Before I take the opportunity to respond on behalf of the Scottish Government, I thank Rhoda Grant for lodging today’s important motion and members for contributing to an excellent discussion. There have been brilliant speeches from Emma Harper, Murdo Fraser, Kate Forbes, Richard Leonard, Jamie Halcro Johnston, Beatrice Wishart and Stephen Kerr, which have contributed to building a consensus through the Parliament on the importance of banks to local communities and on the social responsibility that banks have to those communities.
The Scottish Government is acutely aware of the frustration and concerns that are felt by many about the overall decline in in-person banking services across Scotland, which have now been exacerbated by the Bank of Scotland’s recent decision to withdraw its mobile banking branch services, which as Rhoda Grant described, were supposed to be a compromise. Murdo Fraser made that point, too.
I assure Rhoda Grant that the Government shares those concerns—as I do, not least because, as someone who grew up in Orkney, I understand the impact that that decision will have on the most vulnerable individuals in our rural and island communities, who might struggle to access alternative services.
Rhoda Grant gave the example of the 36-mile round trip from Lairg to Golspie to access services. It is an area that I know well, so I understand the challenges that she articulated. That example and the example of the three-hour round trip that Emma Harper gave and, even worse, Kate Forbes’s example of having to cross the water to access banking services, demonstrate a lack of consideration by banking institutions of individual needs, the geographical issues that people in remote, rural and island communities face and the impact of those closures.
The discussion that we have had today is essential because Lloyds Banking Group’s decision to withdraw services has not been made in isolation. It continues a trend that has been witnessed across the banking sector in recent years. Since 2015, more than 60 per cent of Scottish bank branches have closed and, since 2018, more than 20 per cent of Scottish ATMs have closed. Those numbers are consistent with those in other regions in the UK, and it would be naive to assume that no more closures will follow.
That is of great concern to the Scottish Government, as we believe that the ability to access cash is essential in our society and that in-person banking still plays an important role in our communities, not least because of the points that Rhoda Grant made about concerns for people with digital literacy challenges and for businesses, which need to be able to bank. I have raised those issues with Lloyds Banking Group, and I will go into more detail about that shortly.
As Kate Forbes set out, the closures have a clear social impact, because those who are most likely to be affected are those who are most likely to be in poverty. Our concerns are not solely about having access to cash and services, as Emma Harper said. The point has not been raised thus far in the debate, but bank branches are often seen as anchors in our smaller communities. That is something that I recognise from the closures in my constituency or in towns such as Kirkwall, where we have seen branches close. Their closure will have wider impacts on the dynamics of our town centres and high streets, particularly when it is the last bank in town.
Despite our concerns, the Scottish Government’s regulatory power to act—as Kate Forbes said, although I suggest that she has more hair to pull out than I do, sadly—is extremely limited, because financial services are wholly reserved to the UK Government. I was therefore pleased to hear Stephen Kerr make the point that not only is it important for us to debate the issue despite it being reserved, but it is critically important that there is change at the UK Government and FCA level.
The UK Parliament recently legislated in this space by passing the Financial Services and Markets Act 2020 . We are encouraged by the access to cash provisions that are contained in the act. Most notably, the act gives the Financial Conduct Authority, which is the regulator of financial services in the UK, greater powers to protect access to cash by ensuring the provision of cash deposit and withdrawal services for personal and business current accounts across the UK.
Kate Forbes pointed out that the FCA has launched a consultation, and I also encourage colleagues to engage with it. The Scottish Government will certainly engage with the FCA in the coming period. I will meet the chief executive, Nikhil Rathi, next week to discuss the issue. This debate is incredibly timely, because I will be able to raise the concerns that have been well expressed today directly with the FCA to explore what can be done to ensure that the unique banking and cash access needs of Scotland’s communities, people, small businesses and charities are being considered.