I am pleased to open this afternoon’s debate on behalf of the Rural Affairs and Islands Committee. The committee is holding the debate as part of its pre-legislative scrutiny of the Scottish Government’s proposals for future agriculture policy. The purpose of that work is to inform the committee’s consideration of the Scottish Government’s proposed agriculture bill, which the committee expects to be introduced sometime later this year.
It is vital that we set the right direction for Scottish agriculture for the years ahead. We need to have a strong agriculture sector that can provide us with a secure and sustainable food supply, that maintains our high standards of food production and that helps us to tackle the twin emergencies of climate change and biodiversity loss, and, in doing so, ensures that our rural communities are viable and supported.
To achieve those aims, any new agriculture policy needs to provide our farmers, crofters and other food producers with the support, investment and—this is equally important—the clear direction that are needed in order for us to make a just transition towards a more sustainable future.
The Scottish Government launched its consultation on its proposals for a new agriculture bill in August last year. Those proposals centre on a new farm payment framework to replace the common agricultural policy following the United Kingdom’s exit from the European Union. Payments under the new framework will be subject to greater conditionality with regard to nature restoration and the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions
In February, the Cabinet Secretary for Rural Affairs, Land Reform and Islands shared with the committee a route map for agricultural reform that sets out a high-level timescale for the transition towards the future agriculture support framework. Although that information is, of course, welcome, a common thread running through the evidence that the committee has heard so far has been the concern that food producers and other agriculture stakeholders have voiced about the lack of information and detail from the Scottish Government about what a new agriculture policy intends to achieve and how it will achieve it.
The committee would therefore welcome any further information from the cabinet secretary about the Government’s proposed future agriculture policy and more clarity on the timescale for the introduction of the agriculture bill to Parliament.
The committee began its pre-legislative scrutiny in February and has heard evidence from a considerable number of individuals and organisations representing farmers and crofters, land managers and many other players in Scotland’s food supply chain. I take the opportunity to thank everyone who gave evidence to support the committee’s work. The committee took a thematic approach to gathering evidence about what a future farm payment system should look like. We held evidence sessions on climate change mitigation and adaptation, nature restoration, biodiversity loss and resilience within the food production and supply chain.
We also heard from a broad range of groups and organisations that have been involved in developing, and will be at the heart of implementing, a new agriculture policy. Those included the farmer-led climate change groups that reported in 2021 and the agricultural reform implementation oversight board. Key industry bodies engaged with the committee, including NFU Scotland, Quality Meat Scotland and the Agriculture and Horticulture Development Board. We also heard from organisations focused on the role of agriculture in addressing climate change, including NatureScot, RSPB Scotland, the Climate Change Committee and Farming for 1.5°.
All witnesses, without exception, recognised the urgent need to reduce emissions from agriculture in order to meet our challenging net zero goals and to tackle the worrying decline in biodiversity. The capacity for future payment schemes based on conditionality for emissions reduction was explored. Although there was broad agreement that a payment scheme is the best vehicle to achieve that, there were concerns about the potential impact that some of the suggested measures—particularly the reduction in livestock numbers to meet methane reduction targets—might have on agriculture.
NFU Scotland and Quality Meat Scotland, as well as the farmer-led groups, were concerned about the loss of the critical mass of livestock numbers, which might lead to a decline in Scotland’s food production supply chain as it became less economically sustainable. NFUS stated:
“The critical mass is key to maintaining our processing capacity and our ability to produce high-quality food, which is going to be the bedrock and the mainstay of Scotland’s economy going forward.”—[Official Report, Rural Affairs and Islands Committee, 22 March 2023; c 18.]
Quality Meat Scotland also warned:
“The big problem that we face is the loss of critical mass in the red meat sector. If we lose animals and primary producers—farmers—we will not have enough animals to make the rest of the supply chain viable.”—[Official Report, Rural Affairs and Islands Committee, 26 April 2023; c 2.]
That would have a negative knock-on effect and would significantly undermine the sustainability of farming and rural communities, particularly in less-favoured areas, which have considerable limitations in relation to alternative forms of farming.
Failing to consider and adequately scrutinise the unintended consequences of future agriculture policies—including the impact of conditionality—could jeopardise the primary aim of a future policy, which is to grow more of our own high-quality food, more sustainably, in Scotland.
There was real support for a sectoral approach to emissions reductions based on land use. In particular, Farming for 1.5° suggested that some sectors and areas of production must focus on baseline biodiversity and emissions targets, while others should focus on nature restoration and the sequestration of carbon. It was suggested that a future farm payment system should incentivise farmers to meet baseline targets while also rewarding those who have already made progress towards sequestration and biodiversity restoration.
It was suggested that area-based payments should be subject to conditionality to support biodiversity restoration, with farmers and crofters receiving payments based on outcomes and—crucially—on practices that will lead to desirable and positive outcomes. There was also support for whole-farm plans and for professional development and training for farmers and land managers.
NatureScot pointed out that farmers could adopt more regenerative agricultural systems in highly productive areas rather than having to set aside land for tree planting in order to promote biodiversity. Controversially, the Climate Change Committee advocates a reduction in livestock numbers and the expansion of tree planting on agricultural land, although that approach was not supported by many other witnesses.
The committee will continue to scrutinise the Government’s proposal for future agriculture policy and ensure that it delivers for Scottish agriculture and rural communities. I hope that the evidence that we have heard, and that we will hear today and in future sessions, will be taken seriously by the Government and will be reflected in new policy development.
I look forward to members’ contributions to the debate. I am sure that my committee colleagues will find it useful to hear the views of other members from all parties on the proposals for a future agriculture policy and with regard to what we need from an agriculture bill.
I move,
That the Parliament recognises the need for Scotland to develop its own agriculture policy and support post-EU exit; notes the Scottish Government’s Vision for Agriculture, which was published in March 2022, and its intention to introduce an agriculture bill in the next parliamentary year, and welcomes the Rural Affairs and Islands Committee’s evidence taking in order to fully understand the broad range of policy areas that are fundamental to a successful future agriculture policy and to ensure that the agriculture sector is a thriving part of the economy, which helps to tackle climate change, protects biodiversity and, most importantly, puts food on plates.