I rise to make a small contribution regarding the final part of Craig Hoy’s motion, in which he calls on the Scottish Government to review its blocking of any future civilian nuclear energy projects in Scotland.
Last week, Maree Todd set out the Scottish Government’s position in the John O’Groat Journal. She rejected nuclear power as, she said, it has a “high cost” to consumers over other options; it is “high risk” in terms of safety; and it is not “sustainable”. She said:
“We must focus on reliable energy sources that ... align with our net-zero ambitions ... I believe that the renewables plan, as set out in the Scottish Energy Strategy, offers just that.”
Not unusually, Maree Todd’s arguments, when they are stress tested, lack foundation. She is apparently unaware that the Scottish Government confirmed to me earlier this month that it has no strategic plan to transition from Scottish-generated nuclear energy to renewables. I do not know how she knows that nuclear does not
“align with our net zero ambitions”.
That is extraordinary, given that the Cabinet Secretary for Net Zero, Energy and Transport told me that,
“it is not currently possible to distinguish between types of generation or fuels”—[Written Answers, 21 January 2022; S6W-05511.]
in order to break down CO2 emissions data from energy generation sources in Scotland.
As Craig Hoy flagged, the Scottish Government will not replace Torness and Hunterston, but has done no modelling of the impact on energy bills and the cost of living crisis, so Maree Todd’s cost claims are spurious at best.
Maree Todd justified her position by stating:
“I believe the vast majority of the public back my position.”
I respectfully suggest that she reviews some YouGov research that was published in the run-up to the 26th United Nations climate change conference of the parties—COP26—which shows that, in Scotland, 65 per cent are in favour of a role for nuclear in the energy mix, 13 per cent are against and 20 per cent do not know.
Maree Todd also said that nuclear was “high risk” in terms of safety, but there have been no major nuclear safety incidents in the UK industry’s 46 years. Anyone who has done their homework knows that all current operating stations have extraordinary levels of built-in redundancy and that new reactors are designed with even higher levels of safety built in, with further enhancements being made as the technology moves on, all while being subject to one of the most robust regulatory regimes in the world.
I turn to the economics of nuclear over other options. The price of power from Hunterston B until it was retired and from Torness is about £45 per MWh. Wind contracts for difference historically average around £90 to £100 per MWh and have only recently reduced to levels similar to those of Torness. In terms of build cost, the UK Government’s proposed regulated asset base model will lower the cost of financing. As Paul McLennan will be delighted to hear, the National Audit Office says that that would have reduced Hinkley’s costs by 40 per cent. In addition, wind turbines operate only 25 to 40 per cent of the time. Without nuclear power, when wind turbines are not operating, the grid would have to use expensive gas to fill the void. Nuclear stations operate more than 90 per cent of the time, which means that they require far less back-up.
On waste, members should bear in mind the fact that the nuclear industry is the only one to pay for and clean up its own waste. EDF and the UK Government have already set aside £14.8 billion to decommission the existing power stations and dispose of waste from them. An increasing fund, equivalent to about £2 per MWh, has been created to cover the cost. The amount of waste that is produced by nuclear is also very small. Almost all the radioactivity is found a tiny fraction of the waste, which is called high-level waste. Over the lifetime of a station, there is one dishwasher tablet-worth of such waste for every person in the UK.
That was a short contribution to the debate, but one that was necessary, if only to add some scientific and data-driven fortitude to a Scottish Government position that is anything but scientific and data driven.
13:23