To ask the Scottish Government what its response is to the findings of the health and care experience survey 2021-22 in relation to patient satisfaction with GP services. (S6O-01318)
Official Report · Chamber
General Practice (Patient Satisfaction)
Portfolio Question Time Health and Social Care
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Humza Yousaf SNP 4
- Mercedes Villalba Lab 2
- Kenneth Gibson SNP 1
- Annabelle Ewing SNP 1
- Tess White Con 1
The record
9 contributionsAny reduction in patient experience is regrettable, but I hope that the context of that particular survey is well understood. I am certain that it is understood by Ms Villalba and members throughout the Parliament. That context is, of course, the pandemic. Guidance was issued to GP practices not to treat patients face to face unless that was clinically necessary; social distancing was introduced in practices; and, although there were more remote consultations, electronic booking systems were used less, as existing systems could not screen for Covid-19 symptoms.
We will continue to invest in GP practices. We want people to have access to those services at similar levels to those that existed pre-pandemic. The health and care experience survey is a vital tool for us, in that it gets us direct feedback from patients across the country.
The health and care experience survey results show that patients are dissatisfied with GP services at medical practices that were put out to tender in Aberdeen earlier this year. I have shared with the cabinet secretary the testimonies of patients at Old Aberdeen medical practice. In a letter to me today, the cabinet secretary said that his officials have communicated his
“expectation that GP practice contract monitoring should resume in Aberdeen as soon as is practically possible”.
However, what about the declining standards that have been reported in recent months? Will the cabinet secretary request that NHS Grampian sets out a plan to address the issues that have already been identified by patients such as those at Old Aberdeen?
Ms Villalba raises a fair point. Some of the scores in the health and care experience survey, for example for the Newburn practice, were far from acceptable. Some scores were far below the Scottish average. We have to recognise, too, that some were above the Scottish average. However, scores in relation to accessibility and the ability to get an appointment within three working days were particularly low.
I will ask my officials to reach out to local partners to determine the improvement plan that those practices will put in place, to give reassurance about the actions that will be taken to improve the patient experience.
link
Does the cabinet secretary agree that much patient frustration lies with the often opaque appointment systems that some GP practices use? I have heard of ill constituents calling 100 to 150 times to get through to some practices, if they got through at all.
What steps can the Scottish Government take to ensure that systems whereby folk know that they are in a telephone queue are implemented as standard?
Kenny Gibson makes a good point. There is no doubt that a lot of the understandable frustration of members of the public comes from when they have to phone up a general practice, because whether they get through is a game of Russian roulette. I hope that that happens only in a minority of cases—I do not doubt that it is the minority—but I take what the member says on board. I had a discussion this morning about the fact that every general practice should have in place pre-bookable appointments. I accept what Kenny Gibson says and am happy to keep him and other members up to date as we progress the matter.
There is a supplementary question from Tess White.
Friockheim health centre in Angus got a 95.46 per cent positive score in the health and care experience survey, which was the highest score across Tayside. However, difficulties in recruiting GPs to the surgery meant that it closed earlier this year, which moved 3,000 patients elsewhere. That was another huge blow for rural patient care.
The Scottish Government committed to a £20,000 golden hello to help to fill rural vacancies. Why is that not working?
There were particular issues with that practice, which were raised with me by the constituency MSP at the time. It is right that such matters are taken forward at local level.
The member is correct that we have a number of incentives in place to make general practices in rural and remote areas more attractive, such as the golden hello scheme, the GP speciality training bursary and the Scottish graduate entry medicine programme, the first cohort of which has just graduated. I hope that all those incentives, taken together with the work that we are doing on the back of Sir Lewis Ritchie’s report, will encourage more and more doctors and GPs to take up roles in remote, rural and island communities.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 7 Sep 2022 →- Health and Social Care Questions · 1
- General Practitioners (Menopause and Perimenopause Training and Development) Questions · 10
- Covid-19 Recovery (Support for Primary Care Services) Questions · 8
- General Practice (Patient Satisfaction) Questions · 9
- Alcohol-related Deaths Questions · 7
- National Treatment Centres (NHS Tayside and NHS Fife) Questions · 4
- General Practitioner Pensions (British Medical Association Guidance) Questions · 6
- NHS Orkney (Meetings) Questions · 5
- Health Practitioner and General Practitioner Vacancies (Aberdeenshire) Questions · 5
- Social Justice, Housing and Local Government Questions · 1
- Single Building Assessment Programme (Cladding Removal) Questions · 9
- Inflation, Energy Prices and Interest Rates (Impact on Household Costs) Questions · 6
- Refugee Accommodation (Support for Local Authorities) Questions · 6
- Building Standards (Price of New Homes) Questions · 5
- Housing Waiting Lists Questions · 5
- Children in Temporary Accommodation Questions · 5
- Public Sector Pay and Emergency Budget Review Statement · 47
- Programme for Government (Cost of Living) Debate · 110
- Business Motions Business motions · 2
- Parliamentary Bureau Motion Business motions · 2
- Point of Order Procedure · 2
- Decision Time Decision time · 1
- Institutional Racism in Sport Debate · 19
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.