Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Sea Fish (Prohibition on Fishing) (Firth of Clyde) (No 2) Order 2022 (SSI 2022/35)

Wednesday 9 March 2022 Rural Affairs, Islands and Natural Environment Committee About 09:00–11:15 Subordinate legislation 291 contributions · 14 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

291 contributions · showing 201–291
Karen Adam SNP Banffshire and Buchan Coast
link

Overall, what has been clear today is that Scotland’s marine environment is one of this country’s greatest treasures, and it is right that we continue to take robust steps to ensure that it remains a prized asset for our future generations. However, it can often be quite complex to get the balance right between competing interests, and there are potential tensions. Has there been a reasonable level of recognition of the complexity involved in taking these decisions—carefully balancing environmental, social and economic interests and using the best evidence that is available to you to protect marine species while allowing fishing activity?

Mairi Gougeon SNP Angus North and Mearns
link

As Allan Gibb alluded, the committee has probably been able, through this discussion, to see the sheer range of views and the competing and complex issues that we have to balance when we take such decisions. What Allan has just set out about moving forward and about where that step change is needed is critical. Today, we are looking at one difficult area, and there will be more to come in the various other measures that we are looking to introduce. Getting the foundations for such decisions right will be critical.

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

Can I take you back to the co-management process that you mentioned, cabinet secretary? In the evidence that we took, it was thought that co-management is the gold standard. However, we heard that fishing families want to be able to feed into the process instead of having to accept last-minute policies and compromises that they do not understand and that they fear because they fear that not accepting them might lead to something worse. Are you aware of such a culture of fear in that so-called gold standard of management?

Mairi Gougeon SNP Angus North and Mearns
link

I do not want people to be scared or to have that fear about the process. That is very much not where we want to be. As I said, we want to have the gold standard of co-management. We want to engage with the people who are impacted by such decisions and with all the various interests that are represented. That is absolutely critical for us. That is why, as I said, we are keen to address the points and learn the lessons from this process, in particular. We aim to achieve that gold standard of co-management.

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

Will you accept as true the accusation that you put the Bute house agreement before fishermen and their livelihoods and families?

Mairi Gougeon SNP Angus North and Mearns
link

That is not true. As I said, a variety of different factors have fed into our change in position and have ultimately led to the SSI that is before the committee today. Through listening to all those different points of view, and through going over the science and the evidence that are available, we have reached the best outcome, which is achieving the policy objective of giving enhanced protection to spawning cod while trying to balance those other interests.

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

Will you provide the committee with details of all the publicly funded organisations that, within those stakeholder inputs, campaigned for the removal of the exemptions?

Mairi Gougeon SNP Angus North and Mearns
link

I do not know that information off the top of my head, but, if there is information that I can provide to the committee, I will be sure to do that.

Dr Alasdair Allan SNP Na h-Eileanan an Iar
link

We have heard about the financial impacts of the closures, and I do not doubt that those are real.

Many of us around the table represent fishing communities and we are familiar with the biggest issues that people in those communities bring to us. Those are around the financial impacts on businesses, families and individuals that have been caused by difficulties in accessing European markets and in finding a workforce for fishing and fish processing. Where do some of the issues that we have been talking about fit into the Government’s response to the realities of Scotland being dragged out of the European Union?

10:45

Mairi Gougeon SNP Angus North and Mearns
link

I recognise that the measure comes on the back of a really challenging time for people. The loss of EU markets has had a stark impact, including in relation to labour issues. I met you and some of your constituents to talk about those very issues.

We have talked through the process of how we reached the decision and the financial information that is taken into account when looking at decisions such as this. Undoubtedly, this has been a particularly difficult time for the industry because of some of the other issues that you outlined.

Dr Alasdair Allan SNP Na h-Eileanan an Iar
link

The only thing that I would add to that is a certain word that you are too polite to mention: Brexit. That has had a real impact on those communities.

Beatrice Wishart LD Shetland Islands
link

This discussion is all about the Clyde cod box. However, will the cabinet secretary tell us what consideration has been given to wider spawning grounds when deciding on offshore wind areas? I do not expect you to answer that today, but perhaps you could provide a written response.

Mairi Gougeon SNP Angus North and Mearns
link

Yes, I can. Again, that touches on some of the difficult and complex decisions that we will have to take in the future, as we will have to balance those interests, too.

Finlay Carson Con The Convener · Galloway and West Dumfries
link

I call Jim Fairlie.

Jim Fairlie SNP Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
link

Can everybody hear me?

Jim Fairlie SNP Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
link

I am working very remotely and using a phone, which is quite tricky.

There are, undoubtedly, huge pressures on the fishing community right now, and, as Dr Allan just mentioned, Brexit is one of the biggest of those pressures. Through the earlier questioning, we have already established that the right thing to do, from an ecological point of view and to ensure that we do not take out a top predator, is to try to save cod. That being the case, we must take action to do so.

I do not know whether you were included in this, cabinet secretary, but, this week or last, all committee members were tagged in a Twitter thread in which competing interests in the cod box issue were—I will be polite—talking to each other. They were being less than polite; they were like ferrets in a sack. As far as I can see, that is because they simply cannot agree on anything. Maybe I am missing something, because I am not in a coastal community—I do not know. However, there seems to be a huge divergence of opinion on what the right way to go is to protect individual species and individual industries. How does the Government manage all those competing factions? Some folk want there to be no fishing, and other folk want their sector to be protected but are not too worried about other sectors. How can the Government be the guy in the middle and find the solutions to make sure that all interests are protected?

Finlay Carson Con The Convener · Galloway and West Dumfries
link

Before you answer that, cabinet secretary, I ask that we try to stick to the cod box issue, which is what we are discussing today, rather than spreading things a little bit wider, given the time constraints.

Jim Fairlie SNP Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
link

Convener, I am absolutely talking about the cod box. I am talking about the pressure that families are feeling across the industry. They do not care where the problem comes from; they just know that they have a problem. I am very much thinking of those people who have an interest in the cod box—that was the basis of my question.

Mairi Gougeon SNP Angus North and Mearns
link

We have to try to manage that as best we can. I am dependent on the advice that I receive, which includes advice from the likes of Dr Needle. I also speak to people and listen to different representations. Ultimately, we try to take the best decision that will meet the policy objective, and will protect and, I hope, increase the cod stock biomass. However, we must also recognise that there are socioeconomic consequences to that, so we must balance those aspects as best we can.

I think that we have achieved that with the SSI that is in front of the committee today, by reducing the closure area and allowing more activity to take place, while ultimately protecting the spawning cod.

Finlay Carson Con The Convener · Galloway and West Dumfries
link

I call Mercedes Villalba.

Jim Fairlie SNP Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
link

Can I follow up on my question, please?

Finlay Carson Con The Convener · Galloway and West Dumfries
link

If you are very brief.

Jim Fairlie SNP Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
link

I do not know whether you addressed this earlier. You have to find a balance for all the competing sectors. Does that mean that you will consult over the coming year in relation to 2023? Will you be able to get everybody in the room to thrash out the problems?

Mairi Gougeon SNP Angus North and Mearns
link

I go back to what Allan Gibb said about lessons that we are looking to learn and making sure that we hear all the different interests and perspectives so that we can understand people’s positions and find a way forward. That is a positive action that we can take away from the current process.

Finlay Carson Con The Convener · Galloway and West Dumfries
link

Finally, we come to Mercedes Villalba.

Mercedes Villalba Lab North East Scotland
link

I have a straightforward yes or no question for Mr Gibb, the cabinet secretary and Dr Needle. Is it your view that trawling and dredging have a bigger environmental impact than creeling and diving?

Mairi Gougeon SNP Angus North and Mearns
link

They have a different impact. We have not tried to say that they all have exactly the same impact.

In relation to the cod box, all activity has been prohibited because any activity has the potential to impact on spawning cod. That is why all activity has been stopped throughout the closure period.

Allan Gibb Marine Scotland
link

I agree with what the cabinet secretary said about the cod box and disturbance, but, in answer to your basic question, yes, mobile activity has a larger impact than some other activities.

Dr Needle
link

Yes, I would agree. Benthic disturbance—disturbance of the sea bed—in particular has a bigger impact.

Mercedes Villalba Lab North East Scotland
link

Based on that, following the reduction of the closure area, why has all fishing activity in the border area—the area that is outside the new closure area but within the original closure area—been treated equally?

Mairi Gougeon SNP Angus North and Mearns
link

Do you mean activity within the closed area?

Mercedes Villalba Lab North East Scotland
link

When you reduced the closure area to make it smaller, on what basis was the decision made to allow all fishing to take place in the area that falls outside the present closure area but which was part of the original area?

Mairi Gougeon SNP Angus North and Mearns
link

All activity was prevented because of the issue of disturbance, which I talked about.

Mercedes Villalba Lab North East Scotland
link

That is the case in the new closure area but, outside that area, all fishing is now allowed. The original closure area has been reduced. In an area where all fishing activity was previously excluded, all activity is now allowed. Why has there been no variation between different types of activity?

Allan Gibb Marine Scotland
link

I do not think that that is right. We looked at the existing closure area. That remains—it has not been reduced, apart from a section in the middle of it; 28 per cent has been left open. We have not changed the boundaries anywhere else.

The part that is closed has not been reduced. It is the right area. The part that is closed is closed to everybody, because cod can or may spawn there. That is where the point about disturbance of habitat comes in. Part of the original closure area has remained open, following reflection by the Scottish Government. That is because we have a high degree of belief, if not certainty, that there will not be any spawning cod in that area because of the habitat. So far, the monitoring has proven that to be case. We have not reduced the area elsewhere.

Mercedes Villalba Lab North East Scotland
link

So, the precautionary approach has not been applied at all in that 28 per cent of the area that you have taken out—there is no precautionary approach there; there is just a free-for-all, with any type of activity allowed.

Allan Gibb Marine Scotland
link

No, not at all. It is entirely precautionary. It is precautionary in relation to the policy, not in relation to fishing, mobile or otherwise. This is about protecting the spawning cod. I think that getting everyone to stay focused on the objective has been part of the challenge. It is not about types of fishing and so on.

The bit that is open is precautionary in the sense that spawning cod will not be there. It is only mud. There will not even be scallops, and therefore there will be no scallop dredging; there will only be nephrops. It is a nephrops habitat; it is not for scallops or spawning cod. The approach is precautionary and evidenced.

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

I would like some clarification of the 28 per cent area. Was that area previously closed?

Allan Gibb Marine Scotland
link

Yes, but with exemptions.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

I find this entirely inconsistent. That area was previously included. You said that you do not have much evidence about that area of the Clyde, yet you have taken it out. We hear that it is because of representations made—I accept that—but it is not based on the science, and I think that we should be honest about that.

Allan Gibb Marine Scotland
link

What I said was that the entire area was closed, with exemptions that permitted nephrops trawlers, scallop dredgers and creelers to fish in some areas. The evidence that we are using suggests that any disturbance, including that which is created by those methods, is detrimental to the spawning activities. The decision to leave an area open is science based, because that area is mud habitat. Spawning cod will not be there, so there is no need to close that area.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

But it was closed previously, on the basis of the same science.

Allan Gibb Marine Scotland
link

It was not based on the same science.

Allan Gibb Marine Scotland
link

We are looking at the best available science that we have now.

Allan Gibb Marine Scotland
link

The original closure was based on collaboration with Government and industry around the issue of what area would be the right place to close.

Allan Gibb Marine Scotland
link

We are being far more directive in order to deliver the maximum protection.

Mairi Gougeon SNP Angus North and Mearns
link

That is part of the extra advice and information that we sought from Dr Needle in relation to looking again at the closure to find out whether we are closing off the correct areas and prohibiting the right fishing measures in that closure.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

I entirely accept that. However, what I want is a degree of transparency about where the decisions are based on risk, where they are based on new science and where they are based on lobbying by stakeholders. I think that that is important information. If we do not have it, you could find yourself in a situation in which you could be destroying livelihoods and protecting the wrong area, which would be a disaster in everybody’s book.

Finlay Carson Con The Convener · Galloway and West Dumfries
link

That opens up some questions about what additional science-based evidence was introduced between order number 1 and order number 2.

Jim Fairlie would like to ask a final and very short question, and then we will need to move on.

Jim Fairlie SNP Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
link

My question has been answered already.

Finlay Carson Con The Convener · Galloway and West Dumfries
link

Okay. Cabinet secretary, I thank you and your officials for staying with us for this extended period. We really appreciate it. As you can understand, there are a lot of questions to be asked.

Agenda item 2 relates to motion S6M-03543, in the name of Rachael Hamilton, which asks the committee to agree to recommend that the instrument be annulled.

I invite Rachael Hamilton to set out her reasons for lodging the motion. The cabinet secretary will have an opportunity to comment and can bring in her officials as necessary. We will debate the motion formally at item 3.

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

Thank you for allowing me to explain my reasons for lodging the motion to annul the instrument.

The Firth of Clyde closure is an expected yearly event that fishermen have supported since its initial implementation to ensure sustainability. Fishermen have supported that for their livelihoods and to encourage sustainability of cod and other fish in their fishing areas so that that tradition can continue. This year is different, with there being no exemptions for any fishermen, which means that those who would normally continue to have some income now have none.

11:00

Last week, Elaine Whyte of the Clyde Fishermen’s Association told the committee how removal of the exemptions is detrimental to the fishermen who are proud to call the Firth of Clyde their home waters. She said that fishermen are having to find other sources of income because they simply have no alternative. According to other witnesses, the Scottish Government did not follow the business and regulatory impact assessment guidance for policy officials.

Last Thursday, in response to my colleague Jackson Carlaw MSP, the cabinet secretary said that she had listened to the industry, but it appears that the reality of the situation is different to what was said in the chamber.

The committee will be aware that fishermen are struggling to find any source of income, and they were told bluntly by the cabinet secretary that there would be no financial help or compensation from the Scottish Government. Again, to quote a witness, a seemingly “knee-jerk reaction” without consultation or evidence concluded that there was no need for compensation.

At a time when living costs are rising, we cannot afford to abandon our fishing communities as the Government is doing. The removal of the exemptions will result in reduced income for vessel crews and will have a knock-on effect on the livelihoods of families and the coastal communities that some people in this room represent.

I urge members to think about the evidence that we have heard and to imagine themselves in the position of the fishermen who will be left without work for 11 weeks or be forced to work in unsafe surroundings and conditions or, which would be even worse, not be able to move elsewhere. The truth is that the Scottish Government did not consult the fishermen properly. Elspeth Macdonald from the Scottish Fishermen’s Federation suggested that, given the outcome, the consultation document misled the industry and effectively gave it a false sense of security without providing any real opportunity to argue against the removal of the exemptions.

The committee heard that stakeholders had insufficient warning about changes to proposals, and that there was a lack of stakeholder engagement in advance of the announcement of the removal of existing exemptions. Furthermore, stakeholders said that there was a lack of collaborative working from the Scottish Government and, worryingly, they did not have equal access to the information that others had access to.

I suggest that that was not a level playing field. Consultation responses were published only at the end of January 2022, after two orders had been made. That shows a serious lack of transparency in the decision-making process. The committee should be worried about what we have heard today and from witnesses in the past. I have been motivated to seek annulment of the order because bad regulation cannot be the cornerstone of the Scottish Parliament.

The Bute house agreement has been raised as a concern. The committee has a duty to hold the SNP-Green collaboration to account. We cannot allow this badly executed process, which is clearly detrimental to Clyde fishermen, to impact on socioeconomic, environmental, safety and proportionality considerations. Ultimately, each of us should heed our witnesses’ warnings of the Scottish Government’s decision-making process.

As was said by Simon Macdonald at committee:

“If you want to hear from a conservationist, ask a fisherman, because their livelihood and their future as well as their family’s future depend on ... conservation”.—Official Report, Rural Affairs, Islands and Natural Environment Committee, 2 March 2022; c 5.

The Scottish Government has failed to do that.

I will finish by quoting the words of Elaine Whyte, because they perfectly summarise my decision to lodge a motion to annul.

“We are moving to managing fisheries by campaigning as opposed to by data, science and process, which sets a very worrying precedent.”—Official Report, Rural Affairs, Islands and Natural Environment Committee, 2 March 2022; c 9.

Colleagues should consider supporting my motion to annul the order. Thank you.

Finlay Carson Con The Convener · Galloway and West Dumfries
link

As no member of the committee wishes to ask Rachael Hamilton any questions, I turn to the cabinet secretary.

Mairi Gougeon SNP Angus North and Mearns
link

I will reiterate some of what I have said throughout the meeting. The committee has heard from a cross-section of stakeholders and has heard a diverse range of views. I have already talked about the complexity of the issue; the evidence that you have heard outlines that.

It is a difficult situation to find a solution to; in this case, it is impossible to find one that would make everyone equally happy. As the cabinet secretary who is responsible for fisheries management and protection, it is my job—as I outlined in response to Jim Fairlie’s question—to take on board and try, no matter how well-intentioned they are, to balance all the competing interests.

Rachael Hamilton talked about some of the comments that I made in response to Jackson Carlaw’s parliamentary question last week. In that response, I said:

“Responsible fisheries management means ensuring that we get the right balance between socioeconomic and environmental outcomes.”—Official Report, 3 March 2020; c 60.

In this case, we have done that by increasing protections for spawning cod while also ensuring that fishing can continue to take place in surrounding areas.

The committee has also heard a variety of scientific opinions about what constitutes protection. However, on the advice of Dr Needle, who is the chief fisheries adviser for Scotland, we are applying the precautionary approach and minimising disturbance of the sea bed during the spawning period in the known spawning area. That is the fundamental objective and it is important that we not lose sight of it.

As I said in my opening comments and have said throughout the meeting, the process that led up to the SSI being laid before the committee was by no means ideal, but I firmly stand by the closure decision and believe that we are doing the right thing to contribute to protection of spawning cod.

I have outlined the next steps that Marine Scotland will take. Allan Gibb also talked about monitoring and compliance. We will meet stakeholders after the closure ends this year to hear their thoughts on how it has worked. As we also said, we will look to learn lessons on how the processes can be improved. However, ensuring that the closure was in place from 14 February until the end of April was the right decision and was our number 1 priority.

I hope that Rachael Hamilton will consider not moving her motion and, failing that, that the committee will not support it.

Finlay Carson Con The Convener · Galloway and West Dumfries
link

We move on to formal consideration of the motion to annul. I ask Rachael Hamilton to speak to and move motion S6M-03543.

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

I thank you for giving me this opportunity, convener. I listened carefully to what the cabinet secretary had to say. I believe even more that my arguments for annulling the order are justified, because neither the cabinet secretary nor Marine Scotland has justified the Scottish Government’s actions. The process is utterly botched. There is a complete lack of evidence. There is a lack of engagement, fishermen are fearful and questions need to be asked about the intent of the Bute house agreement, which seems to be behind what has happened and the devastating impact to the fishermen on the Clyde.

I move,

That the Rural Affairs, Islands and Natural Environment Committee recommends that the Sea Fish (Prohibition on Fishing) (Firth of Clyde) (No. 2) Order 2022 (SSI 2022/35) be annulled.

Mercedes Villalba Lab North East Scotland
link

I am not sure how everything works, but I will say what I think.

The closure has not been introduced fairly. I would like the Government to go away, rethink it and bring it back, if that is an option. If we need to annul the order for that to happen, on balance I support that.

I am concerned about the evidence base. I am supportive of a precautionary approach, but that needs to be balanced with economic factors and livelihoods. The Government has not got the balance right on that.

During the meeting, I have been looking at the research papers that were cited, and I cannot even see that thing about 5m to 10m above the sea bed; it seems to be based on tidal activity rather than fishing. I just do not feel that, on the whole, the approach is right. I therefore support the motion to annul.

Dr Alasdair Allan SNP Na h-Eileanan an Iar
link

I do not think that anyone would underestimate the difficulties around the issue and the balancing acts that are involved, but I think that we are dealing with a Government that has attempted to meet concerns, so I will vote accordingly.

Jim Fairlie SNP Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
link

I am sorry, but I am hearing only bits and pieces of the conversation.

I urge the cabinet secretary to get the fishing communities into the room to talk to each other about what needs to be done for next year. I will not support the motion to annul, because the precautionary principle is correct in trying to protect the cod stocks. We have heard from every stakeholder. They have all said the same thing, which is that they want the cod stocks to be protected. Clearly, there have been issues with the process, so it would be great if that could be improved, but, at this point, I will not support the motion to annul.

Beatrice Wishart LD Shetland Islands
link

I think that we all agree that this has been a botched process and that how it has been handled does no credit to Marine Scotland or the Scottish Government. Fishermen’s livelihoods—which are not about one individual—are at risk. We have all heard the evidence. We have also heard that, in the past 20 years, the cod stocks have not recovered. There is therefore an imbalance in the understanding of how the new approach will make any difference. I have to say that I am finding this issue extremely difficult.

Finlay Carson Con The Convener · Galloway and West Dumfries
link

Does any other member wish to speak? I call Jackie Baillie.

Jackie Baillie Lab Dumbarton
link

Convener, I was staying quiet because I do not have a vote, as I am not a member of the committee. My opening position is that I share the ambition to protect cod stocks. However, the way that the process has been done has led to a lack of confidence in Marine Scotland’s thinking and evidential base, and that has harmed the debate.

There is a lack of specific evidence about the Clyde. That has been acknowledged by everybody. It is being rectified, and I welcome that. However, it is the case that cod in the Clyde are different. On the west coast, juveniles occupy shallow coastal habitats, whereas, in the North Sea, they occupy offshore banks. Their behaviours are different, and we have not taken the time to understand that.

I understand the risk-based approach, but the Government appears to be muddling the evidential and the risk-based approaches, because evidence in relation to the Clyde is simply not there. I am genuinely worried that we are excluding areas that we previously thought it important to include. Whether that is based on evidence, discussion or debate, I genuinely do not know. We are at risk of taking away people’s livelihoods but might not be protecting the areas that we need to protect. On that basis, I genuinely ask whether the cabinet secretary would withdraw the SSI and bring it back, because we share the ambition of protecting the cod stocks. However, we need to do that properly; the exercise has not been done properly, on this occasion.

Finlay Carson Con The Convener · Galloway and West Dumfries
link

As the cabinet secretary has admitted, the process has been flawed from the start, and I believe that it is still flawed at the finish. The unprecedented numbers of responses about the first order that was laid, and the subsequent very short timescale before the second order was laid, are of concern, and there is a lack of transparency over what factors contributed to the orders being changed. We have heard of concerns about scientific evidence, data collection and monitoring, a lack of appreciation of the impact of the closures on socioeconomic aspects and environmental safety, and proportionality. One fisherman suggested that the comment about a short-term economic impact on local fishers showed an “almost flippant attitude”.

I have concerns that, given the new Bute house agreement, this will not be the last order of this type that we see in front of us. On that basis, there needs to be some recognition that, along with other sectors, whether that is oil and gas, transport or farming, a transition to a more sustainable way of fishing needs to be compensated for or supported in some way. There is a complete lack of appreciation of the impact on fishers as they try to do the best thing, which is to create sustainable fisheries. On that basis, I will support the motion to annul.

11:15

Ariane Burgess Green Highlands and Islands
link

From the evidence that I have heard today, I think that protecting future cod fisheries is paramount, and I agree with the precautionary approach, so I will not support the motion to annul. However, going forward, we must get all the voices in the room, which you have indicated that you are planning to do. Assessing the closure after this period of time is important. Something that has come to me very strongly in the course of these evidence sessions and other ones that we have been taking on the marine space is that there is a lack of resource for an increasing amount of responsibility for Marine Scotland.

That needs to be reviewed, and we need to have the right resource for data gathering and monitoring so that we understand the spatial issues, the spawning issues and whatever other issues we need to understand, so that we have fisheries for the future. What we are talking about here and what we are trying to do for the long term is ensure that people who need to fish to make a living have fish in 10, 20 or 100 years from now. The precautionary approach is the right approach, because we are looking for a long-term impact.

Karen Adam SNP Banffshire and Buchan Coast
link

I will not support the motion to annul. After hearing the evidence, I am in favour of protecting the cod spawning grounds for future generations and the future sustainability of fishing for coastal communities. I hear and understand that there are competing views on the matter and the Scottish Government has been reflective in its process, and I am glad that there will be discussions about that. I am glad that Rachael Hamilton is concerned about the wellbeing of and socioeconomic implications for fishermen in coastal areas, and I hope that we see more of that.

There are long-term implications for our fishing and coastal communities—I represent one—in relation to Brexit and the rising cost of living. Adding an environmental disaster on top of that and reducing the potential amount of cod for future generations would be too big of an impact, so I will not support the motion.

Jenni Minto SNP Argyll and Bute
link

I have found this process incredibly difficult. I represent Argyll and Bute, which is one of the constituencies that are impacted by the decision. I have thought long and hard about this. I have spoken to all the communities that are impacted, and it is clear that we have to strike the right balance between sustainability of stocks and sustainability of communities. What the Government and Marine Scotland have done in relation to the process could have been better, but they have listened to what stakeholders have said.

I agree entirely with what my colleague Ariane Burgess said about ensuring that we continue to pull the right people around the table and listen to them. I appreciate that there are polarised views, but we have to come to some agreement and strike the right balance to ensure the sustainability of the fish and the communities. I will vote against the motion to annul.

Finlay Carson Con The Convener · Galloway and West Dumfries
link

As no member has any other points to raise, I ask the minister to respond.

Mairi Gougeon SNP Angus North and Mearns
link

I have covered a lot of these comments in my previous remarks. I understand where Mercedes Villalba is coming from in relation to some of her points. However, I re-emphasise the point that agreeing to the motion to annul the instrument that is before the committee today would remove all protections.

I recognise members’ points about the process. As I have said previously, we absolutely want to ensure that we learn lessons from this.

Finlay Carson Con The Convener · Galloway and West Dumfries
link

On that point, I presume that, if the instrument was to be annulled, the Government would need to lay another instrument. Are you suggesting that, if the instrument was to be annulled, you would walk away from protecting cod altogether?

Mairi Gougeon SNP Angus North and Mearns
link

Of course, we would not want to do that, but that is essentially what the committee would allow to happen if the SSI were annulled. If more work was to be done, that would take time, during which the protection would not be in place. That would be during spawning time, which is a short window.

I have covered the other issues in my previous remarks, so I draw to a close in highlighting that aspect to the committee.

Finlay Carson Con The Convener · Galloway and West Dumfries
link

I invite Rachael Hamilton to wind up.

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

I thank committee members for setting out their stall. Of course, we want to protect cod stocks; so, too, do fishermen—they call themselves conservationists.

I am disappointed that some colleagues are not considering the issue seriously enough. They are just getting behind the Government. It is a spineless approach by SNP back benchers. In particular, I am afraid that I have to call out my colleague Jenni Minto, as she called for compensation for her constituents in January over this. I am sorry, Jenni, that your Government does not support you or your constituents on that.

It is imperative that the cabinet secretary takes our concerns at face value. I will press my motion. The matter is urgent and the Government must quickly come back to the table with new proposals.

I know that my motion to annul will fail today because I do not have the numbers behind me. The odds are stacked against me because SNP back benchers will support the Government’s position, which is regrettable. However, I urge the Government to urgently carry out a review and come back with new proposals.

Finlay Carson Con The Convener · Galloway and West Dumfries
link

Is it a point of order?

Dr Alasdair Allan SNP Na h-Eileanan an Iar
link

On a point of order, convener. Is it entirely parliamentary for members on the committee to describe each other as “spineless”?

Finlay Carson Con The Convener · Galloway and West Dumfries
link

I have no comment to make on that.

We will move on. The question is, that motion S6M-03543, in the name of Rachael Hamilton, be agreed to. Are we agreed?

Members: No.

Finlay Carson Con The Convener · Galloway and West Dumfries
link

There will be a division. As we are meeting in hybrid format, I ask members who are attending virtually to vote via the chat function by putting yes, no or abstain and members who are in the committee room to vote by raising their hands.

For

Carson, Finlay (Galloway and West Dumfries) (Con)

Hamilton, Rachael (Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire) (Con)

Against

Adam, Karen (Banffshire and Buchan Coast) (SNP)

Allan, Alasdair (Na h-Eileanan an Iar) (SNP)

Burgess, Ariane (Highlands and Islands) (Green)

Fairlie, Jim (Perthshire South and Kinross-shire)(SNP)

Minto, Jenni (SNP) (Argyll and Bute) (SNP)

Abstentions

Villalba, Mercedes (North East Scotland) (Lab)

Wishart, Beatrice (Shetland Islands) (LD)

Finlay Carson Con The Convener · Galloway and West Dumfries
link

The result of the division is: For 2, Against 5, Abstentions 2.

Motion disagreed to.

Finlay Carson Con The Convener · Galloway and West Dumfries
link

The committee must now produce a report on the instrument. Are members content to delegate responsibility to me to sign off the report on behalf of the committee? It will be a brief factual report, with a link to this and last week’s Official Report.

Members indicated agreement.

Finlay Carson Con The Convener · Galloway and West Dumfries
link

Under item 4, I ask whether any member has any comment on the Sea Fish (Prohibition on Fishing) (Firth of Clyde) (No 2) Order 2022. Please raise your hand or type R in the chat box if you are participating remotely.

Committee paper 2 sets out options for our following up the instrument, including in relation to the joint fisheries statement, which we will consider on 23 March, any related future inquiry work and the instrument for next year’s fishing ban, when it is laid. Do members agree to follow up the issues that have been raised in the instrument in those future areas of our work programme?

Members indicated agreement.

Finlay Carson Con The Convener · Galloway and West Dumfries
link

I thank the cabinet secretary and her officials for attending today.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report

No recorded division on this motion that day: decisions taken without a vote are not in the divisions feed.

  1. 09:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 291
  2. 11:15 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.