I congratulate Evelyn Tweed on securing this important debate and, as Michael Marra has just said, providing the opportunity for members from across the country to reflect on the implications of the very challenging instances of weather that we have had to face in storms Arwen, Barra, Malik and Corrie. Evelyn Tweed was correct, in her motion and her comments, to pay tribute to the significant contribution that has been made to the resilience effort by countless communities and community organisations. I will come on to say a little bit more about that.
As members have indicated, in the aftermath of storm Arwen, the Government undertook to review the experience of the handling of the storm. That review was carried out expeditiously by the Government’s resilience division, and the report was published last week. It is a comprehensive report, which contains a number of recommendations on how we should address and improve the resilience effort that is in place.
None of that should in any way detract from the enormous efforts of a range of organisations and the staff from power companies who worked in atrocious conditions to restore supply in complex circumstances. I saw that for myself when I visited Gillian Martin’s constituency in the north-east of Scotland in the aftermath of storm Arwen. It should also not detract from the efforts of local resilience partnerships and volunteer groups who put in such an effort to improve the situation. However, in all those instances, we must be candid enough to reflect on performance and identify how it could be improved.
Having spent most of my weekend involved in calls and discussions relating to storms Malik and Corrie, I have reflected on the fact that, following storm Arwen, two important factors changed in the handling of storms Malik and Corrie. The first is that resilience partners were notified earlier by the power companies of their identification and recognition of the scale of the challenge. We were therefore clearer, earlier in the handling of storms Malik and Corrie, that we had significant challenges to overcome in the restoration of power supply. In broad headline messaging to members of the public, it was clearer than was the case with storm Arwen that people might be off supply for a long period. That does not help anybody if they are off power, but it allows people to make alternative arrangements, and it commits the power companies to making alternative arrangements to support those individuals.
The second difference is that, as a result of that notification, the local resilience operation that has been put in place has been available more timeously than was the case for storm Arwen. Welfare support, access to hot and warm food, and access to leisure centres for phone charging and showering purposes and for a place to get warm have been more readily and quickly available during storms Malik and Corrie than was the case during storm Arwen.
Those are two areas in which the swift review of storm Arwen has helped us to improve the delivery of the resilience operation to members of the public in the course of the past few days. Having said that, there are important additional areas in which we must continue to build on the strong foundations that we have for resilience in Scotland. We have well-established and tested resilience arrangements, but we must constantly improve those arrangements because of the nature of the challenges that we are likely to face. Members are right to highlight the fact that crucial tests will be thrown at us by the weather due to changes in the weather systems that are becoming all too familiar.
In her speech and her motion, Evelyn Tweed made particular reference to the role of volunteers and, in particular, the Killin Mountain Rescue Team, the Trossachs Search and Rescue Team and the British Red Cross. I reiterate her thanks to those organisations and many other voluntary organisations—Gillian Martin and Karen Adam also referenced organisations in their constituencies in the north-east of Scotland. Those organisations are making a huge contribution to resolving the difficulties faced by individuals.
Colin Smyth raised an important issue, which I discussed yesterday with the Scottish resilience partnership, about the necessity of communities having the capacity to contribute to resilience efforts. In some communities, that capacity exists and does phenomenally well, but in others it is not so mature. I am therefore interested in Colin Smyth’s suggestion of an eighth duty to formalise, perhaps, the role of community capacity building. In saying that, though, I acknowledge the importance of that being adequately created and supported to ensure that it is effective in meeting the needs of individuals in their communities.
A significant issue that Evelyn Tweed talked about extensively is the work of the power companies. Power company staff are working extremely hard in very cold and challenging conditions to restore supplies to people affected by storm Malik and storm Corrie. Before I came into the chamber tonight, I was advised that Scottish Power has restored all supplies and that SSEN is optimistic that it will get very close to restoring full supply by the end of this evening, although it might well be late in the evening before that happens.
I thank those members of staff for all that they are doing and all the communication that is under way. In these circumstances, clarity of communication is essential to alert people to the likely challenges, but it is important to acknowledge that our network must be resilient to meet them, and Mr Smyth and Mr Marra made fair points in that respect. We lost power lines because of the amount of overhead cables that we have, and that issue will have to be resolved by Ofgem in dialogue with the power companies.
I am grateful to Evelyn Tweed for the opportunity to reflect on what has been a very stormy period in Scottish weather and what have been very challenging circumstances. A huge amount of effort from communities, local resilience partnerships and the power companies has gone into addressing the challenges, but assure Parliament of the Government’s determination to lead a process of constant improvement, to build on our strong foundations for resilience and, most of all, to act to remedy the challenges that members of the public face as quickly and as effectively as possible.
Meeting closed at 18:22.