I will declare an interest and say that I have a niece and two cousins who all have Down’s syndrome.
I begin by thanking those members from across the chamber who have supported my motion and members’ business debate. It has been great to see support from almost all parties, although I am disappointed that the Greens decided not to support it. I find it sad that they could not bring themselves to put politics aside for the sake of the Down’s syndrome community.
I also thank Dr Liam Fox. His bill has been long anticipated, and it sends a clear message to a community in this country that has felt left behind, undervalued, and ignored for a long time. I am in no way saying that the story will end with the passing of the bill because it is clear that there is still a long way to go, but it is certainly a large step in the right direction.
I have to admit that this is not the speech that I had planned to give, nor is it a speech that I particularly want to give. My original speech was going to extol the virtues of the bill. I was going to describe how placing a concrete responsibility on local authorities to accommodate those with Down’s syndrome will create a much less hostile environment than the one that they unfortunately have been used to.
I was going to petition the Scottish Government to adopt the bill and allow it to be a United Kingdom-wide piece of legislation. As drafted, the bill extends to England and Wales, although there was a possibility for the people of Scotland to benefit from it. The Down’s community in Scotland could have had the same protection as England and Wales. Given the fact that a Scottish National Party member of Parliament had publicly supported the bill, I was hopeful. Mr Chapman said in the second stage debate:
“I hope that, should it be passed, our colleagues in Wales, Northern Ireland and Scotland will look at it sympathetically and introduce equivalent measures across the UK. I wish the Bill Godspeed.”—[Official Report, House of Commons, 26 November 2021; Vol 704, c 580.]
It is now too late. The bill has passed through the Commons and the Lords and is awaiting royal assent. To the delight of those with Down’s syndrome in England and Wales, new protections and rights are only a signature away from being a reality. Those in Scotland, however, are left with a hollow feeling, wondering what possible reason there could be for the SNP to refuse to support them in this way. The answer is that there is no good reason. A political decision has been taken by a Scottish Government that is so caught up in a constitutional battle and grievance politics that it cannot even support the Down’s syndrome community, and whose fear of deviating from saying “Westminster is bad” even overrules issues affecting those with disabilities.
During the past 15 years, the whole of Scotland has suffered from the SNP dropping the ball on issues such as drug deaths, accident and emergency waiting times and educational standards, while the Government’s eyes have been on its constitutional obsession, but the disability community feels uniquely cast aside. Let us have a look back at even just the past couple of years. During the pandemic, face masks presented a great problem for those who are hard of hearing. They muffled people’s voices and made it impossible for those who rely on lip reading to interact with and participate in society. While health boards around the UK approved clear face masks, the Scottish Government dragged its heels and it was not until December 2021—almost two years after the beginning of the pandemic—that NHS Scotland provided doctors with them. The SNP refused to prioritise the disability community yet again.
Another prime example is the unfolding ferries fiasco. Although it is undeniable that lots of mistakes have been made, changing places toilets could have been included in the design. They are the gold standard of disabled facilities that provide for all the needs a disabled person might have, but more than that, they send a message to the disabled community that they are welcome in a place and can travel freely.
My colleague Jamie Halcro Johnston asked the Scottish Government whether the plans for the two new ferries included changing places toilets and the short answer was no, they include no such toilet. The answer seemed to imply that the Minister for Transport did not understand that a changing places toilet is more than just a disabled toilet with changing facilities. Once again, the SNP refuses to make the inclusion of the disabled community a priority.
Those are just two examples, but they show the Scottish Government’s attitude and the reason behind tonight’s debate.
There were no good reasons for the Scottish Government to oppose the bill. It will tell us that it is planning something bigger and better and more tartan, but that is simply an excuse. The UK bill does not need to be exhaustive, and it in no way prevents the Scottish Government from going further with future legislation. This was a political decision that used Down’s syndrome as a pawn for the sake of scoring cheap points against a Government that is taking the issue seriously. The result is that even if the SNP introduces its own bill, those with Down’s syndrome in Scotland will be forced to wait an unnecessary length of time. Unlike those in England and Wales who now have these rights, we do not have them in Scotland. Stronger For Scotland? I think not, and certainly not stronger for the disabled community.
17:34