Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Ferries (Procurement)

General Question Time

Thursday 12 May 2022 Meeting of the Parliament Questions 13 contributions · 7 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

13 contributions
Daniel Johnson Lab Edinburgh Southern
link

To ask the Scottish Government what lessons have been learned regarding the procurement of new ferries. (S6O-01078)

Jenny Gilruth SNP The Minister for Transport · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

Transport Scotland works closely with Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd in relation to the procurement of new ferries and on lessons learned from previous processes. The recent report by Audit Scotland noted that, since the 801 and 802 project, a number of improvements have already been made, including CMAL undertaking additional risk assessments, enhanced financial diligence on preferred bidders and the employment of additional independent technical and commercial support.

Daniel Johnson Lab Edinburgh Southern
link

The problem with the email that was published yesterday is that the Scottish ministers are asking us to accept that a one-line email that simply alludes to a conversation with the Deputy First Minister is sufficient for the Government to undertake a contract that is worth the best part of £100 million, with, as it turns out, hundreds of millions of pounds of liabilities further to that. Yesterday, Audit Scotland’s statement made it clear that that is not sufficient documentary evidence for the decision and, last week, in relation to the decision making on the contract, the permanent secretary accepted that there was a question whether the law had been complied with.

To learn lessons, one must accept the mistakes that have been made. Will the minister accept Audit Scotland’s position of last night that the email is “insufficient documentary evidence” of the decision? Does she accept the permanent secretary’s position that there is a question whether there has been a breach of the law? If there is a question about a possible breach of the law, will ministers now refer themselves to the relevant authorities so that that can be investigated?

Jenny Gilruth SNP The Minister for Transport · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

In Daniel Johnson’s question, he speaks of one email signing off the procurement of ferries. That is how Government works; it is how decisions are signed off by ministers on a daily basis. That is the job and how it is processed.

On the lessons that have been learned—

Stephen Kerr Con Central Scotland
link

Outrageous! That is not how Government works.

Alison Johnstone The Presiding Officer · Lothian
link

Ms Gilruth, will you just give me a moment? Members, we will hear the minister’s response.

Jenny Gilruth SNP The Minister for Transport · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

First, CMAL conducted the procurement process in its capacity as the procuring authority. It then awarded the contract to Ferguson Marine Engineering Ltd and signed it off, following ministerial approval, as was outlined to the Parliament yesterday. It was signed off by the then Minister for Transport and Islands.

On Daniel Johnson’s substantive question, we have already confirmed to members that we will look at a formal lessons-learned exercise on the completion of hulls 801 and 802. The Scottish Government, Transport Scotland and CMAL have already accepted all the recommendations of the Audit Scotland report. CMAL and Transport Scotland have already confirmed that, in future, all major vessel procurements will require a full refund guarantee to be in place. As Audit Scotland has reported, CMAL has redesigned its tender process so that it will carry out additional risk assessments on all bidders, to undertake enhanced financial diligence, as I have previously stated. That will include financial monitoring by an independent accountancy firm before and after the contract award.

Graham Simpson Con Central Scotland
link

It sounds as though there have been no lessons learned. I have been nagging the minister for weeks to publish the project Neptune report. If she published it, we could start to have a conversation about how we procure ferries. When will she publish it? There is no barrier to that now, so she could do it next week.

Jenny Gilruth SNP The Minister for Transport · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

Mr Simpson knows that I have already given an assurance to the Parliament, and directly to him, that I will publish the project Neptune report. He will understand that some of the content of the project Neptune report was impacted by the purdah restrictions for the local government elections, but I recognise the need for transparency on this and I am liaising with officials about publishing the report as quickly as possible. Indeed, I believe that, only last night, Mr Simpson made direct representations on the matter to the director of ferries at Transport Scotland.

For the bodies themselves, I will not set out the detail of that today—not in an answer during general question time—but it is essential that we have transparency on that. I recognise the need for that and I have already given Mr Simpson an undertaking on the publication of the project Neptune report.

Stuart McMillan SNP Greenock and Inverclyde
link

It is clear that the yard won contracts to build three other vessels as well as the 801 and 802. Does the minister agree that the recent reports on the owner of the floating barge indicates that there were issues at the yard that affected public contracts, and put the yard into liquidation, so the nationalisation of the yard was the only way to create a business that was fit to win future public and private contracts?

Jenny Gilruth SNP The Minister for Transport · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

Yes, I agree with Mr McMillan’s observations. We have set out two very clear priorities for the yard’s management. Those are to finish building the two ferries that are under construction, and to get the yard into shape so that it can compete for new work. That is absolutely vital. Although any decisions about pursuing future vessel contracts, whether they be in the public or private sector, are for the yard itself, I know that Ferguson Marine is actively pursuing a range of different opportunities and ministers will support the yard in any way that we can to help to secure those opportunities.

Willie Rennie LD North East Fife
link

I think that the minister does not realise that she has made the situation a whole lot worse. She might be satisfied with one-line emails signing off on hundreds of millions of pounds of taxpayers’ money, but Audit Scotland is not, and it said so last night. We need a proper public inquiry into what has happened. We need the Government to refer itself to the authorities, because there is now a question about state aid, as the permanent secretary made clear last week. When is the minister going to wake up and realise the mess that she is in?

Jenny Gilruth SNP The Minister for Transport · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

I am not sure that there was necessarily a question in what Mr Rennie said. As I have already explained, the Auditor General welcomed the evidence that was given to the Parliament previously. He said:

“We are pleased that CMAL has acknowledged some of our recommendations on the adequacy of the contract and the need for milestone payments to be reviewed to ensure that they are more closely aligned with quality and progress”.—[Official Report, Public Audit Committee, 21 April 2022; c 39.]

CMAL and Transport Scotland have already agreed that all major future vessel procurements will require a full builder’s refund guarantee to be in place.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. General Question Time Questions · 1
  2. Ferries (Procurement) Questions · 13
  3. Community Hospitals Questions · 6
  4. Infrastructure Investment (South of Scotland) Questions · 6
  5. Ukrainian Refugees (Glasgow) Questions · 4
  6. Ukrainian Refugees (Community Integration) Questions · 4
  7. Energy Transition Fund (North East Scotland) Questions · 5
  8. Ferries (Construction Contract) First Minister’s Questions · 12
  9. Cabinet Ministers (Bullying Investigations) First Minister’s Questions · 7
  10. Scottish Football Writers’ Association Dinner First Minister’s Questions · 2
  11. Rail Services First Minister’s Questions · 2
  12. Mental Health Services (Tayside) First Minister’s Questions · 2
  13. Cost of Living Crisis First Minister’s Questions · 2
  14. Midwifery Services First Minister’s Questions · 2
  15. Mental Health (Loneliness) First Minister’s Questions · 2
  16. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 4
  17. Owner-occupied Homes (Decarbonisation) First Minister’s Questions · 8
  18. Early Learning and Childcare First Minister’s Questions · 9
  19. Abortion Healthcare First Minister’s Questions · 9
  20. Striking University Staff Members’ business · 33
  21. Education and Skills Questions · 1
  22. Gender-based Harassment Questions · 6
  23. Race Equality and Anti-Racism in Education Questions · 6
  24. Circular Economy Questions · 5
  25. Subject Choice (Secondary Schools) Questions · 8
  26. Fair Work Conditions (Funding) Questions · 6
  27. Neurodiversity (Support) Questions · 6
  28. Closing the Attainment Gap Questions · 7
  29. Cladding Remediation Statement · 29
  30. Coronavirus (Recovery and Reform) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 92
  31. Coronavirus (Recovery and Reform) (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution Bill debate · 1
  32. Appointments to Scottish Fiscal Commission Debate · 1
  33. Business Motion Business motions · 1
  34. Decision Time Decision time · 7
  35. International Nurses Day Members’ business · 16

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.