Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Cost of Living (Tenant Protection) (Scotland) Act 2022 (Amendment of Expiry Date) Regulations 2023 [Draft]

Tuesday 12 September 2023 Local Government, Housing and Planning Committee About 11:15–12:00 Subordinate legislation 49 contributions · 9 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

49 contributions
Ariane Burgess Green The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Before we turn to the next item, I give apologies for my colleague Mark Griffin. He had a problem getting in and although we thought that he might arrive at committee, it seems that he is further delayed. I therefore extend those apologies.

Agenda item 3 is to take evidence on the Cost of Living (Tenant Protection) (Scotland) Act 2022 (Amendment of Expiry Date) Regulations 2023.

We are joined again by Patrick Harvie, Minister for Zero Carbon Buildings, Active Travel and Tenants’ Rights. Mr Harvie is joined for this item by Scottish Government officials Adam Krawczyk, head of housing, homelessness and regeneration analysis; Poppy Prior, solicitor; and Yvette Sheppard, head of the housing services and rented sector reform unit.

I invite the minister to make a short opening statement.

Patrick Harvie Green Glasgow
link

It is nice to be back with the committee again. I am pleased to be here to present the Cost of Living (Tenant Protection) (Scotland) Act 2022 (Amendment of Expiry Date) Regulations 2023.

As colleagues know, the 2022 emergency act came into force on 28 October last year and, since then, has provided additional protection for tenants in what remain challenging economic times. The act originally ran to 31 March 2023 and has been extended once, until the end of this current month.

In June, I published a statement of reasons for the second proposed extension of the emergency act. As part of that report, and in line with the requirements of the act, I set out the intention for the measures in the act to be extended for a further, and final, six months to 31 March 2024.

The report provides updated data and economic analysis that shows that the challenging economic position has not yet fundamentally changed and that many households in the private rented sector in particular continue to struggle. For example, according to recent YouGov polling for the Scottish Government, in August 2023, levels of concern in relation to paying rent were twice as high in the private rented sector, at 27 per cent, compared to those in relation to paying rent or mortgages across all tenures as a whole, at 12 per cent. That has not improved since the polling in March 2023.

It was recently announced that the energy price cap will reduce, but it is reducing from a very high level, and the positive impact on fuel poverty rates is offset by the UK Government’s decision to withdraw the energy bills support scheme, under which £400 was paid to all households last winter.

Meanwhile, the freezing of local housing allowance rates by the UK Government for the third consecutive year is yet another reason why those in lower-income households in the private rented sector who access local housing allowance will find it more difficult to afford rental properties.

The picture has changed somewhat since a year ago, but circumstances remain very difficult for many tenants, and many households that are on low and modest incomes continue to feel the strain of cost of living pressures. For those reasons, the regulations seek to extend the application of part 1 of the Cost of Living (Tenant Protection) (Scotland) Act 2022 in its current form—including the rent cap measures for the private rented sector, the eviction moratorium provisions across all rented sectors that the act covers, and other important protections—until 31 March 2024 at the latest.

In reaching that position, I have reflected on the views that stakeholders and partners have expressed and I have sought to find the right balance, under the statutory duty, to ensure that the provisions do not remain in place for longer than is necessary in connection with the cost crisis. I also recognise the on-going impacts that the cost crisis is having on some private landlords. The private sector rent cap is set at 3 per cent, but there is a safeguard for landlords, who can alternatively opt to apply to rent service Scotland for a rent increase of up to 6 per cent if their defined, prescribed property costs have increased within a specified period. I know that some landlords are using that safeguard—1,031 of them had submitted such an application to rent service Scotland as of 1 September.

I turn to our proposed continuation of the eviction moratorium provisions. Tenants in the private and social rented sectors, and those who live in student accommodation, will continue to benefit from the additional time to find alternative accommodation that the six-month pause in the enforcement of eviction action provides. In addition, they are protected from private landlords seeking to end a tenancy in order to raise rents above the cap, and the provisions reduce unlawful evictions by increasing the level of damages that are payable.

As with the rent cap, the eviction moratorium provisions include a number of safeguards for landlords. Those recognise that there are circumstances when enforcement of an eviction order or decree should proceed to protect communities—for example, in instances of serious antisocial behaviour—and to strike an appropriate balance between the protection of tenants and the rights of landlords.

In summary, the latest evidence shows that the cost crisis is still very much with us. It is crucial that we continue the remaining protections in the 2022 act beyond 30 September. If the committee agrees to recommend approval, it will remain the case that, for this final period, I will continue to keep the measures under review, to consider their on-going necessity and proportionality and to advise the Parliament through regular reporting—the next report is due to be laid no later than 14 October.

I thank the committee for its continued interest in the issue and for its scrutiny of the regulations. I am happy to answer any questions that members have.

Ariane Burgess Green The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Thank you for your statement. It is good to hear that you will continue to monitor the situation and look into the proportionality of the measures.

We have heard concern that the provisions are leading to landlords leaving the sector. I am interested in hearing whether there is evidence of that. Are you concerned about that?

Patrick Harvie Green Glasgow
link

We continue to keep a close eye on the issue. We are aware of anecdotal evidence that landlords have been talking about it. Some cite the temporary cost of living measures in the 2022 act as one factor; I have heard from a number of landlords for whom changes in UK tax policy have been a bigger motivation in their decisions about whether to consider leaving the sector.

On the actual evidence, though, the number of properties registered for private rent in Scotland under the registration scheme has not changed significantly. We are conscious that there is likely to be a bit of a time lag in the collection of the data, but at the moment the figures do not show a significant reduction in the number of properties available.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

Good morning again, Patrick. Interestingly, the Association of Local Authority Chief Housing Officers recommends that you withdraw rather than extend the measures, saying that it is not having the impact that was intended and so on. What is your view of that, and why would you disregard it and proceed with the proposal today?

Patrick Harvie Green Glasgow
link

It is worth separating out the rent cap provisions from the eviction moratorium provisions. With the social housing sector—local authority and housing association housing—we reached a different approach on the rent cap. We agreed that approach, taking account of the sector’s concerns and its different nature, such as the way in which rental income is reinvested for public purposes, whether that is for services for tenants, retrofit to improve energy performance or investment in new build. We recognised a range of differences in the way that the private and the social rented sectors operate, and we found that the best solution was to work with the social rented sector to agree a voluntary limit on average rent rises across Scotland.

We removed social housing from the fixed absolute rent cap and agreed the voluntary approach. For an average size of property, that amounted to a close monetary equivalence between the increased rent cap after it raised from zero and the voluntary agreement that was reached with the social housing sector. My view is that that has achieved a level of stability for tenants in a way that has been agreed mutually with the sector.

Some of the sector’s concerns might be more focused on the eviction moratorium rather than on rent. We believe that, in the current climate, it remains important for people to have the additional time available to them if they are faced with the prospect of eviction. Safeguards remain for social landlords that need to evict someone—for example, that can happen in cases of severe or serious antisocial behaviour. For the most part, social landlords, whether they are local authorities or housing associations, have been very responsible landlords and have never wanted to move to eviction as their first recourse. They seek to achieve better outcomes for their tenants. They have had pre-eviction protocols in place for substantially longer than they have been a requirement in the private rented sector.

Therefore, I believe that we still have the right balance when it comes to protection for tenants who might face the prospect of eviction in some circumstances, and protection for landlords, whether in the social sector or the private sector, who, in rare circumstances, have a legitimate need to pursue an eviction order.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

ALACHO said that the measure simply pushes the rent that is due to the end of the process—it is a bigger amount at the eviction point—and does not ultimately reduce the number of evictions. What would be your response to that?

Patrick Harvie Green Glasgow
link

We were clear when we debated the Cost of Living (Tenant Protection) (Scotland) Bill and took it through the Parliament that, in cases of severe rent arrears, a tenant does not simply need to be stuck in one place, accruing ever more debt. That was one reason why severe rent arrears were included as a ground for pursuing eviction.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

In some of the evidence, there has been a suggestion that the supply of private rented homes has been adversely affected by the emergency legislation. What do you have to say about that, and about the potential deterrent to institutional investment in private rented housing? Are we seeing an impact in those areas?

11:45

Patrick Harvie Green Glasgow
link

Again, I would draw a distinction between anecdotal evidence that is being put about and what we are seeing on the ground. It was only ever possible for the Cost of Living (Tenant Protection) (Scotland) Act 2022 to have a direct impact on rental incomes for a period of 18 months. Now that we are at the point of proposing the extension for the final six months, the effect of a decision today cannot possibly impact on the rental income of properties that are subject to investors’ decisions at the moment. Investors’ decisions at the moment would be about the supply of homes that are available to generate rental income in the future, after the temporary provisions in this legislation have ceased.

Some of the wider concerns of institutional investors are around the Scottish Government’s longer-term proposals for rebalancing the private rental sector and, in particular, for a new national system of rent controls. We are keen to continue to work closely with the sector, which includes engagement that I and Paul McLennan as Minister for Housing have with investors as well as developers as we work through the process to determine the shape of the housing bill that will be introduced next year to give effect to that commitment to a national system of rent controls.

The impact that we are seeing on rental prices reinforces the need to commit to that work. We need to ensure that affordability is part of our understanding of what adequate housing is and that all people have a human right to adequate housing. We will continue to develop that work in a way that is well informed by the perspectives of tenants, landlords, the people who work with them and investors. Across Europe, the situation that Scotland and the rest of the UK have been in in recent years and decades is unusual. It is a particularly unregulated market in private housing terms.

Investors—particularly the bigger institutional investors—make decisions across a wide range of countries and they are well used to making decisions about more regulated and less regulated markets with regard to rental property. Evidence from across Europe is very clear: a well-designed rent control system is entirely compatible with a vibrant housing market and investment in homes made for private rent. We believe that that can be achieved in Scotland as well and that it will be consistent with supplying the quality homes that Scotland needs and achieving affordability, which has been lacking in too many cases.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley
link

Thank you for the detail in that response, minister.

Miles Briggs Con Lothian
link

The committee has received evidence about landlords’ increased costs, which have been impacted on by rising interest rates in recent months. What is the Government’s view on the case for increasing the rent cap from 3 per cent to 6 per cent for prescribed property costs?

Patrick Harvie Green Glasgow
link

As I said, we will continue to keep under review the proportionality and necessity of the measures. The next report that I mentioned is due by mid-October; it will inform the committee’s consideration of our proposals at that stage. As was set out in the statement of reasons that we published in June, we believe that the evidence is sufficient to justify continuation of the rent cap. Any subsequent variation in the level of the cap would be likely to be covered in the report in October.

The cost crisis is continuing to have an impact, and we need to recognise that that continued impact is being felt by tenants as well as by landlords. It has always been part of the design of the legislation to recognise the protection that tenants need, but it also recognises that safeguards for landlords are needed and that there must be a proper balance between those needs.

The fact is that the economic circumstances have not fundamentally changed. The cost crisis has not fundamentally gone away and, even if the hopeful projections around reduced inflation come to pass in the months ahead, people are still living with the increased costs that they have been landed with. That applies to tenants as well as to landlords and does not change the fundamental calculation that we have made about the balance between protection of rents and the safeguards for landlords that we have proposed.

Miles Briggs Con Lothian
link

Thank you. I will come back to my other questions later.

Pam Gosal Con West Scotland
link

Good morning. As the minister will probably know, the 2022 act has had unintended consequences for both tenants and landlords. We have heard from multiple organisations that landlords are increasing their rents between tenancies in order to cover their costs and anticipated costs due to fear of on-going rent controls.

In the 12 months to July 2023, private rental prices experienced their highest annual percentage change since 2012. Do you accept that the legislation is leaving landlords with no choice but to increase rents for new lets by more than they might have done had the legislation not been in place?

Patrick Harvie Green Glasgow
link

I do not agree with that characterisation of what the legislation has done.

Pam Gosal is right that rent increases between tenancies are not covered by the legislation. As it is emergency legislation, it was not ever going to be possible, through it, to fundamentally restructure the way that private residential tenancies—PRTs—work. There was recognition that the 2002 act was only ever going to provide protection within tenancies in relation to the annual in-tenancy increases that are allowed under the PRT.

As a result of the legislation being in force in Scotland, the difference is that we are seeing only inter-tenancy increases and tenants are—excepting the exceptional 6 per cent cases—being protected with a 3 per cent rent increase cap within tenancies. Down south, people are being subjected to both. We know that increases in market rents—rents that are being advertised—are significant; for example, the increase is 12 per cent in Glasgow and 10 per cent in Aberdeen. We also know that similar figures are being seen in parts of England; for example, we see increases of 10.4 per cent in Cardiff, 10.7 per cent in Southampton and 13 per cent in Manchester.

The inter-tenancy increases are happening for a wide range of reasons. I am sure that they are a necessity in some cases, but some landlords are pursuing whatever they can get away with. That last point is by no means a characterisation of the whole private rented sector. There are landlords out there who are committed to trying to provide housing that is as affordable as possible for their tenants, but there are also landlords who will go to the maximum that they think the market will bear.

In Scotland, sitting tenants have protection from annual in-tenancy rent increases, rather than their being subjected to both in-tenancy and intra-tenancy rent increases. The level of protection that exists for tenants is higher in Scotland as a result of the legislation.

Pam Gosal Con West Scotland
link

Are you aware that students have been really affected by cases of landlords making prices higher? I know from the Indian student groups and associations who have contacted me that some students have had to go back because they could not find appropriate accommodation, as the rents are so high that they cannot afford them. Sometimes there is even a lack of supply of housing in the market for rent.

Patrick Harvie Green Glasgow
link

Absolutely. The increase in intra-tenancy rents is significant. It is significant both down south and here, partly because of economic circumstances and partly because of the unregulated nature of those rental increases. For me, that reinforces the need to continue to make progress on the development of the new housing bill and a rent control system for Scotland that will be fully effective, rather than our relying on emergency legislation that can protect only people in tenancies. The 2022 act, as emergency legislation, was only ever going to be able to do that. It was also only ever going to be temporary, as it has to be subject to the continual test of necessity and proportionality.

It is very clear that the affordability issues in the private rented sector more generally require longer-term reform, which the Scottish Government is committed to.

Ariane Burgess Green The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

We move to questions from Ivan McKee.

Ivan McKee SNP Glasgow Provan
link

In the interests of transparency I reiterate my declaration of interests with regard to ownership of rental property and a share of a property rental business.

I turn to the period after March next year. You answered Willie Coffey’s question about investors looking at the longer term. As much certainty as you can give tenants and landlords about the situation would be helpful in relation to their interests and longer-term planning. You have previously told the committee that the way to bridge the gap between the end of the rent cap and longer-term rent control measures would be the rent adjudication measures in the 2022 act. What is your current thinking on how those powers might be used and when will you announce your proposed approach for the period after the end of March next year?

Patrick Harvie Green Glasgow
link

That question is hugely important, and Ivan McKee is right to point to that power in the legislation. It allows an adjustment to be made to the rent adjudication process, the idea of which is to prevent an immediate cliff edge when the temporary emergency legislation is switched off. We are still at the point of exploring the options to make the most effective use of that power. I am afraid that I am not able to publish detailed proposals on that, but we can expect them to come forward in time for expiry of the rent cap.

I turn to Yvette Sheppard. Are we able to say anything more at this point on the expected timescale? I know that dialogue has taken place on the subject with stakeholders, too.

Yvette Sheppard Scottish Government
link

We are still taking stakeholder views into account and, as the minister has reflected, considering the different ways in which we could amend the adjudication system. Broadly, the adjudication system relies on comparisons with market rent, so we and our stakeholders are looking at what the alternative options could be in that space. We are hoping to introduce proposals in the first few months after the current extension takes place in October.

Ivan McKee SNP Glasgow Provan
link

Do you accept that the longer that goes on, the more uncertainty exists, which makes it more difficult to go forward with investment to increase supply, which is clearly a significant objective?

Patrick Harvie Green Glasgow
link

Yes. That is why we are keen to ensure that we are hearing from the widest possible range of voices, as we come to a decision. I hope that broad support exists for the principle that such a mechanism is necessary to prevent a cliff edge—I do not recall there being serious opposition when the legislation was passed in Parliament—but Ivan McKee is quite right to say that it needs to be designed in a way that is consistent with both our protection for tenants and the wider need for a housing market that meets people’s needs.

Marie McNair SNP Clydebank and Milngavie
link

Following on from Ivan’s questions, I note that some of the evidence that we have received has pointed to the need for the Scottish Government to review and update the private rented sector policy. Do you have a timescales for when you will publish the tenant strategy and the housing bill to introduce long-term rent control provisions?

Patrick Harvie Green Glasgow
link

The programme for government includes a commitment to introduce the housing bill to deliver the new deal for tenants, which will include the introduction of long-term rent controls and other tenants’ rights, as well as new prevention of homelessness duties. I hope that members and stakeholders will take confidence from the inclusion of that commitment in the programme for government. The precise date of introduction of a new bill is always a slightly moveable feast, but we have the commitment to take that work forward and are continuing to work with a range of stakeholders to ensure that we shape that bill as effectively as possible.

12:00

Ariane Burgess Green The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

It is good to get that reassurance. We stood to attention when we heard what was in the PFG.

I have a question about joint tenancy loopholes. Living Rent has stated that there is a loophole in the legislation as a result of which a joint tenant who remains in the property after another joint tenant leaves might not be protected by the rent cap. How can such tenants be protected?

Patrick Harvie Green Glasgow
link

I share the concern about the matter, although I am not sure that I would use the word “loophole”. The situation is a consequence of the fact that the emergency legislation could take only temporary steps and that it was not possible to use it for a fundamental restructuring of, or major surgery on, private residential tenancy. The current legislation gives the landlord the right to decide not to agree to continue an existing tenancy when one joint tenant leaves.

The intention, of course, behind designing the PRT in that way—this is going back a good number of years—was to avoid a situation in which others were made homeless because one person chose to leave a joint tenancy. I do not think that it was the wrong decision to take that approach, but we need to recognise that one of the consequences was that the emergency legislation was not able to address that particular circumstance. Once again, I come back to the point that it highlights the need for us to make good on the longer-term commitments, including the new housing legislation and the new deal for tenants. As part of our work on developing that, we are looking at joint tenancy issues, including the existing approach to ending joint tenancies.

Ariane Burgess Green The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Thanks for that. Miles Briggs has a final question.

Miles Briggs Con Lothian
link

I want to raise a couple of issues with the minister. First, I think that we would accept that the approach has been useful for current tenants. However, with regard to people seeking tenancies, do you have any views on the facts that we now have among the highest-ever homelessness rates and numbers of children in temporary accommodation, and that councils are saying that they are unable to put together sustainable tenancies with the private rented sector? Do you understand that consequence of the policy?

Patrick Harvie Green Glasgow
link

The issue is, of course, extremely serious. Some of the longer-term work that we are doing, including the homelessness prevention duties in the new housing bill, will be relevant.

I should, though, point out some of the information that has already been published on referrals with regard to people becoming homeless and the tenure that they previously had. A significant reduction in respect of the private rented sector has been showing up in the statistics over the period; in fact, I think that the figure has come down to pre-pandemic levels.

Adam Krawczyk might have found the graph that I have just been frantically searching for. Adam—is there anything you can say about the figures that you have in front of you?

Adam Krawczyk Scottish Government
link

Sure. The biannual update on homelessness statistics were published in August, and they show that for the six months up to September 2022, before the emergency legislation came in, there were 2,990 assessments of homelessness with regard to people who had been in the private rented sector. For the six months after—that is, from October 2022 to March 2023—there were 2,200 such assessments, which means that there was a 26 per cent reduction in the number of households coming from the private rented sector that were assessed as homeless. As Mr Harvie has said, that figure for those six months is below the pre-pandemic level, in 2019.

Patrick Harvie Green Glasgow
link

Again, some of that variation will be to do with protections being brought in due to Covid and then starting to ease off. Over time, such things can change significantly. I do not think that we have to go back very many years to see a period when evictions from the private rented sector were the principal—the biggest—route into homelessness. That level started to come down because of a number of actions that were taken. We need to continue to ensure that people are protected from the risk of homelessness, and the new homelessness prevention duties are going to be important in achieving that. However, it is pretty clear that the legislation has given additional protection that has been necessary, particularly for people living in the private rented sector.

Miles Briggs Con Lothian
link

You have said that you do not want to create a cliff edge, but from my reading of the legislation, every landlord in Scotland will be able to seek a review in March without the further extension that the Government is outlining. My concern is about what that will mean for the housing tribunal, the backlog that it already faces and the resources that it will need. Has the Government considered what that will look like?

Patrick Harvie Green Glasgow
link

Obviously, we stay in touch with the tribunal on the impacts with regard to the design and, now, implementation of the legislation, and we will continue to be in close contact on the implications of any further changes. What is worth reflecting on, though, is that even once the 2022 act comes to an end and ceases to apply, tenants will have the high levels of protection that they had before it. Indeed, the UK Government itself is now starting to introduce some aspects of that protection; I welcome its change of position in that respect. The end of the emergency legislation will not mean the end of tenant protection—not by a long way; tenants will return to the high level of legal rights and protection that existed prior to it.

Miles Briggs Con Lothian
link

Finally, how does the extension to the regulations fit with the Scottish Government’s wider objectives in “Housing to 2040”? Moreover, I note that many of the homelessness duties that are being presented were to do with the development of sustainable tenancies within the private rented sector. I do not know whether you have to hand any data on the situation today, but my understanding is that very few such tenancies have been taken forward since the rent controls were put in place. It seems really critical that we re-establish that relationship to deal with the housing crisis that we are facing.

Patrick Harvie Green Glasgow
link

I come back to the difference between the longer-term development of housing policy and legislation, the new housing bill and the homelessness prevention duties and the good level of dialogue that we are having with the sector in the broadest terms as we take forward that work and, in this instance, the specific tests that we have to go through that were required under the Cost of Living (Tenant Protection) (Scotland) Act 2022 to justify the necessity and proportionality of not only continuing but, in this case, extending the provisions. Under the legislation, we remain under the duty to keep that test of proportionality and necessity under on-going review and to expire provisions that we can no longer justify in those terms. The extension to next March at the latest does not remove the requirement on us to continue to carry out that on-going review.

Ariane Burgess Green The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

That concludes our questions, so I thank the witnesses for their evidence.

We move to agenda item 4, which is consideration of the motion on the instrument that we have been discussing. I ask the minister to move motion S6M-09290.

Motion moved,

That the Local Government, Housing and Planning Committee recommends that The Cost of Living (Tenant Protection) (Scotland) Act 2022 (Amendment of Expiry Date) Regulations 2023 be approved.—Patrick Harvie

Ariane Burgess Green The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Do members wish to make any points?

Miles Briggs Con Lothian
link

As with the other extensions that have been proposed, we in the Conservative Party will oppose the motion in the vote.

Pam Gosal Con West Scotland
link

I echo that comment. We will be opposing the motion.

Ariane Burgess Green The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Do you wish to add anything further, minister?

Patrick Harvie Green Glasgow
link

I just thank the committee once again for its scrutiny and for giving me the time to explore the issues with you.

Ariane Burgess Green The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

The question is, that motion S6M-09290, in the name of Patrick Harvie, be agreed to. Are we all agreed?

Members: No.

Ariane Burgess Green The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

There will be a division.

For

Burgess, Ariane (Highlands and Islands) (Green)

Coffey, Willie (Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley) (SNP)

McKee, Ivan (Glasgow Provan) (SNP)

McNair, Marie (Clydebank and Milngavie) (SNP)

Against

Briggs, Miles (Lothian) (Con)

Gosal, Pam (West Scotland) (Con)

Ariane Burgess Green The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

The result of the division is: For 4, Against 2, Abstentions 0.

Motion agreed to.

Ariane Burgess Green The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

The committee will publish in the coming days a report setting out its recommendation on the instrument.

We agreed at the start of the meeting to take the next two items in private. As that was the last public item on today’s agenda, I close the public part of the meeting.

12:09 Meeting continued in private until 12:30.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report

No recorded division on this motion that day: decisions taken without a vote are not in the divisions feed.

  1. 09:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 191
  3. 11:15 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 49

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.