I am grateful for the opportunity to secure this debate for the Parliament, providing us with an opportunity to reflect on the progress that we have made in five years since introducing landmark asset transfer legislation that has empowered our communities to take on many of our public places and spaces.
Today’s debate provides us with a chance to hear about the difference that asset transfers have made locally in Scotland, enabling community organisations to take over management and ownership of many public spaces. It also creates an opportunity to consider some of the challenges that we face, such as in supporting our most vulnerable communities to engage with asset transfers.
Community asset transfer is not new. Our communities have a long history of owning and managing land and buildings. Local authorities have worked with community organisations for many years, agreeing the transfer of assets that, often, have been surplus and where the benefits of community management have been recognised. I acknowledge the hard work that has been carried out across the country by local authorities and other public service partners to develop community asset management and ownership strategies.
Since the introduction of the Community Empowerment (Scotland) Act 2015, that initial good work has been strengthened by introducing new rights for community organisations that submit asset transfers, including a right of appeal, and by placing new responsibilities on public authorities to decide on applications by set timescales, to do so transparently and to publish details of their assets and asset transfer activity annually.
Much has happened since asset transfer legislation came into force in January 2017. The Scottish Government has worked directly with the 95 public authorities—known as relevant authorities—to establish and support annual reporting processes, including by developing an annual reporting template to capture the necessary data. We also commissioned researchers at Glasgow Caledonian University to carry out an evaluation of the first three years of asset transfer activity, which reported in July 2020. We set up a national asset transfer action group of partners and community representatives to consider the Glasgow evaluation and any challenges in embedding asset transfer. In addition, we hosted two national events for asset transfer in 2021; one was for the relevant authorities and the other was for community organisations.
Through those actions, we have learned a lot about how the legislation is working on the ground. For example, we know that local authorities currently receive most requests but that there are signs that that is changing as other relevant authorities come on board and help community groups to take on their assets.
In 2017-18, 85 per cent of the total number of asset transfer requests were made to local authorities, with only 15 per cent made to other public bodies. However, by 2021-22, 46 per cent of the total number of requests were made to other public authorities, including NHS Lanarkshire, NHS Dumfries and Galloway, NHS Fife, NHS Grampian, NHS Highland and NHS Western Isles. Scottish Government agencies such as Scottish Water and Forestry and Land Scotland received requests, too.
Those figures are about more than just numbers and data; they represent a tangible change to the way in which communities now control their own place. For example, Forestry and Land Scotland transferred the Fairy Pools car park in Skye to the Minginish Community Hall Association, which went on to provide better facilities at the site. In another example, NHS Lanarkshire transferred Croy clinic to Croy Community Hub on an initial lease, with the view of transferring full ownership, to create local jobs and to enable a local community space for the development of community groups.
Since 2017, more than 350 asset transfer requests have been made using asset transfer legislation; more than 200 have been granted and many more are in progress. That has played a significant role in maintaining the upward trajectory of overall community land use in Scotland.
Of course, asset transfer sits within a wider community land use setting, in which other mechanisms are available for communities to take on land or buildings. We know from the latest report—the “Community Ownership in Scotland 2021” report, which the Scottish Government published in September 2022—that there has been a steady upward trend in community ownership, with an increase from a known 84 community-owned assets in 2000 to 711 in 2021. Over the same period, there has been more than a sixfold jump in community groups owning assets, with an increase from 74 to 484.
Our work with partners plays a vital role in embedding asset transfer policy. We fund the community ownership support service—COSS—which provides expert support and advice on the asset transfer process to community groups and to relevant authorities. We established the aforementioned national asset transfer action group in October 2020 to help us to respond to the recommendations of the Glasgow Caledonian University report, and it also helped to inform the annual reporting template that we developed to support relevant authorities to meet their statutory duty to publish asset transfer data annually.
The group also supported our work in response to the findings of the Local Government and Communities Committee in the previous session of Parliament, which made recommendations on asset transfer. We have listened to advice and, working with the national group and our partners, we have acted on those recommendations, including through our launch in September 2021 of guidance titled “Community Empowerment (Scotland) Act 2015: Asset Transfer Guidance for Considering Social Value”.
Although we rightly celebrate the success of asset transfer, we are now working to better understand the detail of the data and learning that have been gathered over the past five years. Work is under way to learn from those authorities that are promoting and embracing asset transfer, as well as to understand the cold spots of little or no activity, and why those cold spots exist. In addition, we are listening to our community organisations and acting on their feedback and experiences.
That work will form part of the wider review of the Community Empowerment (Scotland) Act 2015, which I launched in the summer at the Loch Ness community hub in Glenurquhart. There, I saw at first hand the achievements of Glenurquhart Rural Community Association, the local community organisation that, through an asset transfer in 2018, took on a former tourist information centre, which it has, by working with partners, turned it into a vibrant community hub that employs local people and operates a green transport business.
As we progress the review, learning such as that will be explored with partners and communities, which are being asked for their views on what is working and what needs to change.
I want to take a few moments to speak about some of the other key developments that the Scottish Government backs that will support communities to take on the running and ownership of more land and assets, as well as supporting wider community empowerment objectives.
Community wealth building provides national and local government, the third sector, the private sector and communities with an opportunity to approach economic development in a new way, thereby creating conditions for the people of Scotland to own a greater stake in local economies and shared wealth. Significant progress has been made in the pilot areas of Clackmannanshire, the south of Scotland, the Western Isles, and the Tay cities and Fife and Glasgow city regions, all of which are developing and embedding bespoke community wealth building action plans, with the support of the Scottish Government.
In addition, the £3 million Ayrshire growth deal community wealth building fund, which commenced delivery last April, is supporting local businesses and community organisations to grow local wealth.
Through partnerships with local communities, businesses and anchor organisations, local authorities are taking collective action to implement community wealth building by helping to create fairer local economies that tackle poverty and inequality; by focusing on wellbeing and inclusion; and by maximising the benefits of public spend and strategic decision making. Locally, that could involve small businesses or social enterprises winning procurement contracts for the first time, the creation of new local jobs or the protection of existing jobs, or communities owning and managing more local assets.
The review of the 2015 act provides an opportunity to build on those successes. We have an opportunity to progress that work further through a more comprehensive place-focused model of economic development at the local and regional levels.
To further support the implementation of community wealth building, we have committed to developing legislation and to holding a consultation to help us to gather a wide range of views on the changes that are required to grow local wealth and give communities a greater stake in the economy.
Although asset transfer is an important tool in providing opportunities to communities throughout Scotland to acquire assets and take over services, there are other options for acquisition—for example, through the various right to buy requests that are available under the Land Reform Act (Scotland) 2003 and the Land Reform Act (Scotland) 2016.
The Scottish Government also provides £10 million a year to support communities to acquire assets through the Scottish land fund. In the past five years, the fund has given grants of more than £39 million to more than 230 projects across Scotland. In 2020-21, our programme for government committed to a new five-year SLF that commenced in April 2021, and we will seek to double the SLF to £20 million by the end of this session of Parliament, enabling many more community groups to engage with public land ownership.
Our place-based investment programme embeds, at its core, community empowerment and equality, backed with an initial £325 million capital investment over the next five years to support community-led regeneration and to accelerate our ambitions for place, 20-minute neighbourhoods and town centres, helping to create the conditions that support community wealth building.
The place-based investment programme builds on the successful impact of the regeneration capital grant fund, the town centre action plans, and the partnerships and networks that have been built over a number of years. It aims to link and align all place-based funding initiatives to ensure that we have a coherent approach that will build resilient communities and promote inclusive growth and wellbeing. It is complemented by our empowering communities programme, which provides support to develop and build the capacity, resilience and sustainability of our communities, of which community ownership is a key part in helping to create more resilient and sustainable communities.
Local government is a key partner in delivering the place-based investment programme and it will receive an allocation of £140 million in capital funding during this session of Parliament. In addition to accelerating our shared ambitions for place, the funding will also contribute to net zero, wellbeing and inclusive economic development, tackling inequality and disadvantage and promoting community involvement and ownership. To complement that work, we will also support participatory budgeting and participation requests, as covered in the 2015 act.
I very much look forward to members’ contributions to the debate, as we recognise the tremendous impact that asset transfer is having in Scotland.
I move,
That the Parliament welcomes the progress that has been made to date in implementing Part 5 of the Community Empowerment (Scotland) Act 2015; recognises that ownership, lease or management of land and buildings are powerful tools for communities to drive change and achieve their shared ambitions; acknowledges the programme of support for participatory budgeting that has given communities a stronger voice in decisions on how public money is spent, and agrees that place-based, community-led regeneration can help local areas, individuals and businesses to tackle poverty and inequality, and build community wealth, on their own terms.
17:06