I thank all those members, across parties, who signed my motion, allowing me to bring this important debate to the chamber. I also thank my constituents and the Friends of St Michael’s Hospital, some of whom are in the public gallery this evening, for their work on the campaign.
St Michael’s is a community hospital that provides end-of-life care, respite and step-down intermediary care, and it supports patients who are waiting for care packages or for placement in a care home. It is situated in Linlithgow, in the north of the county, and it supports patients from all over West Lothian.
St Michael’s hospital is the only national health service facility of its type in the north of West Lothian. The land for the hospital was owned by St Michael’s church and gifted to the health authorities at no cost in 1854, on the stipulated condition that it would remain land for a hospital facility and a garden for the people.
I understand that the former Conservative Secretary of State for Scotland Michael Forsyth MP confirmed to David Steel—not our former Presiding Officer, but his father, who was minister of St Michael’s at the time—that the land would revert, with the buildings on it, to the kirk session if it ceased to be used for the purpose for which it was given.
In August 2021, the West Lothian health and social care partnership integration joint board took the decision to close St Michael’s temporarily, using emergency powers, under pressure from short-term staff shortages across the NHS. A decision was taken to move patients and staff to Tippethill community hospital in Armadale, which allowed staff to be reassigned to St John’s hospital in Livingston. St Michael’s hospital remains closed.
In June 2022, a report to the West Lothian integration joint board contained two recommendations: that either St Michael’s should remain closed or a public consultation should be held with all relevant parties to review future bed-space requirements at the hospital. If the minister is told that there were few patients previously, that is because the IJB did not refer them.
In February this year, West Lothian health and social care partnership held a public information meeting, which was organised by the Friends of St Michael’s Hospital, on the future of the hospital. Hundreds of people attended that standing-room-only public meeting in the kirk hall, and the health and care management were left in no doubt about the importance of St Michael’s hospital to the community. Many of those who attended the public meeting had relatives who had been cared for there.
The IJB then launched a review of bed capacity with a consultation, citing moves for care at home. The review is due to report next month. However, the same IJB has since announced that it wants to outsource care at home and six care-of-the-elderly residences in the future. Taken together, that all points to an IJB that wants to own no community properties for elderly care and that exists simply to contract out home care services. That is not on. We need the public provision of quality care, and the certainty of a home for older people in our county and community hospital care when they need it.
I implore the Minister for Social Care, Mental Wellbeing and Sport to look carefully at what West Lothian IJB is doing in removing public facilities with stealth tactics over a number of years. We know that the IJB’s finances mean that it has to make savings, but we also know that it holds significant reserves. With such drastic action planned, now is the time to allow the IJB to release reserves in order to support care for our elderly population.
When I raised the need for step-down care and facilities such as St Michael’s—and specifically St Michael’s—with the First Minister in October 2021, when he was Cabinet Secretary for Health and Social Care, during questions on his winter planning and social care statement, he agreed to “stress” the need for community-based elderly nursing care and respite in the north of the county as a priority “with local partners”.
My constituency of Linlithgow is the largest in Scotland by population. West Lothian as a whole has a growing and an ageing population. It is forecast to have the fastest growth in pensionable-age population in Scotland over the next 25 years, with an increase of 44 per cent, which is twice the Scottish average. In addition, there are no hospices in West Lothian, which means that, without St Michael’s, families in West Lothian who require end-of-life palliative care to support their loved one will have to travel for almost an hour, to St Columba’s in Granton in the north of Edinburgh or to the Marie Curie hospice in south Edinburgh.
The IJB has previously used statistics that underreport the scale of population growth in neighbouring Winchburgh. Given the high price of property in Edinburgh and major population growth in Queensferry and Kirkliston, joint provision with the west of Edinburgh for elderly care at St Michael’s would surely make sense. There is a clear moral and needs-based argument to keep the site for health purposes, but there is also possibly a legal argument, if the health board thinks that it will sell lucrative land for housing, that the land might revert to church ownership.
The Friends of St Michael’s Hospital is a dedicated and committed group of volunteers, and I thank them for their work and their support and care over the years for patients and their families. They were a lifeline to the families of those who were staying at St Michael’s, and they provided emotional support to many. They also provided financial aid to families who needed that extra help—they paid for taxis and other public transport to make sure that patients got to see their loved ones when they were at their most vulnerable. As the local MSP for Linlithgow, and on behalf of all patients and families who have benefited from care at St Michael’s in the past—as patients and families will, I hope, in the future—I thank them.
We know that there are continuing challenges in securing and resourcing staffing for any expansion of care at home, and we recognise that senior managers at West Lothian health and social care partnership have been clear that no decision has been taken about St Michael’s and have made commitments to maintain the fabric of the hospital, pending their review. However, I reiterate my call to the partnership to take a strategic view in favour of using the physical, social and community assets of St Michael’s for the benefit of the growing population in the north of the county.
It is clear that there will be an on-going need for a health facility that provides end-of-life and step-down intermediary care and, potentially, new support services to match the increase in home-based care for a rapidly growing elderly population in the north of West Lothian. The strong spirit and solidarity of local people who support the retention of the hospital exist because of the extraordinary nature of the way in which St Michael’s hospital and the Friends of St Michael’s Hospital have cared for their loved ones and their families. St Michael’s hospital must be retained to benefit the communities and the families who depend on it.
17:05