I congratulate Gordon MacDonald on securing the debate. I associate myself with his motion, which I was happy to sign, and I acknowledge the work that he does as convener of the cross-party group on independent convenience stores, of which I am happy to be a member and supporter.
In his opening speech, Gordon MacDonald referred to “The Scottish Local Shop Report 2023”, which was published recently. I think that he quoted every statistic from it, so I will not repeat every one of them but will give a few highlights.
In Scotland, there are 49,000 jobs in the sector, which is a significant employment footprint. The sector pays £9.1 billion in taxes across the UK, which is a significant economic and fiscal contribution. There are 5,171 convenience stores in Scotland, and 70 per cent of those are independently owned. The sector is made up of small, often family, businesses—people, as we have heard in the debate, who work extremely hard, work long hours and provide a vital service to their local communities.
The key point about convenience stores is that they are convenient for local people. They are convenient in that they are often at the end of the street. If, as a society, we are concerned about meeting net zero targets, we want to have convenient services available to people, so having shops that people can buy their groceries in within walking or cycling distance of their homes makes a lot of sense.
As Gordon MacDonald said, convenience stores often provide a range of other services, such as mobile phone top-ups, post office services and bill payment and cashback facilities. Convenience stores mean that a range of other activities are available in local neighbourhoods, which are all very welcome.
I was very pleased to attend, as a guest, the Scottish Grocers Federation’s conference in Glasgow last month. I think that I might have been the only MSP who was there. I very much enjoyed being part of that event, hearing about the success stories and celebrating a lot of the good news in the sector, which we have already heard about.
However, during the conference, the sector raised a number of challenges, one of which was to do with business rates. Many convenience stores will be beneath the threshold for paying business rates because of the small business bonus scheme, but some of them will not—some of them will be larger and will pay business rates. A concern that was raised with me was the fact that, although retail businesses south of the border have a 75 per cent rates relief in the current financial year, that was not passed on by the Scottish Government to shops in Scotland. That has caused concern to people who are involved in businesses here.
Concern was also raised about the shambolic deposit return scheme, which I am pleased to see has been shelved for the time being. Businesses in the sector are concerned about the fact that, in due course, that scheme might come back, and about what that would mean for them and what costs would be involved.
In addition, concerns were expressed about what might come down the track in terms of restrictions on the marketing of alcohol products, because alcohol forms an important part of the range of products on offer in many convenience stores. If there were overly restrictive rules on the promotion of alcohol, as was originally suggested, that could have a really negative impact on the sector. That is another issue that we need to be careful about.
However, the biggest concern in the sector is about the rise in crime and the violence against shop workers, which has been growing. Daniel Johnson, who is not with us tonight, introduced a member’s bill on the issue to make it an enhanced offence to attack a shop worker. That was very welcome, but there are still too many attacks on shop workers.
There has also been a dramatic increase in the number of reports of shoplifting. Rather than being due to increases in the cost of living and people being in poverty, that shoplifting is being arranged by organised crime gangs that are targeting particular products and local shops. There is real concern that that is happening and that there is a lack of a deterrent. We do not have enough police around to deter such crimes, it is very difficult to catch people when they commit them and, when they are caught, the penalties that they receive are not sufficient to act as a deterrent. We definitely need to have a more effective police presence, and we need to have a justice system that properly punishes people who are caught shoplifting.
That is what people in the sector are calling for. If we support the sector, we should endorse those calls and support them in their efforts to provide more protection for people who are trying to earn a living in what can often be a difficult business.
17:43