I thank everyone who has contributed this afternoon. I recognise Mr Balfour’s point that the reality of politics is that the debate is not over when everything is said, but is over only once everyone has said it. However, we have had a very useful debate and the opportunity to explore a range of issues.
The bill is indeed sizeable and, to some—as was noted earlier—it might seem to be dry and technical. There is also some complexity, not least in respect of the insolvency provisions that we considered earlier. However, a detailed and methodological approach is needed to address the particular challenges of reforming law that is outdated and no longer fit for purpose.
I hope that it is clear that we listened carefully to what stakeholders, the committee and other MSPs said at stages 1 and 2, and I hope that it is clear that the bill matters. It matters to the estimated 360,910 private sector businesses operating in Scotland as at March 2022. The vast majority of those businesses—98.3 per cent of them—are small, with 49 or fewer employees.
It is clear that cheaper and less risky access to finance will provide a boost to those businesses, not just in terms of survival and making ends meet, but in terms of development and growth, by improving the facility and the ability for businesses to innovate and expand. Anything that can be done to improve the environment in which business in Scotland operates should be welcomed. Although the bill is legal and specialist, it is intended to deliver real and practical help on the ground to businesses throughout Scotland.
I was happy to lodge amendments at stage 2 to implement some of the committee’s thoughtful recommendations, particularly in relation to individual consumers. I have also been pleased to support some of the amendments that the committee made at stage 2. We have agreed some adjustments to those today to ensure that they work as intended. I hope that members will appreciate, on reflection, why we needed to reverse some of the other amendments that were made at stage 2. However, some of those reversals have come with commitments—namely, to consult further in respect of the definition of “insolvency” and to keep the threshold for encumbered property for sole traders under regular review so that it takes account of inflation.
If the bill is passed today—I sincerely hope that it will be—there will still be a lot of work to be done before the provisions will be capable of coming into effect. The provisions in relation to assignation and statutory pledge rely on the creation and operation of two new registers that will be run by Registers of Scotland. Considerable progress has already been made on the necessary technology and development; we are in a very good place, with the necessary funding also being in place. Quite detailed regulations will also need to be in place to set out the rules about use of both registers. Again, progress is being made on that. I thank the people in Registers of Scotland who are undertaking that work, and I thank them for their close and helpful co-operation with officials in the Scottish Government.
As I have mentioned, I have undertaken to consult on the complex issues around how we define insolvency for the purposes of the legislation. That will take place over the course of the next year, and any necessary regulations will be made in time for the provisions coming into force.
As expected, mention has been made this afternoon of the need to ensure that the provisions in the bill extend to financial instruments and financial collateral. I hope that I have been very clear that I am absolutely and fully committed to extending the provisions in the bill to financial instruments and financial collateral. We will work with the UK Government to have in place the necessary section 104 order to achieve that.
In that spirit, I very much welcome Mr Balfour’s remarks and his intimation that he will encourage his Conservative colleagues in the UK Government to continue their constructive engagement. I also thank the committee for taking an interest in that and for taking the step of seeking to engage directly with the UK Government. We are absolutely united in recognising the benefits that that will confer on the Scottish economy, and we want to ensure that we can achieve that section 104 order in as smooth a manner as possible, so that the provisions are ready to come online when the new registers are in place next year. Consultation will also need to be undertaken on the issue of the fees for using the registers. Again, we will be relying on and working with Registers of Scotland on that aspect of the legislation.
There is, as I said, still a lot to be done, but our target is to have all the necessary consultations, regulations and functioning registers completed by next summer. At that point, we will commence the main provisions.
Importantly, the bill incorporates powers so that we have the tools and flexibility to ensure that provisions can be kept up to date. Some of the powers are likely to be used rarely. Nevertheless, as time passes and we gain knowledge and experience of how the registers are being used and the extent to which they are being used, Scottish ministers will have—subject, of course, to scrutiny by the Scottish Parliament—the ability to, for example, specify the type of case for which registration of an assignation would be compulsory; provide a model notice of assignation; refine what constitutes a “seriously misleading” inaccuracy in the registers; extend the categories of person who are entitled to make an information request; and add to the kinds of incorporeal moveable property over which it is possible to grant a statutory pledge.
I could go on, but I hope that that illustrates that, subject to what it is reasonable to delegate, efforts have been made to future proof the bill to help it to stand the test of time. From that perspective, although I did not feel that a review duty was necessary, I have always been of the view that the legislation should and would be reviewed as necessary. The Government looks forward to the opportunity to review it in due course.
Finally, I repeat my thanks to all those who gave evidence to help to improve the bill during its parliamentary process. As has been highlighted, that has demonstrated the Scottish Parliament working at its best, with detailed scrutiny by committee and considered engagement with a range of stakeholders. The legislation, which I appreciate has taken a long time to come to fruition, is something that the Parliament collectively can be proud of. I once again put on the record my sincere thanks to the Law Commission, to stakeholders, to the committee and to everyone who has contributed to getting the bill into the state that it is in today.
I commend the motion in my name.