I am delighted to contribute to today’s extremely important motion on victims awareness week. I thank my colleague, Russell Findlay, for bringing the debate to the chamber.
Since I began working on my domestic abuse prevention bill, I have been contacted by a number of women who need help. These women have, in some cases, faced threats and abuse from violent individuals for months and sometimes even years. However, the comprehensive services that victims organisations offer mean that, even in the most difficult of cases, they are able to step in and help those women to get the support that they need.
In the past year, Victim Support Scotland has supported around 16,000 people who have been affected by crime; helped more than 5,000 witnesses in court; and successfully rolled out more than 1,000 VSS emergency assistance funds.
Another example is the social enterprise No Feart, which draws on experiences of childhood trauma and the criminal justice system to support others with lived experiences of trauma through to long-term recovery. There is also Shakti Women’s Aid, which helps black and minority ethnic women and children who have been affected by domestic abuse. The organisation raised important points with me about the lack of support for black, Asian and minority ethnic survivors of domestic abuse to attend court and the growing need for the citation letter and subsequent information to be provided in the victim’s mother tongue.
In a briefing ahead of today’s debate, Children 1st stated:
“At the moment, the system itself creates standalone trauma—often reported to be more harmful than the incident itself.”
It is this Parliament’s duty to ensure that support that is provided to victims by the third sector is met with an equally robust response from within the criminal justice system itself. As my colleague Russell Findlay highlighted, that is not always the case. An HM Inspectorate of Constabulary in Scotland report recommended that there should be increased training, understanding and a more informed approach to domestic abuse by justice professionals.
Similarly, the “Analysis of the Call for Evidence responses to the Violence Against Women and Girls Funding Review”, which was published last month, found that
“Many responses indicated that third sector organisations should act as a bridge between victims and the statutory services, encouraging reporting of”
violence against women and girls
“especially among hard-to-reach groups.”
It noted that,
“they can bring the voice of the lived experience to the statutory sector”,
and that such organisations can be
“more approachable and can be more accessible to particular groups of women, i.e., BME women, women with disabilities”.
However, respondents also wanted to see tougher punishments for abusers.
Scottish Women’s Aid and others have said that they are concerned about the impact on victims of reducing prison sentences. Recently, Kate Wallace of Victim Support Scotland told the Criminal Justice Committee that,
“Victims often feel as though they have to police the bail conditions themselves, and they often do not know what those are.”—[Official Report, Criminal Justice Committee, 11 January 2023; c 7.]
That is simply not good enough.
While we mark victims awareness week, it is important that, this week and every other week, we keep in mind the work that is carried out by organisations, staff and volunteers to improve the lives of victims in Scotland. However, should this Parliament and this SNP Government fail to adopt a victim-centred, trauma-informed approach to policy making, we risk undermining the hard work of victim support organisations and further traumatising victims.
I think that I speak on behalf of every member in the chamber when I say that, even though many of us hope that we will never have to rely on the services, we must do everything in our power to ensure that we support the organisations that champion the rights of those who do.
17:28