To ask the Scottish Government, in light of the announcement from the United Kingdom Government that it plans to ban single-use vapes to protect children’s health, whether it will outline what action is being taken in Scotland. (S6T-01768)
Official Report · Chamber
Single-use Vapes
Topical Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Jenni Minto SNP 5
- Emma Harper SNP 3
- Carol Mochan Lab 1
- Gillian Mackay Green 1
- Alison Johnstone 1
The record
11 contributions
link
The Scottish Government was the first Government in the UK to commit to taking action on single-use vapes, so I was delighted to announce yesterday that we plan to introduce a ban on single-use vapes, alongside raising the age at which people can be sold tobacco and restricting vape flavours and packaging, in order to protect children and young people, public health and the environment. That will help us to create a generation free from tobacco addiction, tackle youth vaping and take us closer to a tobacco-free generation by 2030, in line with our “Tobacco and Vaping Framework”, which was published in November.
We continue to work with the UK Government, the Welsh Government and the Northern Ireland Executive to take forward the plans across the four nations.
I have been really concerned by the dramatic rise in levels of youth vaping, given the evidence from experts, including physicians and ASH Scotland, on the health impact of e-cigarettes and vaping and the negative impact of nicotine on young people.
As the founder and, now, the co-convener of the Parliament’s cross-party group on lung health, I recently heard from a mother how her school-age daughter has experienced anxiety, aggression, agitation, depression, withdrawal and shortness of breath since starting vaping. She has also missed school. What steps will be taken to minimise the health impacts of youth vaping, given the announced ban on single-use vapes?
link
I recognise the issues that Emma Harper has raised, having met some fathers to talk about exactly those issues. The Scottish Government has already been taking action to address the issues, as we committed to doing in the programme for government.
This month, we laid a Scottish statutory instrument in the Parliament to enable provisions in the Health (Tobacco, Nicotine etc and Care) (Scotland) Act 2016 to be enacted, including the ability to tighten rules on the advertising and promotion of vaping products.
In December 2023, we launched our “Take Hold” marketing campaign, which educated parents, carers and children about the dangers of vaping and about the harms and risks of nicotine addiction. We have been hearing very positive information about the campaign’s reach. A key aspect of the campaign involved speaking to children in order to understand what they would like us, as policy makers, to do. I spent a very informative morning discussing exactly that with the Children in Scotland advisory group.
In addition to the health concerns, there are clear short-term and long-term environmental impacts of single-use vapes, with communities, including communities in Dumfries and Galloway, being blighted by them, as they are dumped and discarded on our streets. Does the minister agree with me and charities such as Keep Scotland Beautiful that the ban on single-use vapes will benefit our environment, as well as keeping our communities safer and cleaner?
link
Absolutely. On Friday, I had the privilege of joining one of the classes at Sunnyside primary school in Alloa, which is part of the Children’s Parliament. The children complained to me that they are seeing vapes in spaces for children, which really upset them.
Last year, the Scottish Government commissioned an urgent review of the environmental impact of single-use vapes. The review found that up to 26 million disposable vapes were consumed and thrown away in Scotland in just one year. An estimated 10 per cent of them were littered, and more than half were incorrectly disposed of. The ban will tackle the detrimental impact that single-use vapes have on our environment, local communities and young people.
link
Can the minister set out timescales for the introduction of the ban and what the associated repercussions are expected to be if the ban is not complied with? How will the Scottish Government work with shop owners and others who sell such products so that they can safely dispose of their stocks?
link
As I said in my first answer, we are working from a four-nations perspective and we await the legislation from the UK Government, with which we, as a Government, have been working closely. We already have legislation on enforcement, but we will be looking to tighten it as best we can.
We must ensure that disposal is done in the most environmentally friendly way, which is why I am working closely with my colleague Lorna Slater.
link
I place on record my thanks to the campaigners and organisations involved, and to the Daily Record for working with me and other MSPs in campaigning for the ban. The proposals are a huge victory for them, and I thank the Government for the positive conversations that I have had with it throughout the campaign.
As we move forward, other tactics might emerge in the evolution of vapes. What conversations is the minister having with colleagues across the UK on how we can anticipate some of the changes and ensure that any legislation that we introduce appropriately tackles any measures that we might see?
link
I echo Gillian Mackay’s thanks to those who campaigned for a ban on disposable vapes.
We aim to implement a ban at the earliest opportunity in order to ensure that the health and environmental benefits are realised as soon as possible. As I have said, we propose to align the coming-into-force dates of our regulations with those of the other three nations, where feasible, to provide certainty for businesses and consumers. We will legislate separately in Scotland to enact a ban, as it will be taken forward using powers under the Environmental Protection Act 1990 that are devolved to the Scottish ministers.
That concludes topical questions. I will allow a moment for those on the front benches to organise themselves for the next item of business.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 30 Jan 2024 →- Time for Reflection Time for reflection · 2
- Professor Sam Eljamel (Independent Clinical Review) Questions · 12
- Single-use Vapes Questions · 11
- European Union Debate · 124
- Committee Announcement (Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee) Procedure · 2
- Motion without Notice Business motions · 1
- Decision Time Decision time · 21
- Michael “Mick” McGahey Members’ business · 16
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.