It is really important that we have a clear and ambitious innovation policy and strategy. It is also vital that we have a collective sense of mission about that. That is why, although Labour will be making criticisms of and suggestions on the policy, we ultimately support the publication of the paper.
My main criticism is to ask why it has taken so long. The lack of clarity and of a clear innovation policy was identified and discussed some time ago. Indeed, I remember that, leading up to my election to Parliament for the first time, debate was very much focused on that.
I refer to a paper that I have often looked to, which was published in 2014 by Nesta—the national endowment for science, technology and the arts. It is about innovation in small countries and it identifies five key factors that a successful innovation strategy brings: first, a focus downstream, making sure that you deliver commercial success; secondly, openness and being open to the world; thirdly, a whole-government approach; fourthly, effective and flexible institutions; and, fifthly, a sense of mission. That last one is why I think we have to have a consensual debate.
It is clear to me that the Government has addressed the first and fifth points but, on the third and fourth points—whole-government approaches, and effective and flexible institutions—the strategy is found wanting.
Ultimately, the strategy dodges two big, central questions. The first is on institutional landscape. We still have a cluttered landscape and there are only oblique references in the strategy to what has to happen to improve that.
Secondly, the biggest issue that we have on innovation is private sector investment. I take slight issue with what the minister said. He is correct that Scotland has good figures if we look at gross domestic expenditure on research and development—GERD. However, if we split that between higher education expenditure on research and development—HERD—and BERD, we see that, on BERD, we are behind the UK on levels of investment and we would be at the very bottom of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development tables.
Yes, we have strong, higher education-led research and innovation, but those fail to translate. The section on productivity in the strategy does a huge amount of work because it is the only place where the spillover is talked about or focused on in any meaningful way. There has to be a great deal more work to improve the detailed plans under the strategy to deliver on that.
To come back to the cluttered landscape, we have only to look at the diagram on page 14 of the strategy to see it. That diagram resembles something that we might see in the optician’s. It is a sea of coloured blobs without any clarity about who is in charge. Indeed, the strategy identifies five different lead institutions on innovation. It certainly does not set up our version of Tekes or Sitra in Finland. We need urgently to learn the lessons from 30 years ago in Finland rather than attempting to paper over the institutional cracks in our own framework.
The other key point that I will make is that the strategy assumes that innovation is something for external organisations to do. It is assumed to be a task for the private sector or higher education sector but, ultimately, the Government needs to internalise it.
I was at the recent Scottish EDGE awards. One of the winners, who has come up with an amazing product to help to use operating theatres in the national health service far more effectively, said that his peers told him not to bother to sell into the NHS because it is too difficult. If that is what entrepreneurs are saying, we have a big problem. Members should couple that with the insight that there has been a massive fall-off in the number of clinical trials in Scotland. We need a public sector that innovates end to end, and does not leave it to the private sector, because it understands that it ought to be a test bed and platform for innovation to help our life science businesses to grow.
In other areas, the strategy fails to understand where we are. It does not deal with the nuts and the bolts. We already have our clusters—they are successful. We do not need to set up new clusters but to get behind the ones that already exist. That is not about doing fancy things; it is about the nuts and the bolts. If we talk to life science companies, we find that their issues are to do with planning, roads and infrastructure. Those issues are what holds them back from setting up and innovating, but the strategy does not deal with that adequately.
I will touch on skills. I agree with Jamie Halcro Johnston that, unless we develop the mainstream skills in science and other key subjects, we will struggle.
Unfortunately, I cannot support the Conservative amendment because obliterating the innovation strategy in its entirety is wrong. We need an innovation strategy and there are good things in the one that has been published, but it does not go far enough. Ultimately, we need an innovation strategy that joins up with an integrated industrial strategy because it will not and cannot deliver unless we get innovation right and contextualise it within a good, strong, investment strategy and a procurement strategy, along with regulation, planning and skills.
That is why we mentioned the plans that we launched yesterday. They are an example. They have innovation in them, as well as research, delivery and investment in supply chains and delivery. That is the sort of industrial strategy that we need.
I move amendment S6M-09594.1, to insert at end:
“; recognises that ambition alone will not be enough to realise the potential of Scotland’s people, businesses and communities; believes that a genuine coordinated industrial strategy, built on investment, skills and infrastructure, will be central to driving innovation; welcomes the identification of the energy sector as a sector with high potential, and believes that the best chance of realising the potential in Scotland’s energy sector is through the Labour Party’s plan to create a new publicly-owned energy company, which will be headquartered in Scotland and will deliver lower bills, energy security and good jobs for Scotland.”
15:59