I thank those members who supported the motion to allow the debate to take place.
The debate is about future proofing transport connectivity for rural and island areas. We already know about the impacts of poor connectivity on women, fixed-income households and both older and younger people. Today, I call on the Scottish Government to listen to communities that feel that they would be better served by bridges or tunnels.
Members will not be surprised to hear that, in my contribution, I will focus on moving away from carbon-intensive, interisland ferries, in particular in Shetland. The tunnels debate is not new. In Shetland, however, it is currently set against the backdrop of an ageing ferry fleet with high carbon emissions, and a situation in which the recruitment and retention of ferry crews is difficult. All those issues are having an ever-increasing impact on the reliability of services.
There is proof of concept. More than a century ago, the short bridge between Muckle Roe and the Shetland mainland was seen as a means of reversing depopulation. The islands of Burra and Trondra were connected by bridges in the 1970s, and their populations have grown; Trondra’s population has increased eightfold from its lowest point, at just 17.
The issues of depopulation, the economy and social links are driving the campaign’s calls for short subsea tunnels. The economies of the islands are being stifled, and that, in turn, impacts on Shetland’s wider economic contribution to the national economy. Two ferries are needed to get to Unst, which is home to the new SaxaVord spaceport, in the most northerly location in the United Kingdom. The debate is of national strategic importance. The former First Minister agreed with that in December 2021, when she said:
“A development like that would be of strategic importance, as well as being important to the local community and economy.”—[Official Report, 23 December 2021; c 27.]
In Yell, a local haulier transports significant quantities of fish that are landed at Cullivoe pier, and salmon from the local processing factory. However, because of ferry delays out of Yell, there is a risk that they miss the onward ferry connection from Lerwick to Aberdeen, and the markets. Delays cost money for the haulier and for those exporting seafood.
With tunnel infrastructure, it is anticipated that social and cultural links would be enhanced, including better public transport, increased tourism opportunities and improved health and public services, not least emergency services provision.
However, there is a danger that some view discussions about interisland fixed-link connections purely through the lens of their benefiting only those people who live on those islands, rather than looking holistically at the benefits to Shetland, and ultimately to Scotland. If island communities are valued, they must be supported to reach their full potential. There is no shortage of potential in Shetland, from space, fishing and aquaculture to offshore and onshore energy in various forms.
In February 2022, my MP colleague Alistair Carmichael and I hosted an online public discussion about the prospect of short subsea tunnels in Shetland. We followed up that with our first “Tunnel Vision” event in summer 2022, with an islands tour, hosting discussions in community halls, to gauge the views from each island about the opportunities and challenges of tunnel connections. Community-led, grass-roots Unst and Yell tunnel action groups, known as UTAG and YTAG, were developed.
A further round of community engagement events this past summer saw the creation of a tunnel action group in Whalsay, which is the home of Shetland’s pelagic fleet, and where yesterday, one of its island ferries, the 41-year-old Hendra, broke down yet again.
UTAG and YTAG have been busy this last summer, crowdfunding for geotechnical investigations to complement the work that has already been done on the concept of tunnels.