Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Deposit and Return Scheme for Scotland Amendment Regulations 2023 [Draft]

Tuesday 13 June 2023 Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee About 09:30–11:30 Subordinate legislation 238 contributions · 12 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

238 contributions · showing 201–238
Lorna Slater Green Lothian
link

I am very happy to do that. The regulations as passed by the Parliament in 2020 were deliberately quite broad, to allow industry to find a route to compliance that would suit it. The amendments cover five areas that have been the result of extensive work between us and industry.

The first is the requirement for online takeback, which is an important part of the scheme when it comes to equalities and people who are housebound or otherwise disabled and not able to get to a return point to return their scheme articles.

Originally, the regulations required anyone who sold any container to implement an online takeback service. That was difficult for small producers such as gin distillers who might sell only 500 bottles per week. They asked how they were to put in place an entire takeback scheme with vehicles to go and collect such items. The obligation has been restricted to the largest grocery retailers who already have the infrastructure, vehicles and IT systems to handle it, which will make the scheme both accessible and not overly burdensome for small businesses.

11:15

Another amendment is the provision on low-volume products, which is specifically aimed at supporting small producers but in fact will apply to all producers. It says that runs of products valued at less than £5,000 will not incur a deposit and therefore will not have to meet the system requirements. That will remove 44 per cent of the smallest producers from the scheme altogether, but it will also reduce the materials for the scheme by less than 0.5 per cent. It therefore does not undermine the scheme’s environmental benefits but does provide the crucial support for small producers that we all agree is important.

Another amendment is on the minimum container size, as it will apply to miniatures. There are practical issues around how tiny bottles and barcodes can be made recognisable by RVMs, but that change largely involves a simplification of the scheme that will help producers. We think that it will remove only 0.2 per cent of the total scheme articles. Again, we are providing significant support for business while not undermining the environmental aims of the scheme.

The fourth amendment applies to hospitality retailers. Originally, in the regulations as passed, any retailer who sold any article covered by the scheme would be required to apply to be a return point, unless they were granted an exemption. We have widened that out at the specific request of hospitality retailers, who sell more than 90 per cent of their items in a closed loop. I am sorry to use that technical phrase; it means that they sell things that are to be consumed on their premises. If someone goes to a restaurant and buys a bottle of wine they do not take it off the premises; they consume it there and then they leave. That is an example of a closed loop. However, if they go to premises and buy a can or a bottle of juice and then leave with it, that is an example of an open loop. Hospitality premises, 90 per cent of which represent closed loops—which will include most restaurants and many nightclubs and bars—will not be required automatically to be return points. That will remove a substantial proportion of operators from the scheme. The rough estimate that I had from the industry was 50 per cent or so, but David McPhee might correct me on that.

David McPhee Scottish Government
link

It is slightly more than that.

David McPhee Scottish Government
link

Yes.

Lorna Slater Green Lothian
link

That substantially removes hospitality venues from the scheme, which was their request. Again, we do not think that that will interfere with accessibility. The model in other countries is that people tend to return their bottles when they buy their groceries, whether that be at a small shop or at a larger one. They do not think so much about taking their bottles back to a nightclub, for example.

The final aspect is about the right to refuse scheme packaging in certain circumstances. That is specifically in relation to businesses who sell only some types of packaging and their having to handle other types that they would not normally do. That is a more technical aspect, but it matters to some businesses.

Those are the substantial amendments to the scheme’s operation that we are considering today.

Mark Ruskell Green Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Okay. It would be useful to get a sense of what the reaction has been from businesses that would benefit from those amendments and whether there are calls for others to be made, beyond the larger issues of glass.

Lorna Slater Green Lothian
link

The amendments were developed over several months of discussion with industry representatives. They were asking for those five changes, so we have done as they asked. The amendments were broadly welcomed by industry as helping to make the scheme workable, which is of course why we want them to be passed and covered by regulations in Scotland, so that we can demonstrate to the other UK nations that we have a workable scheme that has industry support behind it. We had not intended to bring in any more regulations to define the Scottish scheme but, depending on how the politics over the internal market act play out over the next couple of years, we might have to lodge further amendments should the UK Government impose matters upon us. At the moment, the present regulations fully comprise the Scottish scheme.

Mark Ruskell Green Mid Scotland and Fife
link

You said earlier that there is now effectively a doorstep-ready DRS in Scotland. In your discussions with Rebecca Pow and other ministers, will you be presenting it as a scheme that has effectively been designed by the industry itself?

Lorna Slater Green Lothian
link

That is a really nice way of putting it. As I have said, the regulations as they were originally passed in 2020 were made deliberately broad to allow the industry to find its way. The amendments represent feedback from the industry on the support that it would like to make the scheme work best for its members. We have gone and done what it asked us to do.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Jackie Dunbar wants to ask some questions.

Jackie Dunbar SNP Aberdeen Donside
link

I do not so much want to ask questions, convener, as get clarity so that I can try to get my head around this. We heard from Ailsa Heine that, if we were to withdraw today’s SSI and introduce a new one, because of the date, we would have to recall Parliament to ensure that the scheme did not go live in August. Is that correct?

Lorna Slater Green Lothian
link

In planning the process and looking at our options after last week’s disruption, I considered the option of working within the given parliamentary days. It is the smoothest process for ensuring that scrutiny happens and that things do not hit the cut-off within the given parliamentary days.

Jackie Dunbar SNP Aberdeen Donside
link

If that did happen, what would happen to the scrutiny? You said previously that it would go to the DPLR Committee and then have to come back to us. Should Parliament be recalled, would we have a good level of scrutiny?

Lorna Slater Green Lothian
link

I ask Ailsa Heine to review the process again.

Ailsa Heine Scottish Government
link

Under normal standing orders, Parliament has 40 days to scrutinise an affirmative instrument, and it is my understanding that the first 20 days are for the DPLR Committee to consider the regulations, which then go to the subject committee. Normally, the Government gives 54 days for scrutiny, which allows for the 40 days of committee scrutiny plus time for the regulations to be sent to the chamber for the plenary vote. That whole process would have to be severely truncated and expedited with the agreement of Parliament to allow any regulations to be approved before the end of this parliamentary term.

I am not sure what the process would be for asking Parliament to have that scrutiny time during recess. Normally, the counting days—the 40 days plus the 14 extra days that the Government gives—stop at recess and the recess dates are not counted towards those scrutiny days. An arrangement would therefore have to be made with Parliament on how the scrutiny would work. Although I do not know exactly how that process would be agreed, it would be in the gift of Parliament.

Lorna Slater Green Lothian
link

Although that mechanism for passing regulations that we know will need to be amended is, as the convener has said, a bit clumsy, it is the smoothest in terms of not having to recall Parliament while still allowing for the full scrutiny process instead of an expedited one. Once this SSI passes, I will immediately bring another one before Parliament, which will set the October 2025 date. That will allow for a normal amount of scrutiny, not some accelerated process, as we will have passed that 16 August cliff edge by passing the SSI that you are considering today.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

That probably proves that we have quite a clunky system—I think that that was the description. If there had been an act before the SSI, you could have done it by other procedures—by the made affirmative procedure, I think, for those people who are interested—but there is not, so we are struggling a wee bit with the fact that this is the only way of doing it. We cannot use the made affirmative procedure in this case, so the process appears quite clunky. On that note, I thank you for your evidence.

We move straight to agenda item 4, which is the formal consideration of motion S6M-09033, calling on the committee to recommend approval of the Deposit and Return Scheme for Scotland Amendment Regulations 2023. I remind members that only the minister or members of the committee may speak in the debate. Minister, would you like to speak to this and move the motion—Interruption.

That was a bang and a half. If you did not hear me, minister, I asked that you speak to and move the motion.

Lorna Slater Green Lothian
link

Thank you, convener, We have covered the matter extensively, so I will go straight to moving the motion.

I move,

That the Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee recommends that the Deposit and Return Scheme for Scotland Amendment Regulations 2023 draft be approved.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Would any member like to contribute?

Liam Kerr Con North East Scotland
link

I will make a brief contribution. I understand the difficulty of the timing, but I am deeply uncomfortable that the committee is almost being bounced into agreeing this motion—and I do not mean that in a pejorative way. I just find it deeply unsatisfactory to agree to a motion that we know will not be actioned next March, and I do not entirely understand why it cannot be changed. If it meant that the committee or the Parliament would have to sit during recess, that would be fine in my view—there are more than 40 days between now and 16 August. It is better to do things right, rather than quickly.

However, I appreciate that we do not have that choice, so I do not expect to vote against the motion. Indeed, it is for those reasons that I will vote for it. My observation on the substantive amendments that we looked at is that, although they might be the right way to go—and I listened to Mark Ruskell’s questions in this respect—I still find it difficult to understand why, given what we heard earlier, this has not at the least been discussed with the UK Government. The minister could have said, “Look, events of the past few weeks have caused changes to the Scottish scheme. Why are we not trying to make sure that there is alignment so that there will be no further changes?”

That is just an observation, however. I appreciate the situation that the minister has set out. For that reason, I am likely to vote for the regulations.

Mark Ruskell Green Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I welcome the SSI, which was lodged some time ago. It represents the fact that the minister and her officials have, over time, listened to business and actively engaged with the sector. As a result, business has helped shape the scheme, and we are probably as close as we can be to a consensus on what a model DRS scheme for Scotland—and, potentially, the rest of the UK—could look like.

Inevitably, there will always be sectors, particularly those that favour glass as well as the glass industry itself, that will want glass to be excluded from any scheme and which will try to seek a commercial advantage over other businesses by doing so. However, this scheme has captured the consensus and has been shaped by business; it can operate in Scotland and could be adopted across the rest of the UK.

The Government has worked long enough on this. In fact, there has been so much consultation and engagement with business that we now have a model that should set the direction for the rest of the UK with regard to interoperability. I am proud of where we as a Parliament have got to with the scheme and proud of what the Government has achieved. We will be ready to go with the scheme as soon as we are able to.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

I will be brief, as Mr Ruskell has made some of the comments that I wanted to make.

Somewhere during our robust scrutiny session, the point about the progress made in working with business got a little bit lost in amongst all the process. Mr Ruskell has put that on record pretty well. Having listened to colleagues and having asked lots of questions, I believe that this matter would benefit from more scrutiny, not less. A fresh set of regulations and a statutory instrument returning in September for scrutiny would be no bad thing for the committee and the Parliament. Supporting this statutory instrument is the way of securing that and of making sure that we do not have a scheme that starts in August—which, after all, would not be possible.

As for what Mr Kerr has just said—and I note that he tried to be conciliatory in his remarks—there have been many opportunities over the past three years for the UK Government to raise its concerns, but it did not do so until the past few weeks. We should not lose sight of that when we look at why we are in this situation. It needs to be put on the record, yet again: the requirement for a further set of regulations and further statutory instruments lies squarely at the door of the UK Government.

That said, I think that the statutory instrument that the committee has to pass is perfectly competent. If I were to be invited back to the committee in September to scrutinise the new set of statutory instruments, I would look forward to it.

11:30

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I fear that the person for whom you are substituting might not allow you to take her place. I might have misjudged that, though—I do not want to put words in her mouth.

Minister, I have a question for you to start with, before I make a comment. When do you perceive laying the set of regulations, or the statutory instrument, to replace this statutory instrument?

Lorna Slater Green Lothian
link

It will not replace it—it will just amend the date.

Lorna Slater Green Lothian
link

Yes. I hope to be able to do that before recess—that is my intention. There is a requirement for the statutory instrument that the committee is considering to pass through Parliament before I can lay that one. I am not the Minister for Parliamentary Business and I am not in charge of the timetable, but that is the intention.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

As you and I well know, it will be just a quick vote at decision time, so it is simply a question of putting it in.

So, in the regulations that you will bring in to update these regulations, it will just be a matter of amending the date. There will be nothing else in it.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

So that instrument will need a lot more scrutiny, will it?

Lorna Slater Green Lothian
link

It will have to go through the same process as every other SSI.

Lorna Slater Green Lothian
link

The parliamentary process is the process, and we need to make sure that it is followed. The number of scrutiny days and so forth is set out, and it is not something that I intend to challenge.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

So there will be no other regulations in that statutory instrument apart from those to do with the date.

Lorna Slater Green Lothian
link

Yes—sorry. There will be some consequential date changes around registration, but it will be to do with that date. There will be no more definition of the scheme in terms of the materials included in it and so on. It is specifically in order to get that date right.

As I have said, there are some consequential date changes in terms of the registration date. The registration date for 16 August, for example, required a March date, so if we were to move to October 2025, there would be other consequential dates associated with that. However, that would be the full matter.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Okay. I do not mean to labour the point, but I will just say that the process for getting us to where we are today seems very clunky. I find myself in a position where voting against this statutory instrument would put unbearable strains on businesses, but I also believe that there would have been a way of resolving this before Parliament went into recess, if there had been the will to do so. I find it particularly difficult to consider and approve something when I know that, as soon as I approve it—or as I am in the process of approving it—it is invalid. That is my position.

As no one else around the table wants to make a comment, you may make a closing statement, minister. You could of course waive that, if you would like to, and we would move directly to the decision. It is up to you, minister.

Lorna Slater Green Lothian
link

I am happy for you to move to the decision, convener.

Motion agreed to,

That the Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee recommends that the Deposit and Return Scheme for Scotland Amendment Regulations 2023 draft be approved.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

The committee will report on the outcome of the instrument in due course. I invite the committee to delegate authority to me, as convener, to finalise the report for publication. Is the committee happy with that?

Members indicated agreement.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I thank you and your officials, minister, for the time that you have given us this morning.

I briefly suspend the meeting and ask committee members to be back at 11:40.

11:33 Meeting suspended.

11:40 On resuming—

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report

No recorded division on this motion that day: decisions taken without a vote are not in the divisions feed.

  1. 09:30 Interests Procedure · 3
  2. 09:30 Decisions on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 2
  3. 09:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 238
  4. 11:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 4

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.