Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Age of Criminal Responsibility (Reports on Use of Places of Safety) (Scotland) Regulations 2022 [Draft]

Tuesday 20 September 2022 Equalities, Human Rights and Civil Justice Committee About 14:30 Subordinate legislation 24 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

24 contributions
Joe FitzPatrick SNP The Convener · Dundee City West
link

Good afternoon and welcome to the 23rd meeting in session 6 of the Equalities, Human Rights and Civil Justice Committee. We have received no apologies for this afternoon’s meeting.

Item 1 is consideration of an affirmative instrument. I welcome Clare Haughey, the Minister for Children and Young People. She is accompanied by Lynsey McKean, who is police powers team leader in the Scottish Government—you are both very welcome.

I refer members to paper 1 and invite the minister to speak to the draft regulations.

Clare Haughey SNP The Minister for Children and Young People · Rutherglen
link

Good afternoon, and thank you for your invitation to address the committee in relation to this Scottish statutory instrument.

The SSI sets out the information that will be contained in the annual report to Parliament on the use of the place-of-safety power in section 28 of the Age of Criminal Responsibility (Scotland) Act 2019. Section 28 provides Police Scotland with the power to take a child who is under the age of 12 to a place of safety when they consider that the child

“is behaving or is likely to behave in a way that is causing or risks causing significant harm to another person.”

The SSI has been developed since the 2019 act’s commencement on 17 December 2021, which means that it has been informed by the first few months of the legislation operating in practice. The police have used the power on only four occasions since December.

In developing the SSI, I have taken account of the fact that the power has been required only infrequently, and of the risk that is therefore posed in relation to compromising a child’s identity when information is reported to Parliament. The information that will be reported to Parliament, as set out in the SSI, will not contain the same level of detail as the information that Police Scotland records and provides to ministers. The essential difference is that it will not focus on the specific date, time and location of a child being taken to a place of safety; instead, the report will contain detail on the length of time that a child was at a place of safety, how many times in a month a place of safety was used, and the number of times each place of safety included in the 2019 act was used within the reporting period.

The SSI has been designed to ensure that the reports that are laid in Parliament safeguard children’s identity while furnishing Parliament with information on the safe and proper use of the power. I believe that the SSI does that without materially altering the intent or the information that ministers receive.

We collaborated with Police Scotland on the development of the instrument, to ensure that its terms are appropriate, deliverable, proportionate and underpinned by the principles of the 2019 act. We also informally consulted with stakeholders, including organisations that have a strong focus on children’s rights.

The 2019 act requires ministers to carry out a review of its operation and to consider the future age of criminal responsibility. Should the age of criminal responsibility be raised or the frequency of the power’s use increase, the regulations can be modified to require reports to include further information.

Scottish ministers will look to provide Parliament with the first report in early 2023, after the end of the first year of the 2019 act’s implementation.

I hope that that provides the committee with a helpful overview of the draft regulations.

Joe FitzPatrick SNP The Convener · Dundee City West
link

Thank you, minister. I give the floor to members who have questions.

Pam Duncan-Glancy Lab Glasgow
link

Thank you, minister, for setting out the detail of this affirmative instrument.

I was pleased to hear you make the point about raising the age of criminal responsibility, because, as you are aware, the current age of criminal responsibility in Scotland is lower than is recommended by the United Nations Committee on the Rights of the Child. Is the Government considering raising the age?

The child rights and wellbeing impact assessment says:

“the Regulations are UNCRC compliant.”

However, the legislation to which the regulations relate—the 2019 act—is not UNCRC compliant, given its incompatibility with the UNCRC in relation to the age of criminal responsibility. Will you comment on that?

Clare Haughey SNP Rutherglen
link

I will take the first part of that question and then I will hand over to Lynsey McKean on compliance.

The 2019 act placed a duty on the Scottish ministers to review its operation in general and with a view to considering the future age of criminal responsibility. The three-year review period started on 17 December last year, which was the day that section 1 of the act came into force. In carrying out that review,

“the Scottish Ministers must consult such persons as they consider appropriate”

and must lay a report before the Parliament within 12 months of the completion of the review period.

An advisory group has been established to support that work and it has met since summer 2019. The review will ensure that the operational learning and experience from the implementation of the act will inform the discussions that we have about the future age of criminal responsibility in Scotland.

I hope that that gives the member an overview of some of the work that is going on. I am sure that we will come back to the matter in future as the review reports.

Lynsey McKean Scottish Government
link

I can provide a slight overview on the CRWIA. The impact assessments were specifically for the SSI and, therefore, concerned the use of the place of safety power rather than the act in general. The age of criminal responsibility is currently under the UNCRC age. As the minister explained, there will be a review and we will consider whether the age of criminal responsibility can and should be increased. The CRWIA is simply about the use of the place of safety power. That is why our analysis of the SSI says that the regulations are UNCRC compliant.

Fulton MacGregor SNP Coatbridge and Chryston
link

Like Pam Duncan-Glancy, I welcome the talk about the possibility of the age of criminal responsibility being increased because, when we scrutinised the Age of Criminal Responsibility (Scotland) Bill, that was a major talking point for the committee members who were involved in it. The same is true for the place of safety power, which is what the regulations are about. I welcome the explanation that the minister gave, in that the power has been used only four times.

I ask the minister to answer a question that has come up through some of my constituency work. Because of the legislation that is now in force, some constituents are under the impression that the police can no longer talk to children under the age of 12—it is not about charging them but about talking to them. Is the minister able to confirm that that is not the case and that the police can engage with children, as they can with any other member of the community? That is the advice that I gave to my constituent but he asked that I raise it in the Parliament.

Clare Haughey SNP Rutherglen
link

Yes, I confirm that that is correct. The police can engage with children who are under the age of 12.

Fulton MacGregor SNP Coatbridge and Chryston
link

It is really helpful to have that on the record.

Maggie Chapman Green North East Scotland
link

Thank you, minister, for providing the information that you have provided so far.

I ask for clarity on the types of information that will be reported. Will we be able to connect them? For instance, when a child is being violent or is likely to cause violence to somebody else, then and only then can they be kept in a police cell and there is provision to report that. If their violence is directed at themselves only, will we be able to connect the nature of the behaviour with where they are kept if it is not a police cell?

Clare Haughey SNP Rutherglen
link

It would be helpful to establish for the committee and for the record that a police cell would be used only in one rare circumstance, which is when a child behaves in an exceptionally violent manner or their behaviour poses extreme risk to someone else.

Under the place of safety power, it would be unusual for the police to take a child to a police station, never mind to take the step of putting them in a police cell. If police had concerns about a child and were using the power, they would contact social work and the local authority to try to identify a relevant place that would best meet the child’s needs for a place of safety. Local authorities could identify various places; it could be a care home, or, if that child had identified medical needs, it could be a hospital. A police station would be the last resort, and the use of a police cell would be in extremis.

Maggie Chapman Green North East Scotland
link

Given what you say, which is a welcome clarification, it will be possible to identify the types of behaviour that are connected with the use of a cell as a place of safety. Will it be possible to identify the types of behaviour that are associated with other places of safety?

Clare Haughey SNP Rutherglen
link

There would be only one reason for a child to be kept in a cell as a place of safety, and that would be, as I outlined earlier, if they were behaving in an exceptionally violent manner or posing an acute threat to someone else.

On why someone would go to another place of safety, the police would liaise with social work, which would take a holistic view using a getting it right for every child approach to consider what is in the best interest of that child and where would best suit their needs. Social work would consider the situation from a child protection and child safeguarding point of view in relation to whether the child needed to go to a place of safety until they were able to be returned home or to another appropriate adult.

Maggie Chapman Green North East Scotland
link

Okay. My question was about connecting the numbers with the different locations.

Clare Haughey SNP Rutherglen
link

Lynsey McKean will be able to tell you about that.

Lynsey McKean Scottish Government
link

There is a provision in the SSI that talks about

“the nature of the behaviour or likely behaviour which was considered to be causing or risk causing significant harm to another person”.

In essence, that provision asks for a report to be produced stating why a child has been taken to a place of safety and what the nature of their behaviour was. Police Scotland records will have dropdown menus. The information will be quite high level and will not go into too much detail, so that we do not risk identifying a child.

Maggie Chapman Green North East Scotland
link

Of course; that is where I was going with the question.

Lynsey McKean Scottish Government
link

However, there will be a connection in relation to why a child is in a place of safety.

Joe FitzPatrick SNP The Convener · Dundee City West
link

Do members have any further points or questions?

As there are no further indications, we move on to agenda item 2, which is consideration of the motion to approve the affirmative instrument. I invite the minister to move motion S6M-04890.

Motion moved,

That the Equalities, Human Rights and Civil Justice Committee recommends that The Age of Criminal Responsibility (Reports on Use of Places of Safety) (Scotland) Regulations 2022 draft be approved.—Clare Haughey

Motion agreed to.

Joe FitzPatrick SNP The Convener · Dundee City West
link

I invite the committee to agree to delegate to me the publication of a short, factual report on our deliberations on the affirmative SSI that we have considered today. Is that agreed?

Members indicated agreement.

Joe FitzPatrick SNP The Convener · Dundee City West
link

That concludes consideration of the affirmative instrument. I thank the minister and her officials for attending; you are good to go.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report

No recorded division on this motion that day: decisions taken without a vote are not in the divisions feed.

  1. 14:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 24
  2. 14:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 8

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.