I am delivering this speech on behalf of my colleague Graeme Dey MSP, who is ill. I am privileged to have been asked to do so, and I imagine that my role in the Scottish Parliament branch and executive committee of the Commonwealth Parliamentary Association might have been a factor in that. In 2013, I visited the Falkland Islands on behalf of the Scottish Parliament to take part in a conference on the issue of self-determination for the islands, which is an issue that Graeme Dey’s speech touches on. From this point on, this speech is from Graeme Dey.
Any commemoration demands careful reflection on an event’s impacts and legacies, and one marking a 40th anniversary requires a particular focus. Many, if not most of us, in the chamber will have some recollection of the Falklands conflict, and I am grateful to colleagues who supported the motion and those who are contributing this evening. However, a recent survey by Help for Heroes found that almost half of 18 to 34-year-olds do not know when the Falklands war happened; indeed, more than a quarter of them had not even heard of it. Based on the age profile, that is perhaps not surprising, but it is important that we do not allow that conflict to join the Korean war in being felt by many of those who served in it as a forgotten war.
Veterans and their sacrifice cannot be forgotten. It is crucial that we remember those who lost their lives and those who were left mentally and physically scarred by events 40 years ago. When we reflect on past conflicts, it can be easy to get caught up in dates, overall narratives and accounts of decision making of political leaders. One of Mr Dey’s abiding personal memories, as a young journalist at the time, was of an infamous tabloid newspaper front page reporting the sinking of the Belgrano. That very much returned to the forefront of his mind when watching a recent documentary on the war and hearing a British naval veteran speak of his mixed emotions on hearing of that event. The euphoria over a significant win for his side in the conflict was immediately tempered by recognition that many fellow mariners had perished.
In reflecting on what unfolded in the south Atlantic, it is essential that we focus on those individual stories and sacrifices on the front line. The first front line, in the Falklands, consisted of 32 local defence force volunteers and the navy personnel there at the point of invasion, none of whom had gone there expecting to see action. At just 67 men, the marine contingent, which was known as naval party 8901, showed a bravery and resistance that went unrecognised for too long.
In a recent documentary, Major Mike Norman, who led those men in a vastly underresourced defence against an 800-strong landing party, described how certain of death he was. Many tabloid headlines at the time painted Norman and his men as cowards, but their efforts, which have now been acknowledged, quash any such claim. During the several hours of fighting, around 6,500 rounds of ammunition were discharged, casualties were inflicted and arms were eventually laid down only on the orders of the British governor. After being sent home, most of the marines immediately volunteered to head back and ended up there as part of the forces who recaptured the islands.
The 45 Commando unit, which is based in Arbroath, in Mr Dey’s constituency, played a significant role in the Falklands, being among the very first troops to depart, with Cabinet Secretary Keith Brown among them. The 45 were to become known as the yompers, due to the extreme miles that they had to march, or yomp, in grim conditions on those small islands, 8,000 miles from home. They followed a 110-mile route with constant diversions and detours, during which everything that they had was carried on their backs.
James Kelly, a young second lieutenant talked of going for 44 days without fresh water and a change of clothing and being freezing cold and soaking wet, with wind chill temperatures well below zero. The marines saw ships being hit and sunk, and friends and colleagues injured. That must have been unimaginably hard on all involved, but there were to be tough, heart-breaking experiences for those back home, too. Theresa Davidson was just 25 when she lost her husband, Clark Mitchell of the Scots Guards, on the final day of the Falklands conflict. He was one of eight Scots Guards to lose their lives that day. All of that is a reminder that there is nothing—nothing—glorious about war.
Apart from the liberation of the islands and the sending of a clear message that the right to self-determination is to be cherished and protected, the Falklands war proved important in another way, in that it led to a re-evaluation of previous perceptions of trauma. It was to become recognised that, even the after-effects of a short-term war had the power to linger for much longer than desired. The unpredictable nature of trauma can be brought on by grief, survivors’ guilt or simply the inability to cope with the reality of life after war. As a result, too many Falklands veterans have been led on to paths of alcoholism, drug abuse, homelessness, family breakdown and crime.
When we read the stories of Falklands veterans, the main takeaway is that, for most, not a day goes by without a memory or thought of the conflict. Individual decisions that were made during the war can still play on their minds, with the only solution being to live with them and their consequences, good or bad. Post-traumatic stress disorder, or PTSD, was not recognised until 1987. Before then, during the second world war, it was known as shellshock and, during the great war, it was viewed as cowardice.
There remains progress to be made. Many people who have served in the armed forces fear that, by disclosing a suspected mental health issue, they are disclosing a weakness that may affect their future careers. That is why I express my continued appreciation for the military charities and associations that provide the necessary support and friendship to manage the powerful emotions that are experienced daily by our veterans.
For many Falklands servicemen, the effects of PTSD have taken years and sometimes decades to manifest. Before PTSD received recognition, veterans were shunned and unsupported, to the point where the act of seeking help seemed out of the question. Take the example of the youngest Scot who was deployed in the Falklands, David Cruickshanks, who was aged 17 and for whom joining the navy was a dream come true. It was not until 1999—17 years after the Falklands war—that his struggle with PTSD and depression was picked up by a doctor in an unrelated consultation. Only then did he start to speak about his personal struggles.
Last November, Mr Dey was fortunate to revisit RM Condor’s woodlands garden of remembrance, which is a poignant memorial to the men who have lost their lives in various conflicts, including the Falklands. The garden’s tranquil environment offers a focal point for the men of 45 Commando and their relatives to reflect and remember. One cannot visit it and fail to be moved. It is a matter of record that 255 British servicemen lost their lives in the Falklands as well as, lest we forget, 649 Argentinians. According to Royal British Legion figures, approximately 350 British Falklands veterans have taken their own lives since the conflict.
Although it can be said that, in the decades since the Falklands war, there has been more cultural awareness of the seriousness of PTSD, many people still struggle with the issue. The expectation during the Falklands conflict was to get on with it and deal with it, whatever “it” actually was. There can no longer be a stigma around asking for help, which is an act that is so simple yet, in some cases, is life changing.
To conclude my contribution to the debate I want to quote Ian Gardiner, then commander of X-Ray company, 45 Commando, as he reflected on the war:
“We are all of us changed men. For many, it was the pivotal event in their lives. The time before was innocence, while afterwards was a particular form of adulthood that not many ever see.”
In recognition of those words, this anniversary must serve as a reminder of the need and our collective responsibility to support our veterans whose service exacted a toll, because they bear their physical and mental wounds every single day, not just during anniversaries of the conflicts in which they saw action.