I thank my colleague Carol Mochan for bringing forward this timely debate to highlight the rising level of harm being caused in Scotland by alcohol, which is exacerbating health inequalities and adding to the huge but avoidable pressures faced by our NHS, at huge cost to our economy.
Carol Mochan is right when she says that this is a national crisis. The latest figures from National Records of Scotland show that almost 1,300 people died last year from conditions caused by alcohol, which is the highest figure in 14 years and is up 2 per cent on the previous year. Although we can always use different reference points and figures, it is clear that the situation is becoming more serious.
Our most disadvantaged and marginalised communities are disproportionately impacted by the harms that are caused by alcohol. Shockingly, people in Scotland’s most deprived communities are reportedly five times as likely to die and six times as likely to be admitted to hospital because of alcohol as are people living in the wealthiest communities.
The crisis directly impacts my constituents. NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde, my local health board and the largest in the country, recorded Scotland’s highest rate of mortality caused by chronic liver disease. This is, indeed, a crisis.
That is unacceptable and highlights the need for urgent action to strengthen prevention and improve access to services. It is important that there are facilities to help women offenders, which has been a key focus for this and previous Governments. There was a question yesterday about the 218 service, which is something that I know about because it was set up under a Labour Administration. It provides a very important alternative to custody for many women, including those who are alcohol-dependent, but it faces deep cuts. I wonder how that fits with the Government’s strategy on women’s offending and the crisis that we face.
Six months ago, Justina Murray of Scottish Families Affected by Alcohol and Drugs told the Criminal Justice Committee that one of the biggest barriers to effective change comes from implementation. She said:
“In Scotland, we are really good at writing down what we want to do—we have all the right things written in legislation, strategies and policies—but we do not implement what we say we will. We are good at saying what we are going to do, but we are not so good at doing what we should be doing. There is not really any accountability in the system ... there are still significant failings in treatment, care and support services.”—[Official Report, Criminal Justice Committee, 22 March 2023; c 7.]
Much more immediate work is required to reduce alcohol-related harms and death. The long-term funding of relevant services is absolutely vital in tackling the rise in alcohol-related deaths. We need services throughout the country, and the third sector must be appropriately funded in order to sustain those services for the foreseeable future.
Make no mistake: this is a public health crisis that should be taken as seriously as the crisis of drug-related deaths. In Scotland last year, 21 per cent more people died because of alcohol than because of drugs. It is clear that we must tackle both crises. Stuart McMillan made that point earlier and I agree with him. It is time to view alcohol as one of the biggest threats to population health. Every year, alcohol costs Glasgow, the region that I represent, an estimated £365 million, which equates to £615 per person.
Aside from the horrific impact that alcohol has on people’s lives, which Carol Mochan talked about, it has a hugely detrimental impact on economic growth and workforce productivity.
Every life lost is a tragedy, so we must do more to ensure that vulnerable people have access to local community services and the resources to reduce alcohol abuse and alcohol-related deaths in Scotland.
I want to make special mention of Alcoholics Anonymous, which is an organisation and a fellowship that has helped millions of people—and it means a lot to me. The mentoring system and the 12-step programme has given me the opportunity to try to understand alcoholism and the complexity behind it, and I realise that there is not one simple answer.
The organisation has something to offer to the overall strategy on alcohol. Sandesh Gulhane talked about the fact that alcohol is an issue that affects all communities and all classes, as well as about how dangerous it is to focus only on one policy. It is my personal experience, based on talking to people who have been seriously dependent and who have almost risked their lives, that people have been saved by services and by Alcoholics Anonymous. I also agree with Mr Gulhane’s point that affected people will do anything to get access to alcohol because of their dependency on it. There cannot be a one-size-fits-all solution to this. We need to realise that it is a complex issue.
Once again, I thank Carol Mochan for bringing this important debate to the chamber.
13:11