Today is motor neurone disease global awareness day, when people around the world who are affected by motor neurone disease remember those whom they have loved and lost to that devastating terminal disease. Here in the Scottish Parliament, we, as a community, will be no different—there will be friends and loved ones who are no longer with us. During the debate, we will no doubt hear about some of those people. For some colleagues in the chamber, they will include Gordon Aikman, whose loss is still very much felt in this place.
This debate is focused on housing and on how we better support those who are currently living with MND. On that front, I am sure that we will agree that much remains to be done. I thank the many members who signed my motion, allowing me to secure a debate on addressing the housing needs of people with motor neurone disease. I also thank MND Scotland for its powerful, sobering and challenging report “No time to lose”, which gathers much of the vital data and, importantly, captures the crucial lived experience and reality of the individuals who are living with MND and of their families.
My thanks also go to the families who have shared their stories. That includes Marie, whose husband Ian had MND; Beverley, whose husband Alan had MND; and Lynn, whose father-in-law Drew had MND. They all played pivotal roles in MND Scotland’s research, and they are in the public gallery this evening. I thank them for their attendance and their contribution. That is exactly where the debate must begin.
I will quote two examples of lived experience directly from the report. The first is one that I raised at First Minister’s question time a few months ago. Marie, whom I just mentioned, told MND Scotland:
“My husband lived in the living room with no shower facilities at all. We were washing him out on the decking with buckets of water. No dignity in that whatsoever”.
The report notes that,
“11% of people affected by MND reported waiting more than a year for a wetroom”.
For some, the wait is longer than the time they have left—we should let that sink in. We must do better.
Among the local authorities that responded to MND Scotland,
“the average waiting time for wetrooms to be fitted in 2020-2021 was 158 days.”
However, one local authority reported an 80.7-day average, while another reported a 256-day average—that is three months in comparison with eight and a half months. Every local authority must strive to be better, but such regional variations highlight that improvements can surely be made by learning from best practice.
With regard to the requirement for a ramp, a family member of another MND suffer said:
“We got in touch to apply for a ramp and we were asked by the local council if he could still walk. He said yes, and so they said, we’ll not look into it until you can’t walk ... He asked how long the waiting list was and it was 9 months. So, they wanted us to wait 9 months from the point that he couldn’t get out”.
There has to be a better way to deal with adaptations like that. The approach needs to be proactive, not reactive or heavily delayed. People cannot be prisoners in their own homes.
For ramps, there is an average waiting time of 149 days. However, the report notes that
“one local authority said that they had an average waiting time of”
just
“23 days, while another local authority had an average waiting time of 475 days.”
Again, the regional variations are stark. It cannot be right for people to face a wait of 15-and-a-half months to have a ramp installed when the average prognosis for someone who is living with MND following diagnosis is just 18 months.
The MND Scotland report makes various recommendations regarding adaptations. Understandably, MND Scotland calls on the Scottish Government
“to require local authorities to formally fast-track applications for adaptations for people with MND”,
and it suggests that certain social security forms could be used to underpin such a scheme. That is a powerful call.
Of course, there may be resource implications, and increased investment in resource may be required. I do not doubt that there is a challenge in identifying and securing that resource, and we should not pretend otherwise. However, I very much hope that, with cross-party purpose, we can find a way forward.
We also need to ensure that, even if a property is not externally accessible, that cannot be used as a justification not to adapt it internally. MND Scotland has reported that that has happened far too often. It is hardly surprising that MND Scotland has called its report “No time to lose”. We, in this place, must do anything that we can to allow those who are living with MND to spend as much of the precious time that they have left making invaluable memories rather than having a prolonged fight to have their housing needs met.
The properties that we build today must be future proofed to ensure that they are fit for purpose in years to come. As our life circumstances change, including our health, we increasingly need housing stock that is both accessible and easily adaptable. That should be dealt with at the design-and-build stage. Trying to look for imperfect housing solutions to support accessibility both internally and externally, which can be difficult to resolve, must increasingly become a thing of the past, as must the need for people to move properties in the first place.
I know that Glasgow City Council has been keen to see such future proofing, having championed the Glasgow standard for developments, along with attracting public subsidy and seeking to ensure that 10 per cent of new properties are wheelchair accessible across all tenures. However, I note that I could not get data in relation to waiting times in Glasgow. I am looking to meet the council soon to discuss how we can work in partnership with it and with housing associations to get that data and drive improvements in that regard.
I also acknowledge the Scottish Government’s work in this area. The Scottish Government is investing around £16 billion to deliver 100,000 additional affordable homes by 2032, with a minimum of 70 per cent of those being for social rent. That offers a real opportunity to ensure that we future proof all new properties for families across all tenures. I know that the Scottish Government is keen to see that happen as it develops a common housing standard as part of its work on the strategy outlined in “Housing to 2040”.
In the meantime, however, there remain significant issues over agreed definitions of what constitutes an accessible home in the first place, as well as various other matters on which more must be done. Likewise, much more needs to be done to ensure that the various allocation policies of councils and various housing associations are better aligned and that the housing needs of those who are living with MND are more consistently taken into account within those policies. For my part, I will—as I have said—arrange to meet colleagues in Glasgow City Council to see what more they can do, in partnership with housing providers, to better meet the housing needs of those who are living with MND.
I know that the First Minister pledged that she would take the time to consider the various recommendations in the MND Scotland report “No time to lose”. I look forward to hearing the thoughts of colleagues on the issue this evening, as well as an update from the Cabinet Secretary for Social Justice, Housing and Local Government on how the issues in the report are being addressed. In particular, we need robust, reliable, comparable and routinely collected data on the wait for adaptations across all 32 local authorities. We need to see the waiting times reduced and the significant gaps in performance across local authorities narrowing. That needs to include fast tracking as required.
Similarly, we need meaningful comparisons in respect of how local authorities and housing associations use their allocation policies to support the housing needs of those who are living with MND. We also need to build homes that are fit for the future. I know that there is much good work going on, but I am conscious that, as the title of the report suggests, we have no time to wait.
For some of the people who are in the gallery today, time ran out for their loved ones. Together, across parties and across Parliament, we must do better. I thank them for taking the time to listen to my contribution here this evening.
17:19