenda item 7, which is consideration of the motion on the instrument. I invite the minister to move motion S6M-12003.

Motion moved,

That the Local Government, Housing and Planning Committee recommends that the Local Authority (Capital Finance and Accounting) (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2024 be approved.—Tom Arthur

Motion agreed to.

Ariane Burgess Green The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

The committee will publish, in the coming days, a report setting out its recommendations on the instrument.

At the start of the meeting, we agreed to take the next item in private. I therefore close the public part of the meeting.

11:59 Meeting continued in private until 12:30.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report

No recorded division on this motion that day: decisions taken without a vote are not in the divisions feed.

  1. 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 41
  3. 10:45 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 34

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.