Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Redress for Survivors (Historical Child Abuse in Care) (Reconsideration and Review of Determinations) (Scotland) Regulations 2022 [Draft]

Wednesday 26 January 2022 Education, Children and Young People Committee About 09:00 Subordinate legislation 10 contributions · 2 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

10 contributions
Stephen Kerr Con The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Good morning, and welcome to the third meeting in 2022 of the Education, Children and Young People Committee.

The first item on our agenda is evidence from the Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Covid Recovery, John Swinney MSP, and his Scottish Government officials, on the Redress for Survivors (Historical Child Abuse in Care) (Reconsideration and Review of Determinations) (Scotland) Regulations 2022.

I welcome the Deputy First Minister and his accompanying officials Paul Beaton, the head of the legislation and contributions unit, and Claire Montgomery, a solicitor in the legal directorate.

I invite Mr Swinney to speak to the draft instrument.

John Swinney SNP The Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Covid Recovery · Perthshire North
link

I am grateful for the opportunity to discuss the issue and explain the detail of the affirmative instrument that is before the committee.

As the committee will be aware, at the end of last year, we passed a significant milestone with the launch of Scotland’s redress scheme, which opened for applications on 8 December. I am pleased to inform the committee that we have received more than 2,000 calls to the scheme since its launch and that more than 250 application forms have been received. That represents a significant step towards facing up to the wrongs of the past and the harm caused to society’s most vulnerable children.

As we move to deliver redress to survivors, we must ensure that the scheme operates fairly for all. Part of that is providing mechanisms to be able to reconsider, and deal with, any determinations under the scheme that are made in error, including those relating to the outcome of a redress application. The draft regulations before the committee seek to achieve that clear goal.

Section 75 of the Redress for Survivors (Historical Child Abuse in Care) (Scotland) Act 2021 creates a reconsideration process, whereby a Redress Scotland panel can revisit a determination already made under part 4 of the act, should a concern arise that the determination was materially affected by error. That includes where a mistake might have been made in making the determination, or where it is thought that a determination was made on the basis of incorrect or misleading information.

Where the panel determines that an error has occurred, it must put that right. Importantly, where an applicant is not satisfied when they are told of the outcome of a determination, they can request a review. Safeguards are included in the act so that an applicant cannot be prejudiced by exercising their review right when the review is linked to the determination of a redress application.

In practice, we hope and anticipate that we will very rarely require to use the reconsideration and review processes, because robust measures have been embedded throughout the application process and wider scheme to reduce the opportunity for error and potential fraud. However, the draft regulations aim to ensure that we have suitable mechanisms in place to support people through the reconsideration and review processes if required. They also allow us to respond in a fair and effective manner to all possible outcomes of the processes that are linked to the determination of a redress application.

Although the range of possible outcomes is complex, the principle underpinning the proposed amendments to the act is simple: as far as possible, we wish to put an applicant back in the position that they would have been in, had no error occurred.

That may mean that an applicant is offered a different redress payment than the sum that they have been offered or have accepted previously, or that they may benefit from a fresh offer where an error has led to them not being given one before. In those scenarios, we intend that applicants will be given the option to do what is right for them, with the benefit of legal advice, by either accepting or rejecting the new offer.

The waiver is a key, and much debated, aspect of the act. It is essential that the way in which the waiver operates is fair. The draft regulations therefore seek to amend section 46 of the act on waiver. The effect of the proposed amendments is that, where an applicant is issued with an updated or fresh offer of a redress payment following a reconsideration or review, the waiver linked to that offer will reflect the contributor list at the time when the offer should have been made, rather than at the date of the offer itself. That will ensure that, where the offer is accepted, survivors do not miss out on any opportunity that they would otherwise have had to raise civil proceedings.

When a person has already signed a waiver to accept a redress payment offer that has changed following the reconsideration or review process, we consider that it is only fair that they have the opportunity to reconsider their choice and receive legal advice at that critical stage in the process.

We have therefore made provision for that and have ensured that, if a person is content to accept a new offer, the waiver that was signed to accept their original offer will remain in place. If they decide that accepting the new offer is not the right option for them, they will be able to reject it, and any waiver that was signed to accept the original offer will be rendered of no effect.

In the interests of fairness, we have also made provision for a waiver to be rendered of no effect where it is determined that a person ought not to have been offered an award under the scheme.

As I have stressed, the draft regulations ensure that people have access to support and advice, along with the provision for the payment of legal fees and the reimbursement of costs and expenses. That will allow them to fully understand and engage with the reconsideration and review processes and to make the choices that are right for them.

The draft instrument is the final one in a package for the implementation of the redress scheme, and I welcome and appreciate the cross-party support that has ensured that we have delivered the scheme that survivors deserve. I hope that I have provided members with a sufficient overview of the instrument, and my officials and I welcome any questions that the committee may have.

Stephen Kerr Con The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Thank you, Deputy First Minister. If any member has any questions or comments, I ask them to indicate that in the chat box.

Deputy First Minister, you rightly put great emphasis on fairness in your statement. Given those principles of fairness, will the person at the centre of the process—the claimant—have guidance and legal advice at each point of the process, and will that be funded?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

Guidance will go with the instrument that I have set out today and that we have worked through. At the outset, I should acknowledge that the instrument is complex. The reason for its complexity is that multiple permutations have to be provided for, to establish legal clarity. I have looked very carefully at the issue with my officials, and there is no easy way around that. Guidance therefore has to accompany the instrument.

In any judgments that a survivor makes, they will be supported by having access to legal advice at any point. A crucial element of the redress scheme in its entire design has been that all applicants must be able to make informed judgments about the right course of action to take. That must be funded. A schedule to the instrument sets out the arrangements for meeting the costs of legal advice, should that be required by applicants.

Stephen Kerr Con The Convener · Central Scotland
link

In a case in which there is any suggestion of fraud—albeit that we hope that, as you said, there will be very few examples of that—would legal advice for the individual concerned still be part of the funded package of support that they would get during the process?

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

Yes. In the process of consideration of what has led to the circumstances that have given rise to a reconsideration, it must be ensured that individuals are supported without prejudice. That fraud has occurred is perhaps a conclusion; it is not a starting point. Individuals therefore have to have access to the necessary advice, so that they are supported in that process.

Stephen Kerr Con The Convener · Central Scotland
link

As you have said, it is a complex situation with many permutations. However, in your answers, you have been very clear about the upholding of the principles of fairness at all points in the process, as far as the individuals at the centre of that process are concerned.

As no other colleague has questions for the Deputy First Minister, I thank him for his comments.

Under item 2, I invite the Deputy First Minister to speak to and move motion S6M-02797.

John Swinney SNP Perthshire North
link

The comments that I have placed on the record are an adequate contribution to the explanation of the instrument.

Motion moved,

That the Education, Children and Young People Committee recommends that the Redress for Survivors (Historical Child Abuse in Care) (Reconsideration and Review of Determinations) (Scotland) Regulations 2022 be approved.—John Swinney

Motion agreed to.

Stephen Kerr Con The Convener · Central Scotland
link

The committee must now produce its report on the draft instrument. Is the committee content to delegate responsibility to the deputy convener and me to agree the report on its behalf?

Members indicated agreement.

Stephen Kerr Con The Convener · Central Scotland
link

I thank the Deputy First Minister and his officials for their attendance.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report

No recorded division on this motion that day: decisions taken without a vote are not in the divisions feed.

  1. 09:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 10
  2. 09:15 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 7
  3. 09:15 Drink and Needle Spiking Evidence session · 125

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.