Labour supports the hospital at home initiative. We have already heard about the benefits of delivering healthcare external to hospitals and acute care settings, all of which are entirely valid and commendable. For a long time, we have been advocating an approach to healthcare that is based on prevention rather than reaction, and we have been arguing that reducing the pressure on hospitals and acute care settings is essential and will deliver better outcomes.
Everyone in the chamber is well aware of the benefits of early intervention. Equally, we are all aware of the consequences for hospitals and acute care settings when services that facilitate early intervention and prevention fail. Therefore, we support the principle of the hospital at home programme, and we will work with the Government to ensure that patients who are in a position to benefit from the programme are able to do so.
Throughout my time in this role, I have always done my best to be constructive, and I would like to continue that approach today. A cross-party approach to tackling the crisis in our national health service will be crucial. In the interests of co-operation, we will support the Government’s motion and the Conservatives’ amendment. In the interest of trying to make a success of the hospital at home programme, it is important that the Government acknowledges that turning it into a sticking plaster just will not suffice. If we are to make a success of the programme, we need to recognise that, in many ways, our NHS is in dire straits and that we must address the root causes of the problems that we face today.
Those problems are found across our national health service. One in seven people in Scotland is on an NHS waiting list. The social care policy programme is in tatters. More than 160,000 bed days have been lost as a result of delayed discharge in 2023 alone, and more than a million bed days have been lost as a result of delayed discharge since the current First Minister was appointed as health secretary. One in 10 general practices in Scotland no longer accepts new patients. The vacancy rate for registered nurses in district nursing is more than 11 per cent, and it is 12.5 per cent for registered nurses in community settings.
I take absolutely no pleasure in rhyming off that list of problems. I want nothing more than for each and every one of them to be resolved immediately for the benefit of patients who desperately rely on such services, because we all have skin in the game.
However, the reality is that those problems exist today, and the harsh truth is that, for as long as they do, the hospital at home programme will fail to live up to its full potential.
Of all the problems that exist, the most egregious is the workforce crisis that is engulfing the NHS and social care. As I outlined briefly, vacancies are at a record high. Given the multifaceted and multidisciplinary nature of the hospital at home programme, there is a distinct possibility that it will fail purely because of a workforce shortage. That is why our amendment sets out the need for a long-term funding settlement for the hospital at home programme. We will happily work with the Government on that, should it desire it.
Although the workforce crisis in our NHS may take some time to resolve, given the training lead times and issues around that, there is no excuse for the workforce crisis in social care. The backlog in delayed discharge is down in no small part to the lack of a social care plan. One of my primary concerns about the hospital at home programme is that it will be used to try to mask the crisis in delayed discharge.
We can see that playing out in adjacent services such as hospice care. Just a few weeks ago, I visited the Prince & Princess of Wales Hospice in Glasgow, where people highlighted the fact that one third of its beds are unusable due to the lack of specialist nursing staff.
Labour has therefore set out our plan to increase the pay of social care workers to £15 per hour, at a cost of approximately £150 million a year. We have also identified three areas of an opportunity-cost value of almost £300 million, from which that money could be found, which would ensure that we have a further economic multiplier effect in our wider economy, through the marginal propensity to consume. I call on the Government to back us in that commitment and to increase the social care pay to £15 an hour. That would go a long way to alleviating the pressure on hard-pressed social care staff and to resolving the workforce crisis in social care; and, fundamentally, it would ease the pressure on front-line services by reducing the level of delayed discharge that is clogging up the system.
The Labour party supports and commends the hospital at home programme. However, we are clear that there needs to be a realistic and pragmatic assessment about the extent to which it will be beneficial, given the crises that I have mentioned. Without a long-term funding settlement or a plan to fix the workforce crisis in our NHS, and without a long-term prospectus for the future of our social care sector, hospital at home risks becoming a mere sticking plaster—another initiative that is doomed to failure before it has gotten off the ground. That would be a real shame, because the need for such a programme to succeed is greater than ever—and, if done right, it has the potential to enable significant progress for public health in Scotland.
I move amendment S6M-09191.1, to insert at end:
“; notes that one in seven people in Scotland are on NHS waiting lists, delayed discharge remains too high, and thousands of NHS vacancies are unfilled; recognises that Hospital at Home requires sustained investment to bring hospital-standard care into the home using technology, in addition to retaining and recruiting the multi-disciplinary teams that are required; considers that Hospital at Home is being hindered by the Scottish Government’s failure to tackle the social care crisis, which is essential in helping people to live independently, and calls on the Scottish Ministers to deliver a long-term funding settlement for this programme, to take urgent action to deliver well-funded and locally available social care services by immediately uplifting social care pay to £12 per hour, with a plan to raise it to £15 per hour, and, as recommended in the Feeley Review, to remove non-residential care charges.”
15:52