I commend Dr Allan for securing the debate, the powerful way in which he narrated the circumstances of his constituents on Great Bernera and the way in which he explained the powerful and intrinsic links between land ownership, development and sustaining a growing population. I also recognise the contributions from colleagues across the parties that were delivered in a constructive and thoughtful tone.
No landowner should ever be able to exert such control over the lives of people who happen to live on land that they own. That is especially so in the case of Great Bernera, given that the previous owner had already given the community first refusal to purchase the island following his death in 2012. When it was put to the community, 85 per cent of them turned out to vote on the buyout. In total, 142 backed the purchase of the island, with 37 against.
The community trust received £100,000 from the Scottish land fund, financed by the Scottish Government, to help to purchase the 2,260 hectares of the Great Bernera estate, including 69 crofts around Kirkibost, Tobson, Hacklete, Breaclete and Croir. Ideas for boosting the island’s economy range across various areas and types of development, including renewable energy and, indeed, a pier.
Why has that not happened? Other crofting communities have faced similar challenges and succeeded. In 2007, the Galson Estate Trust took ownership of 22,000 hectares in the north of the Isle of Lewis. On the same island, Pairc Trust took ownership of 11,000 hectares in 2015. Neither of those buyouts was without its challenges, most notably in the case of Pairc Trust, but both succeeded.
The most obvious answer lies in the tenacity and belief of the communities themselves. Both communities believed that they could take on the running of the land around them and improve the circumstances of their own communities in doing so. Both communities were determined to see that through, no matter what obstacles were put in their way.
The Scottish Government brought in legislation that was aimed at giving rights to communities to purchase land, and the crofting community right to buy was aimed at just this type of situation. However, it is notable that neither of the two successful groups concluded the transfer of the estates using the right to buy. In the end, both concluded the transfer through a negotiated sale, and the preferred way of achieving these outcomes should be both parties reaching common ground and deciding on the way forward. In the case of Pairc, it took several years and a few legal challenges, but it still got there.
Although neither community concluded their deal using the right to buy, it is equally worth noting that, without that right to buy, it is unlikely that either would have got a seat at the table. Both communities began the right-to-buy process and, through using it, brought the owners of the estates to a position of either negotiating with the community or facing a compulsory purchase through the right to buy. The right to buy is a strong tool for a community to have at its disposal.
In the case of Great Bernera, the community is facing some of the same challenges that the Pairc Trust faced. It has an owner who, through the various means at their disposal, is not willing to entertain any discussion with the community about it purchasing the whole estate. They are exerting influence on those who live on land that they own—to what ends, we can only speculate—making it more difficult for the people who live there to plan for any kind of future.
Any owner of land has responsibility to the land itself and to those who call it their home. The Scottish Government’s land rights and responsibilities statement, which was published in 2017 and is the first statement of its kind in the world, says exactly that in two of its principles:
“The holders of land rights should exercise these rights in ways that take account of their responsibilities to meet high standards of land ownership, management and use. Acting as the stewards of Scotland’s land resource for future generations they contribute to sustainable growth and a modern, successful country”;
and
“There should be greater collaboration and community engagement in decisions about land.”
If the Great Bernera Community Development Trust feels that those principles are not being followed, there is the crofting community right to buy. The trust has already been investigating that route, and it has been in discussion with Scottish Government officials. Admirably, the trust has continued to pursue the negotiation route, but I recognise that there is a view that the time has now come for a more forceful line of action. Officials are considering how the trust could access the right to buy route and they will continue to do so, as they did in the Pairc and Galson cases.
Looking forward, I note that, as has been touched on during the debate, the 2021-22 programme for government committed to introducing a further land reform bill during the current parliamentary session. During the summer, we will work with all stakeholders, including landowning interests, to develop policy and legislative solutions to progress our proposals. We will undertake a wide-ranging consultation on proposals for the bill, which we aim to introduce by the end of 2023. Our proposals will comply fully with the ECHR, including the right to private property, and with terms of the current devolution settlement, but they will also be ambitious and aimed at making sure that the land plays its full part in delivering the vision set out by the just transition commission of a fairer, greener future for all. That reflects the principled position of the Scottish Government and our explicit commitment to respecting, protecting and fulfilling human rights for every member of society.
The programme for government also committed to doubling the Scottish land fund to £20 million by the end of the current parliamentary session. The fund was put in place to make it possible for community groups to apply for awards to purchase assets, no matter which route that ownership takes.
I close by congratulating Great Bernera Community Development Trust on continuing to persevere in the face of adversity, and I encourage it to pursue the purchase by any means at its disposal. Indeed, in responding to Dr Allan’s specific request, I hope that the land fund will now be able to enter into more detailed discussions with the buy-out trust to examine the options that it wishes to pursue.
The crofting community right to buy has never been used to completion, but maybe it is about time that it was. In this case, it might be able to bring the owner to the negotiating table. If not, I feel that this community is the type to follow through with its plans and take it as far as it can until it becomes the owner of the land.
Meeting closed at 20:24.