One of the main characters of one of my favourite TV shows, the much-acclaimed “The Wire”, is the cigar-smoking and curmudgeonly Baltimore detective Bunk Moreland. The actor who plays Moreland, Wendell Pierce, said that culture was a
“form through which we as a society reflect on who we are, where we’ve been, where we hope to be.”
I am fortunate to represent the Highlands and Islands, a region that rivals any in Scotland for the strength of its cultural offering—in fact, it rivals anywhere in the world. As well as being important for those of us who live there, it attracts visitors from across the globe.
There are, of course, well-known events such as Up Helly Aa in Shetland, the St Magnus international festival in Orkney, the many local highland games and, of course, the annual Royal National Mod, which celebrates our Gaelic linguistic and cultural heritage. However, culture and the arts play a part in communities right across the Highlands and Islands, from local events to the smaller museums that celebrate the diversity of my region. Those are supported by passionate and committed organisations and local volunteers, as well as by the work of charities and others.
However, there is real pressure on the sector, not just because of the SNP’s cuts to Creative Scotland. Local government also plays an important role. I am sure that the cabinet secretary, when he was the MP for Moray, will have visited the Falconer museum in Forres. He would not be able to visit it today, because it was closed in April 2020 by Moray Council’s previous SNP administration, because of his SNP Government’s squeeze on local government funding.
In addition, I and Scottish Conservative MSP colleagues have concerns over the planned cuts by the University of the Highlands and Islands to its history department. As a history graduate, I recognise that history is important to both understanding the past and inspiring the future.
Understanding and valuing the past, and learning from the mistakes of the past, are vital. That principle seems to have passed many in the SNP by, but would we expect anything else from a party that, in the past year or so, has mirrored some of the most popular genres of TV culture? The SNP has moved from soap opera to police drama to comedy. Its leadership contest quickly descended from “Succession” to “Game of Thrones”—and now, given its new leader’s endless policy U-turns, including on arts funding, it is more reminiscent of a pantomime. The SNP claims that it is “Stronger for Scotland”. I say, “Oh no it isn’t.”
The arts journalist Brian Ferguson described the funding cuts as
“the biggest betrayal of Scottish culture, artists and performers in modern times”,
and even the most loyal of the SNP’s arts and culture loyalists recognise that the blame falls squarely on SNP ministers in Edinburgh. Iona Fyfe accused the Scottish Government of flip-flopping on arts funding, arguing that workers in the culture sector have already “lost faith” in it.
The Scottish Government’s response to such criticisms is, as is exemplified by its cloth-eared amendment, the usual and sadly predictable blame bingo. “It’s Brexit.” “It’s Covid.” “It’s the UK’s fault.” However, it is not any of those things. The blame lies squarely with SNP ministers in Edinburgh, who always seem to be able to find money down the back of the Bute house sofa when they need something for their own priorities—just not for culture or the arts.
Both the Labour motion and the Scottish Conservative amendment highlight the uncertainty that the SNP’s cuts are creating and the damage that they are doing. There is a real threat to jobs. However, we risk losing much more, because our arts and culture bind together communities across the country, and help us to
“reflect on who we are, where we’ve been, where we hope to be.”
17:13