Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Gas Boiler Replacement

Portfolio Question Time Net Zero, Energy and Transport

Wednesday 29 June 2022 Meeting of the Parliament Questions 9 contributions · 5 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

9 contributions
Pauline McNeill Lab Glasgow
link

To ask the Scottish Government what range of heating systems it anticipates will replace gas boilers in the near future. (S6O-01292)

Patrick Harvie Green The Minister for Zero Carbon Buildings, Active Travel and Tenants' Rights · Glasgow
link

“Heat in Buildings Strategy—Achieving Net Zero Emissions in Scotland’s Buildings” identifies priority technologies that are available for deployment in the near term. Those that are relevant to homes that currently use gas boilers are—first of all, of course—energy efficiency improvements; individual heat pumps in certain buildings that currently use mains gas, namely those where assessment indicates short-term cost effectiveness and those in areas that are least likely to convert to hydrogen in the future; and heat networks in areas that are deemed to be suitable for them. Those are regarded as no-regrets and low-regrets options as, across all plausible pathways to net zero, they are likely to be the most cost effective zero-emissions options in the buildings that are identified.

Pauline McNeill Lab Glasgow
link

Some already available low-carbon systems, including electric boilers and heat pumps, have limitations. Heat pumps are disruptive to install and are simply not practical or even possible for many households. Where they are viable, they are often prohibitively expensive. Electric boilers are costly to run.

Lord Willie Haughey, who is the biggest provider of heat pumps in the country, does not believe that they are a suitable replacement for domestic boilers. Will the minister tell me which low-carbon heat source, that would be comparable to the cost of a gas boiler, the Government currently recommends for houses and flats where people cannot afford, or are unable to install, heat pumps?

Patrick Harvie Green The Minister for Zero Carbon Buildings, Active Travel and Tenants' Rights · Glasgow
link

I have had the opportunity to meet Lord Haughey and discuss the issues with him. I know that he has strong views on the matter. However, the experience that we have and the comparable data that we have from countries that already have a long history of using heat pumps and heat networks show that they will be effective in Scotland.

As Pauline McNeill has pointed out, there are additional challenges in relation to flats and tenements, which make up about 40 per cent of Scotland’s homes, so it is clearly important that we make progress in that part of the domestic sector to meet our statutory climate change targets. It is a complex area, which is why we have established a tenements short-life working group to provide recommendations to the Scottish Government on regulating those homes. That group will provide its recommendations by the end of the year and we will respond by setting out our proposed approach as part of the forthcoming consultations.

It might well be that heat networks play a significant role in tenements and flats, compared with heat pumps at an individual level.

Paul McLennan SNP East Lothian
link

As is set out in “Heat in Buildings Strategy”, when a heat pump replaces a modern efficient gas boiler, the greater efficiency of the heat pump might be insufficient to offset the higher price of electricity, which could increase the cost for the household. Therefore, will the Scottish Government urge the United Kingdom Government to rebalance energy prices to reduce the difference in unit costs between gas and electricity?

Patrick Harvie Green The Minister for Zero Carbon Buildings, Active Travel and Tenants' Rights · Glasgow
link

Yes, indeed.

Of course, there are many areas where heat pumps are already being deployed and where, combined with good levels of energy efficiency, the overall cost is coming down and will continue to come down. However, we have consistently called on the UK Government to take urgent action, using its reserved powers, to rebalance energy prices, so that the running costs of zero emission heating systems are comparable to, or more favourable than, fossil fuel incumbents.

We are again calling on the UK Government to take full account of the needs of Scottish consumers, particularly those who are suffering most from the impact of soaring energy bills when they proceed with rebalancing the costs of energy bills.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

The number of boilers that need to be replaced in the coming years to meet the Scottish Government’s target is significant, to say the least. What measures is the Scottish Government taking to ensure that there is a sufficient number of professionals qualified to install and maintain heat pumps and other renewable heat technologies, in order to deliver the transition on schedule, and to prevent a lack of available contractors pushing up installation and servicing costs?

Patrick Harvie Green The Minister for Zero Carbon Buildings, Active Travel and Tenants' Rights · Glasgow
link

Mr Whittle is quite right to point out that not only the scale of installations that we need to see in the coming years but the acceleration toward much more rapid installation will be significant challenges. The work that we are doing on supply chains is critical, both in terms of the supply of the kit to be installed and in terms of the skills that are required to do that.

However, we see the situation very much as an opportunity, and not just as a challenge. We estimate that an additional 16,400 jobs can be supported across the economy by the end of this decade as a result of the investment in the deployment of zero emissions heat, and it is by giving that strong signal of our intention to regulate that we will give confidence to those who are investing in the manufacturing, skills and capacity to do the installation work.

Liam McArthur LD The Deputy Presiding Officer · Orkney Islands
link

I am conscious that there is a lot of interest in this portfolio, so I ask for briefer questions and answers.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. Point of Order Procedure · 3
  2. Covid-19 Recovery and Parliamentary Business Questions · 1
  3. Covid-19 Recovery (Staff Shortages) Questions · 8
  4. Covid-19 Recovery Planning (Access to Interpreters and Translators) Questions · 4
  5. Covid-19 Ventilation Short-Life Working Group Questions · 7
  6. Scottish Elections (Secret Ballot) Questions · 5
  7. Covid-19 Recovery Strategy (Community Resilience and Mental Health) Questions · 6
  8. Proposed Brexit Freedoms Bill (Impact on Legislative Programme) Questions · 6
  9. Covid-19 Recovery Strategy (NHS Recovery) Questions · 4
  10. Covid-19 Booster Vaccination Programme Questions · 4
  11. Net Zero, Energy and Transport Questions · 1
  12. Gas Boiler Replacement Questions · 9
  13. Publicly-owned Bus Services Questions · 13
  14. Heat in Buildings Strategy Questions · 9
  15. Energy Performance Certificate Rating (Grant for Home Owners) Questions · 4
  16. Renewable Energy (Community Involvement) Questions · 5
  17. Railway Station for Newburgh (STAG Appraisal) Questions · 8
  18. Water Quality (Rivers) Questions · 9
  19. National Generation Target for Solar Energy Questions · 5
  20. Rural Affairs and Islands Questions · 1
  21. Rural Communities (Storms) Questions · 8
  22. Crown Estate Scotland (Meetings) Questions · 6
  23. Seed Potato Industry (Impact of Brexit) Questions · 5
  24. Salmon Scotland (Brexit) Questions · 6
  25. Scottish Animal Welfare Commission (Greyhound Racing) Questions · 6
  26. Food Production Questions · 8
  27. Islands Bond Scheme Questions · 6
  28. Child Poverty Statement · 32
  29. Social Security (Special Rules for End of Life) Bill Bill debate · 12
  30. Northern Ireland Protocol Bill Bill debate · 42
  31. Fireworks and Pyrotechnic Articles (Scotland) Bill Bill debate · 28
  32. Business Motion Business motions · 22
  33. Parliamentary Bureau Motion Business motions · 2
  34. Decision Time Decision time · 19
  35. Scotland’s Companies Members’ business · 8

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.