To ask the Scottish Government what its position is on whether the current devolution settlement has led to a position in which Scotland is considered an equal partner. (S6O-01648)
Official Report · Chamber
Devolution Settlement (Equality)
Portfolio Question Time Constitution, External Affairs and Culture
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Natalie Don-Innes SNP 2
- Angus Robertson SNP 2
The record
4 contributionsIt is clearer than ever that Scotland is not considered an equal partner under the current devolution settlement. No matter how we vote or whether we elect Parliaments that support certain policies, we can be overruled or simply told no by the United Kingdom Government. Since Brexit, the Westminster Tory Government has taken back powers from Scottish ministers and the Scottish Parliament, and the trend continues.
Now that it is clear that Scotland is not, and might never have been, an equal partner in this so-called voluntary union of nations, it is more important than ever that Scotland has a choice over its place in the UK constitution. Will the cabinet secretary comment on Gordon Brown’s recent rehashed proposals to make Brexit Britain work for Scotland? Does the cabinet secretary believe, as I do, that that underwhelming scheme falls very far short of the fairer, greener future that we could grasp with independence and restored European Union citizenship?
Many of the criticisms of the current constitutional set-up that are made by the report in question echo the Scottish Government’s criticism of the Westminster Government’s failure to respect the Scottish devolution settlement, the limitations of the existing devolved powers, the inadequacies of the existing structures of intergovernmental relations and the scale of regional inequality. All of that critique is absolutely correct.
However, I remember Gordon Brown saying in 2014 that, if Scotland voted no, we would live in a federation. That has not happened, and he is now promising even less.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 7 Dec 2022 →- Constitution, External Affairs and Culture Questions · 1
- Cinemas and Edinburgh Film Festival (Closures) Questions · 6
- Heritage Sites (Reopening) Questions · 12
- “Building a New Scotland” Questions · 9
- Independence Referendum (Supreme Court Ruling) Questions · 11
- Devolution Settlement (Equality) Questions · 4
- Retained EU Law (Revocation and Reform) Bill Questions · 4
- Scottish Independence (Support) Questions · 7
- Ukrainians in Scotland (Support) Questions · 9
- Justice and Veterans Questions · 1
- Police Officer Numbers (Edinburgh) Questions · 4
- Women and Girls Experiencing Sexual Violence (Glasgow) Questions · 6
- Jury Service (Support for Parents) Questions · 6
- Asbestos Exposure (Compensation) Questions · 4
- Security Cameras (Companies Subject to Chinese National Intelligence Law) Questions · 7
- HMP Cornton Vale (Replacement) Questions · 7
- Veterans First Point Fife Questions · 4
- Police Officer Numbers (Target) Questions · 10
- United Kingdom Climate Change Committee Reports Questions · 16
- Scottish Education System Debate · 138
- Business Motions Business motions · 17
- Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 2
- Decision Time Decision time · 15
- #IWill Week 2022 Members’ business · 9
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.