I am very happy to speak in the chamber in Lyme disease awareness month. This is a very personal debate for me, as I first became aware of Lyme disease through my good friend Pauline Bowie, who I have known since our university days. Pauline is now an ambassador for the Lyme Resource Centre, and she is in the gallery tonight with fellow Lyme disease sufferers, colleagues and young people from St Peter the Apostle high school in Clydebank. I warmly welcome them to our Scottish Parliament.
Working at a summer camp in 1989, Pauline noticed a small circular rash on her thigh. She was told by the director that it was probably ringworm. Over the next few years, she suffered a range of debilitating symptoms, from flu-like symptoms to inflamed joints, nausea, insomnia and dizziness. She had breathing difficulties and heart palpitations, and she was diagnosed with anxiety and hyperventilation. She was told how to use a paper bag to breathe into. She was unable to do many of the things that she loved, but she could not get answers from doctors.
Years passed and her symptoms worsened. By the mid-2000s, she had extreme joint pain. In 2017, she suffered two incidents of pain so extreme that she was hospitalised with a suspected heart attack. Dizziness, speech slurring, blurred vision and brain fog were all put down to anxiety, and tests were inconclusive. Thirty years later, after hearing that her cousin was ill with Lyme disease, Pauline googled it and was very shocked to find that she was a textbook case.
Lyme disease is caused by a bacteria called Lyme borreliosis, which can be passed on to humans by infected ticks. Ticks infected with Lyme disease are found all over the United Kingdom. There are ticks anywhere that there are pets, wild mammals and birds—in woodland, in open countryside and even in urban parks and gardens. Removing ticks quickly helps to prevent infection, but removing them incorrectly can actually increase the infection risk.
Many people with early symptoms develop a circular red skin rash around the tick bite, which is often described as looking like a bull’s-eye on a dartboard. Lyme disease can also cause flu-like symptoms, fever, fatigue and migratory joint or muscle aches and pains.
There are conflicting opinions on how best to treat Lyme disease, but it is most often treated through a course or courses of antibiotics. Lyme disease can often be treated effectively if it is detected early on, but if it is not treated early or treatment is delayed, there is a risk of developing severe and long-lasting symptoms, such as Pauline’s.
For people without the red rash, laboratory tests are used to diagnose Lyme disease. However, the tests are not sensitive and cannot tell the difference between current and past infections. There are enormous challenges in diagnosing Lyme disease. Many people do not notice that they have been bitten by a tick. It is easily missed given that some bites are as small as a poppy seed. Often, when symptoms appear, people do not associate them with ticks.
That is what happened to Lesley Paterson, world champion triathlete and Oscar-winning screenwriter, who is from my constituency. Lyme disease took her out for a year. Even now, it still impacts her, and like many others, she has no idea where or when she was infected.
What we see as the classic indicator of Lyme disease—the bull’s-eye rash—often does not look like a bull’s-eye. It can appear in different shapes and have different presentations on darker skins, and it does not appear at all in about a third of cases.
Lyme disease’s wide-ranging symptoms can look like any number of other conditions, resulting in the disease being called “the great pretender”. Symptoms that later turn out to be caused by Lyme disease are misdiagnosed as other conditions, such as anxiety or chronic fatigue.
Patients have been dismissed and told that the symptoms are in their heads. When Pauline told her doctor that she thought that she might have Lyme disease, she was told that she was jumping on a fad. Inevitably, that lack of awareness among general practitioners has a detrimental effect along existing lines of inequality. Those who are already marginalised—women, disabled people and people of colour—are less likely to get a diagnosis and timely treatment.
Lyme Disease Action developed an online training course in collaboration with the Royal College of General Practitioners, covering how to identify and treat the disease. However, the charity Lyme Disease UK notes that only a very small percentage of GPs have taken the course.
Tick bites are often associated with recreational activities, such as hillwalking, and working in sectors such as forestry and farming. However, more evidence is being found of the risk of tick bites being much closer to home. The big tick project found that one third of dogs that were checked in its study had ticks attached to them. Pet owners are at risk as ticks can drop off in the home or transfer, but 47 per cent of owners were not aware that they, too, are at risk of infection from tick-borne diseases.
The British Medical Journal has called for more national and international debates on Lyme disease, which I am glad we are contributing to today. It has also called for a solid research agenda, as well as robust public awareness campaigns. Indeed, Dr Lucy Gilbert, a senior research fellow from the University of Glasgow, has noted the need for more research into tick populations and Lyme disease in urban areas. However, funding remains a challenge.
There is huge appetite for change in this area, from committed and well-informed organisations such as the Lyme Resource Centre that are leading awareness campaigns, to a start-up in the Highlands that is developing an app to map the risk of Lyme disease. As well as awareness raising, action such as bracken control can help to mitigate risks.
The issues here are multisectoral and overlap with healthcare, education, forestry and land management, and academia. To take successful action—