Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Cladding Review (Findings)

Topical Question Time

Tuesday 1 November 2022 Meeting of the Parliament Questions 10 contributions · 4 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

10 contributions
Mark Griffin Lab Central Scotland
link

To ask the Scottish Government what steps it is taking to address the reported findings of an independent review of the cladding remediation programme that “successful delivery of the project is in doubt with major risks or issues apparent”. (S6T-00933)

Shona Robison SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Social Justice, Housing and Local Government · Dundee City East
link

I reassure home owners that the programme is not in any way at risk. It is standard Government practice to carry out independent scrutiny of large programmes to ensure that they deliver public value and to help them to succeed. We will continue to do that, and I fully expect that home owners will find that the programme is making progress. The review recognised that cladding issues cannot be dealt with quickly, and it provided eight recommendations, which we accepted and have actioned.

As I announced in a statement in May, our single building assessment programme has changed since the review was carried out and has been expanded from 27 to more than 100 buildings. It is a complex programme that is moving forward, with assessments being completed and discussions on remediation under way.

Mark Griffin Lab Central Scotland
link

The idea that the Government has been delivering on the cladding remediation programme is farcical. Reports confirm that home owners have been given nothing more than the runaround. Risks are unmanaged, there is no plan, the damning verdict is that whatever comes next is unclear, and successful delivery is in doubt.

If there was no plan in July, that calls into question whether the statement that the cabinet secretary made in May was even accurate. All summer, I was contacted by families who were worried sick that they were living in unsafe homes that they cannot escape, because they cannot sell or remortgage. In some cases, they cannot even secure insurance.

I say to the cabinet secretary that barely a building has been made safe. The documents point out that just one of the 26 buildings in the pilot scheme is expected to be given the green light for selling or remortgaging. Does she agree that it is unacceptable that the families who contacted me over the summer have been left in absolute despair? They need to hear an update urgently.

Shona Robison SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Social Justice, Housing and Local Government · Dundee City East
link

It is important that, first of all, we recognise the concerns of home owners and families. I did that when I made my statement back in May.

We must also recognise that the process is a complex one—it is not easy. The owners of each building that is part of the programme are being kept updated by their factors. If there are issues with communications for particular buildings, I will be happy to speak to Mark Griffin about those. If we can do more to ensure that such communications happen, we will do so. A lot of discussions and meetings are taking place, and progress is being made. It is important that that is communicated. The grant-based model gives factors important roles to play, one of which is communication. When we move to a national roll-out, responsibility for communication will fall to the Scottish Government, and we want to ensure that it will be as good as it can be. If members such as Mark Griffin have suggestions about the best way to do that, of course we will listen to them.

The reports that we have received are undergoing technical review. If any issue that needs to be addressed immediately comes to light, of course that will happen. The assessments themselves require complex specialist interventions from fire engineers, who ensure that surveys are carried out to the highest technical standards, which takes time. Such skills are rare—there are not a lot of fire engineers about—so we have had to work hard to get people with the skills that we require. Of course, we will then take action based on the recommendations made by the independent fire safety professionals.

I agree with Mark Griffin that communication is important. If we need to do more in that space, we will. However, providing assurance to home owners is also important. We will do everything that we can to ensure that they are able to move forward with their lives as soon as possible.

Mark Griffin Lab Central Scotland
link

I will aim to feed back to the cabinet secretary the cases that I have been receiving. It has been difficult to do so because those who have contacted me are generally not my constituents; they are primarily home owners in the Edinburgh area. However, I will forward their concerns. I also note that, in her statement in May, the cabinet secretary promised a cross-party briefing, which, had it been forthcoming, could have provided a platform for us to share constituents’ concerns.

The documents that have been released also confirm that the cabinet secretary herself set a deadline of September for establishing an accord with house builders. We are now into November. Where is that agreement with developers?

With Julie James, the minister who is responsible for this area in the Welsh Government, the cabinet secretary wrote to the house-building sector, saying that they saw

“no reason why the Accord and Pact cannot be agreed”

over the summer, after the change in United Kingdom Government roles. Last month, the Welsh Government confirmed that it had signed up Persimmon, Taylor Wimpey, Barratt and other builders to its pact. What can the Scottish Government say about the developers that it has signed up to its accord? What contribution will they make towards remediation? For the sake of home owners, another update to Parliament by means of a statement from the cabinet secretary would definitely be helpful.

Shona Robison SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Social Justice, Housing and Local Government · Dundee City East
link

I will take those points in order. The accord is a critical part of the process. It is due to be signed in the coming weeks. We have taken time to get as many developers on board as we can. I thank Homes for Scotland and the developers that have come to the table for agreeing to step up and do the right thing for home owners. Of course, that represents their chance to put things right and reassure home owners that their homes will be fixed.

I will be happy to give a statement to Parliament. I wanted to do so once we had made sufficient progress on bringing the accord to a satisfactory conclusion. However, I am happy to come to Parliament, and I will try to do that before the end of the year if I can. I am also happy to provide a cross-party briefing to bring members up to speed with all those things. We will organise that as quickly as we can.

Miles Briggs Con Lothian
link

I agree with Mark Griffin that there is growing concern about the lack of leadership from the cabinet secretary and the Scottish Government. Our constituents expect action. I am concerned by the reports that I am getting that people living in those buildings are being told that they, rather than the developer, will have to pay. The cabinet secretary needs to be clear about how the programme will be properly resourced and funded. The accord was meant to be delivered in September, but it is now November. Can she guarantee that that work is taking place and that people living in relevant developments are being communicated with, given that they are having conversations with factors in which they are being told that they will have to foot the bill?

Shona Robison SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Social Justice, Housing and Local Government · Dundee City East
link

Let me remind Miles Briggs and other members of what I said in my statement. The reason for the accord is that we want those developers that are still in existence and that have a relationship with a building to step up, take responsibility and do the right thing for home owners. We will prioritise Scottish Government spend on buildings that are essentially orphaned buildings—that is, where either no developer can be associated with them or the developer no longer exists.

As I said, we have committed all the consequentials so far—£400 million—to the programme of work. The programme is appropriately resourced. We have expanded the programme and we are taking action to address those buildings in order of priority. So far, we have committed spend of almost £1 million on assessments. We have committed to funding assessments of all the affected buildings, so home owners will not need to pay for any of those assessments.

Many of the buildings will not require any remedial action, because they will be found to be safe. That is a good thing and will allow people to move on with their lives. Where remedial action is required, it is important that developers are held to account for those buildings for which they are responsible and that the Scottish Government uses its resources to step in for those buildings where a developer cannot be found.

I would be happy to go into far more detail by way of a cross-party briefing and a further statement, if members would find that helpful.

Bill Kidd SNP Glasgow Anniesland
link

Can the cabinet secretary advise us whether she plans to continue with gateway reviews to ensure that the programme is on track and that the complex technical expertise of external support is available to maintain and develop the programme?

Shona Robison SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Social Justice, Housing and Local Government · Dundee City East
link

Yes. We invite scrutiny of our programmes to ensure that we deliver public value to the highest of standards. Independent examination of any complex programme is standard Government practice. We welcome further independent examination of the cladding programme.

I commissioned the changes to the programme back in March, and I announced the new direction for the programme in May, having learned from the experience so far. The second gateway validated that decision, which was helpful. Of the gateway recommendations, all are on track and four out of the eight have been completed.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. Time for Reflection Time for reflection · 2
  2. Topical Question Time Questions · 1
  3. Cladding Review (Findings) Questions · 10
  4. Ferry 801 (Cost of Fitting Sensors) Questions · 10
  5. Disorder (Dundee) Questions · 13
  6. Ukraine (Humanitarian Response) Statement · 30
  7. Low Income and Debt (Report) Debate · 75
  8. Point of Order Procedure · 2
  9. Business Motion Business motions · 1
  10. Decision Time Decision time · 1
  11. World Menopause Month Members’ business · 23

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.