It is a year to the day since the Scottish Government published a groundbreaking proposal for a rural visa pilot in Scotland. In that time, the need for the initiative has only increased, but the United Kingdom Government’s silence on the matter has been deafening. When Mairi Gougeon gave evidence to the Rural Affairs and Islands Committee this morning, I asked her whether she had had a reply from the UK Government on the matter. She said that she had not.
It is rare to find an issue that unites businesses across rural Scotland, political parties in the Parliament and organisations across the public, private and third sectors. However, the proposal for a rural visa pilot does exactly that. Such is the pressure on the labour market, and such are the stark warnings about rural depopulation, that it is hardly a surprise that the proposal commands widespread support.
The visa would allow for bespoke immigration that would meet the needs of particular sectors and geographies and enrich our communities and our society. It is modelled on the successful Canadian Atlantic immigration programme, which proves that it could work even in a devolved context and be transformational for local economies. However, despite widespread support, the obvious benefits for rural Scotland and the comprehensive work that has gone into developing the proposal, it has not progressed for one reason: the UK Government has blocked it.
I reissue the call to the UK Government to change its stance and think again. We need a rural visa pilot. Our businesses, communities and public sector services need a rural visa pilot. It is the only sensible solution, but, not least yesterday, we see the Tories pursue an increasingly damaging, ruthless and despicable immigration policy that pulls up the drawbridge and inflicts devastation on our rural communities.
For rural Scotland, there are three reasons why it is imperative that there be a rural visa pilot. First, we need immigration after decades of emigration; secondly, the population forecasts for rural Scotland are stark; and, thirdly, the impact will be deeply felt across all rural communities.
Scotland is a country of emigrants with a long history of people leaving our shores. That is perhaps most stark in rural areas. For decades—indeed, for centuries—we have haemorrhaged people who sought new opportunities across the world. That memory is in our national DNA. We, of all people, should have compassion for people who want to make Scotland their home and should recognise the unique economic and social opportunities that that affords those of us who are already in Scotland.
Many businesses in rural Scotland have great ambitions and aspirations but cite a lack of skilled staff as the primary reason why they do not grow and develop. Farms and fishing boats try but are unable to meet the ever-growing demand for sustainably caught and grown food because of the lack of people. At a time when costs are increasing, inflation has eaten into margins and the economy is stagnating, the last thing that organisations need is a staffing shortage.
The magnitude of the impact is difficult to quantify, but, just this week, NFU Scotland said that, in 2022, as much as £60 million-worth of food was wasted on farms because of labour shortages. Fruit and vegetable produce was especially impacted. That £60 million-worth of food was wasted at a time when our children are hungry, our economy is stagnating and key sectors such as agriculture have much to offer.
I mentioned population. We need only look at last week’s initial findings from the census to see confirmation of research that we previously knew about from the Scottish Fiscal Commission and National Records of Scotland. They demonstrated that rural Scotland faces sustained and substantial depopulation. The Western Isles, Argyll and Bute, Dumfries and Galloway, the Shetland Islands, Angus, Moray, the Orkney Islands and the Highlands could all experience population declines of up to 16 per cent between 2018 and 2043. Those figures are in stark contrast to some of the growth in urban centres, which demonstrates why the visa should initially be bespoke.
Population decline is not just a question of numbers and percentages. It will directly increase poverty, it will shrink the economy and it will hamstring public services, because, if the rural population decreases and gets older, as forecasts suggest that it will, there will be fewer workers in our national health service, our care homes and our grocery stores; there will be fewer children in our schools, enriching our communities; and our older people will struggle to get basic services.
Therefore, I come back to the fact that, tonight, we are not just complaining about the situation that our people face; we are proposing a workable, groundbreaking proposal that will reverse depopulation and ensure that there is a viable future for rural Scotland. The proposal outlined by the Government, with support from Shetland Islands Council and Scottish Rural Action, involves a community-based approach that allows rural communities to attract workers in line with their distinct needs. In agricultural areas, the demand might be for farm workers and, in urban centres, there might be more interest in attracting bespoke skills. Employers can advertise vacancies within designated geographic areas and then assess prospective candidates before recommending the chosen candidates to the Home Office for final approval and security checks. At that point—critically and, perhaps, most interestingly—there would then be a package of support to allow newcomers to settle.
I hope that the Parliament can once again unite, irrespective of party, constitutional lines or sectoral boundaries, and call on the UK Government to grant this opportunity for rural Scotland to reverse population decline and ensure that there is a viable future that enriches our communities and ensures that our economy can grow.
18:32