At the height of the Covid pandemic, rarely a day passed without constituents raising with me their heartbreaking experiences of not being able to visit loved ones in care homes, because we did not get our act together on testing; social care packages being removed; people feeling pressure to sign “do not attempt resuscitation” forms; care home staff being frightened because they had no personal protective equipment; and the appalling death rate among people in later life. The human rights of older people were cast aside when the big decisions were being made.
Nicola Sturgeon promised to build from the Covid crisis the positive legacy of a national care service. It was to be a chance to put social care on the same level as our NHS, to create parity, and to ensure that services were fully funded and properly staffed, met national standards, were delivered locally and were accountable to local people.
However, the Scottish Government has squandered that promise with the bill. We know that it is obsessed with framework bills—or, rather, empty-frame bills—but, even by its standards, the bill is ill judged, ill thought through and incoherent.
The bill has been almost universally criticised. For example, Unison, Unite, the Royal College of Nursing Scotland, the Royal College of Physicians and many others support the creation of a national care service but are opposed to the bill’s provisions. Care providers and people with lived experience, Audit Scotland and the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities have all been scathing, and so, too, have been the Parliament’s committees.
The Local Government, Housing and Planning Committee called for the submission of a full business case before the bill was voted on, but that has not happened; the Delegated Powers and Law Reform Committee said that the bill undermined the role of Parliament; and the Education, Children and Young People Committee slammed moves to centralise children’s services that are still on the cards. The Finance and Public Administration Committee said that the lack of a credible financial memorandum breached the Parliament’s standing orders. As Jackie Baillie said earlier, that committee has looked at the bill twice and it still does not believe the numbers. Even the Health, Social Care and Sport Committee, in its watered-down stage 1 report, is unclear about how the Government’s national care service would operate in practice.
It is no wonder that that is the case. Private profiteering from big care home owners, inadequate funding, high vacancy rates, low pay, poor terms and conditions and the absence of sectoral collective bargaining have all been ignored in the bill and ignored, too, by the minister during the debate.
There is a lack of detail, big questions remain unanswered and many issues are unaddressed. Common Weal’s briefing to MSPs highlights several glaring examples of that, and I will mention just a few. The briefing says that there is no clear purpose statement that sets out the need
“for creating a national care service in the first place”
and that there are
“no provisions for how resources will be determined or allocated”.
Common Weal also says that there is little clarity on who will be responsible for delivering or enforcing the crucial human rights-based approach, nothing on transitional arrangements and little on fair work principles, including national terms and conditions.
Despite that, the SNP and Greens, as in a 1960s movie, are determined to carry on regardless, but there is nothing funny about proceeding with a bill that is so fundamentally flawed. If the Government was serious about salvaging the wreck and building consensus, it would have published its planned amendments before today’s debate.
Yesterday, the bill should have been referred back to the Health, Social Care and Sport Committee to revisit stage 1 and properly scrutinise the amendments and to allow those of us who are not on the committee to debate what might be fundamental changes before we vote on the bill’s principles. Either the amendments do not exist or the Government knows that they will not allay the legitimate concerns. It is not good enough for ministers to slip out an operating model that no one has seen, never mind scrutinised, ahead of the debate.
Meanwhile, the crisis that is engulfing our social care continues. When Age Scotland wrote to the cabinet secretary recently, it rightly said that older people
“cannot wait for the delivery of the National Care Service”
to fix a care system in which delayed discharge continues unabated, people are struggling to get a care assessment, more and more care homes are closing—one a week, according to Scottish Care—and older people are stuck in hospital because of a lack of carers. Ivan McKee said that about 160 civil servants are working on the bill. That is about the same as the number of vacancies in the care sector for home care workers in Dumfries and Galloway. The Covid crisis has been replaced by a care crisis. We need action now—not in four years’ time—on matters including Anne’s law and the right to breaks.
The SNP and Greens have cynically chosen to tie people’s rights to see loved ones in care homes, as well as the right to respite, to this roundly rejected bill. It is simply untrue to argue that those rights can be delivered only through the bill. The Government should get on with fulfilling its promise to families who were badly let down during the pandemic.
The mishandling of the bill has been a complete distraction from delivering on those and other social care issues, but it is symbolic of the Scottish Government’s approach to policy and legislation over the past 16 years, which is to issue a press release full of hyperbole, dismiss stakeholders’ concerns, steamroller legislation through Parliament and leave the details until later. The sad thing is that that impacts on people’s lives. It means that vulnerable members of our society—mainly older people—who need support will not get it.
The Scottish Government’s so-called national care service plans were launched to much fanfare and were described as the biggest public sector reform since devolution. Parallels were even drawn with the creation of the NHS after the second world war, but just saying something in a press release does not make it so. The creation of the NHS in 1945 was real public sector reform. It replaced a broken private healthcare system with a universal, comprehensive service that is free at the point of delivery. It had a transformational impact on working people’s lives and still does today. The SNP’s plans are pale in comparison and, to be frank, the bill is not worthy of the title “National Care Service”.
16:28