I thank MSPs across the chamber for supporting the motion to allow the debate to take place. Before I get into the substantive points of the motion, I will give some background on how my office became so heavily involved in this particular matter.
As we know, McClure Solicitors, which was founded in Greenock in 1853, went into administration in 2021. The Glasgow-based firm Jones Whyte then took on the roughly 100,000 matters that McClure had on its books; some people had multiple matters. That meant that anyone who needed to gain access to their documents would need to contact Jones Whyte. They could choose to stay with Jones Whyte or go to any other solicitor of their choice.
When McClure ceased trading, there was not a vast amount of press coverage to read, in particular with regard to how the situation would impact former clients. That occurred during the Covid-19 pandemic. I believe that 84 jobs were secured when Jones Whyte took over the good will, work in progress and certain assets of McClure, including all wills, powers of attorney and trusts.
I was aware that McClure was no more, but the matter had not gained much news coverage or generated many emails to my inbox. However, as of last summer, that changed. An increasing number of people started to contact my office, likely spurred on by the growing knowledge that the firm had gone out of business, more national news coverage, specifically from Katie Hunter at BBC Scotland, and more and more people with trusts receiving letters from Jones Whyte.
I understand from discussions with Jones Whyte that, although there may, quite rightly, be an expectation that former McClure clients should have been notified by now, Jones Whyte is simply not able to do that en masse. The firm is making its way through the files as quickly as it can, and focusing on trusts in the first instance. However, Jones Whyte was clear that anyone who has business with McClure should contact it, and it will do all that it can to help.
Once again, for clarity, I note that there is no requirement for former McClure clients to use Jones Whyte’s services in the future. If those former clients want their legal documents to be reviewed, they can instruct Jones Whyte to do that, or they can ask for their documents to be returned to them or to another lawyer of their choice.
As I learned more about the issue, I arranged meetings with interested parties, including the Law Society of Scotland, the Scottish Legal Complaints Commission and the Minister for Victims and Community Safety, and I have spoken to several solicitors and many constituents. I put on record my thanks to the SLCC and its chief executive, Neil Stevenson, for engaging with my office as I have attempted to assist constituents who have been affected. Neil attended two public meetings that I held in my Greenock and Inverclyde constituency to explain to former McClure clients what the SLCC can and cannot do with regard to any support or redress.
The first event that I hosted sold out and, given the level of contact that I was receiving from constituents, it became clear that another one was required. Across two meetings, more than 270 constituents gained a seat to put questions directly to the SLCC and to me. After the last meeting, I have had requests to do a third meeting, with lawyers present to answer legal questions. I am working through the legal ramifications and risks of doing that.
Although both meetings were for former McClure clients, they were held not specifically to discuss McClure Solicitors, but to provide information about the main route that former clients have for recourse if they believe that they have a complaint to make about McClure, its staff or any other lawyer.
I know that some of my constituents have already had complaints upheld by the SLCC and have had compensation awarded. That is why I have been so keen to raise awareness of the issue. It is also why I was keen to bring to the chamber a members’ business debate. I am aware that it is not only my constituents who have been affected by the situation. I have no doubt that there will be former McClure clients who will find out about the firm closing down only from watching the debate or from any subsequent press coverage as a result of it.
It is clear that something went very wrong at McClure Solicitors, and that is why we are here today. Thousands of people across the United Kingdom spent significant sums of money with McClure, in the expectation that they would not have to pay for any legal work like that again. For many, however, that will not be the reality. Thousands of people are now having to spend additional sums of money to have McClure partners removed from their trusts. Although I understand that that may involve a cost to the trustee who is being removed, I would ask all those individuals whether they believe that, morally, they should be taking a fee.
I also understand that there is nothing wrong at all with solicitors being named as trustees on trusts. However, I believe that it is more commonplace for a law firm itself, as opposed to individual lawyers, to be named on trusts. If that had been the case with McClure—although I believe that it started to do that in later years—more people may have been in a different situation today.
I turn to what can be done as we go forward. At the second public meeting, a constituent suggested that the Scottish Government should create an organisation to review people’s documentation in order to help them to determine what action, if any, to take next. Most of the people are not legally trained and will have already spent many hundreds—if not thousands—of pounds on documentation that may or may not be fit for purpose. That idea is welcome, but I do not know where the solicitors would come from to staff such a body, as trust lawyers are specialists and most will already be in employment. Those who are currently in training may not possess the relevant expertise, and some who are retired may not want to get involved. Nevertheless, if the Scottish Government could consider that suggestion, I know that that would be appreciated.
I believe that an inquiry should be held in the future. I know that some MSPs have echoed that call. However, I make it clear that I do not think that an inquiry at this point would be beneficial, as the current focus must be on helping people. The fact that not every trust will have been reviewed indicates to me that any inquiry in the short term would be premature. It would also divert time on the part of solicitors who are dealing with many of the McClure cases that would otherwise be spent on helping people now. That said, we need an inquiry to be held in the future in order to drill down into what happened at McClure leading up to the administration—not a fishing expedition that looks at everything and anything, but a focused inquiry.
Constituents have made many claims about their documentation—I have a very short list of those claims here. Those include claims that powers of attorney were not lodged with the Office of the Public Guardian in Scotland, despite the work being paid for; that trusts were in the wrong name or other details were wrong; and that clients were not properly advised as to what a trust is, why they might want one, and what the future implications for them would be. Some have even suggested that trusts may have been set up for relatives who lacked capacity, and that trusts had not been registered appropriately with HM Revenue and Customs and the land register of Scotland. The reviewing of the documents will be vital in substantiating those claims—or not—ahead of any inquiry.
I accept that Parliament cannot pass legislation retrospectively to fix past issues, but we can learn from what has happened. The Government has already introduced bills before the Parliament, including the Trusts and Succession (Scotland) Bill, which was passed in December; the Regulation of Legal Services (Scotland) Bill, which passed stage 1 last week; and the Judicial Factors (Scotland) Bill, which the Delegated Powers and Law Reform Committee will be scrutinising from late April. Those bills are important, as they will strengthen the regulatory regime within which law firms operate. However, as I indicated last week in the debate on the Regulation of Legal Services (Scotland) Bill, I believe that an inquiry into what happened at McClure will ultimately lead to more lessons being learned and, potentially, further reform.
During my 17 years as an MSP, no other single issue has dominated my case load and my inbox as this one has. Thousands of my constituents are affected, as are many more people UK-wide. I will continue to do whatever I can for my constituents, and I encourage anyone who has been affected to contact their MSP, or their MP if they live elsewhere in the UK.