This is probably one of the most important debates that we will have in Parliament. I thank the committee clerks, all the organisations that sent us their views and analysis and the witnesses who shared their expertise and answered our questions.
The work of the Constitution, Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee is the start of significant scrutiny not just by my committee but by other parliamentary committees. Brexit is only just over a year old, yet it has had a massive negative impact on businesses, farming and food producers, those in the haulage industry and those in our cultural sector. The UK Conservative Government’s ambition to create an internal market to lower standards must not throw into reverse the devolution settlement, our food and environmental standards or the labour market.
However, at the same time, we need to have an effective internal market, because that is crucial to our future. As has been referenced, the statistics show that Scotland’s exported goods and services to the rest of the UK are worth more than £51 billion, which is 60 per cent of our exports. Therefore, we must have an internal market that works for us in Scotland.
This has been a good debate. It has flushed out the disagreements and we must deal with those issues. We need to focus on the recommendations to manage tensions between Governments and ensure that the principles underpinning devolution are not undermined.
Life after Brexit was always going to be a challenge, so ensuring transparency and enabling all those with an interest to allow our internal market to work while making sure that our businesses across Scotland are not disadvantaged is crucial.
Common frameworks are clearly an important means by which the UK Government and the devolved Governments are able to work together. That gives those in government the opportunity to decide how they can manage the tensions in the internal market and ensure that, where there are strong arguments for divergence and different approaches, those can be enabled and understood.
Although intergovernmental working is crucial, as has been agreed by all parties, the Law Society of Scotland was clear that the current arrangements
“lack sufficient transparency and accountability.”
We need to have interparliamentary work and work within our Parliament to make sure that we get that transparency. In that way, our citizens and our businesses will be able see what is coming down the track, as well as understand the timetables, what the frameworks will cover, and the fact that we have public consultations where significant changes are being proposed. That is why the committee calls for clarity and regular updates to each Parliament across the UK, and for Government to highlight upcoming proposals to enable people to plan ahead.
We recognise the economic benefits for businesses and consumers of having trade across the UK. However, given that a fundamental principle of devolution is the decentralisation of power so that we can meet local needs and address local circumstances, we have to accept the importance of innovation and regulatory learning that has come about. That is why we think that both the Scottish Government and our councils should be able to set standards through public procurement, whether in relation to procurement of food or a deal for fair work.
This is not the time to reject previously high standards, particularly in the aftermath of the ambitions that we all agreed at the 26th United Nations climate change conference of the parties—COP26. Our committee was concerned that the internal market act and the Subsidy Control Bill cut across the devolution settlement, and that concern was expressed very effectively. OneKind expressed concern that the act limits our
“ability . . . to improve farmed animal welfare standards”.
Professor Weatherill said that the act
“places too much emphasis on market liberalisation over local rights to regulate”.
Professor McEwen and her colleagues argued powerfully that the act gives
“a powerful disincentive to engage in legal reform or policy innovation”.
Scottish Environment LINK expressed concerns about the lowering of environmental standards in relation to air, water and soil quality, which we should we worried about.
We need greater transparency, and we need effective intergovernmental working. However, as both Foysol Choudhury and Donald Cameron observed, we also have to have interparliamentary debate. The committee had an excellent briefing on our report this morning. One thing that came across clearly was the need for an independent secretariat to resource and monitor common frameworks. We also need a clear traffic light system, so that citizens, businesses, and campaign and stakeholder groups can also monitor common frameworks and alert us, as MSPs, to their interests and concerns, so that their issues can be raised and debated. There will be times when we want to diverge and innovate—and we should be able to do that—but there will also be times when we want to align. That needs to be a debate that is conducted in public, not behind closed doors.
Whether it is about keeping pace or an internal market, what must drive us are the principles of what we are trying to achieve: environmental standards, quality products, support for our local economies and fair labour market standards. We need to see the Subsidy Control Bill enable strong public procurement that not only gets us value for money but is not a race to the bottom. We need innovative strategic government intervention, both by our Government in Scotland and by our local authorities, when there is a strong case for action.
I think that the UK Government needs to listen to the concerns that have been raised by our committee. Our report was unanimous, and unanimity is not something that we always get on a controversial issue on which there have been differences of opinion in the chamber. To come back to that point: our committee was unanimous. I want the UK Government to listen to our recommendations, and I want it to act. There is an issue about treating our Parliaments across the UK with respect.
15:53