I do not know whether I have ever said this before in my 10 years in Parliament, but it is a genuine pleasure to follow Jackson Carlaw’s excellent and very powerful speech. It was another speech that, unsurprisingly, put the women who have been affected—the survivors of mesh—at the front and centre of the discussion. It was a very fine and powerful contribution from Jackson Carlaw, and it is a genuine pleasure to follow his speech and sum up the debate.
I hope that people, particularly the women who are watching our consideration of the bill, will feel able to agree that our work on it has seen this Parliament at its very best, as others have said, with members working across parties to try to make life better for our constituents—the people who send us here to represent them, to right wrongs that have been done and to help those who have been harmed through absolutely no fault of their own. That is what we have tried to do together in relation to this very important bill today.
Again, I thank the members of the Health, Social Care and Sport Committee for their thoughtful consideration. My thanks also go to those members, both past and present, who have campaigned on the mesh issue for many years. In some respects, as the current Cabinet Secretary for Health and Social Care, I am doing the easy bit in bringing the bill forward, as there was already good will among members of all parties. I pay tribute to my predecessor, Jeane Freeman, for committing to taking action at the end of the previous session, and to her predecessor, Shona Robison, who first engaged with the women who were affected and promised them that their plight would not be ignored.
I also praise—as other members have rightly done—the cross-party campaign that was spearheaded by Jackson Carlaw, Neil Findlay and Alex Neil, who played an incredibly important role in ensuring that the voices of mesh survivors were heard loudly. They were determined in their efforts and they made sure that those voices were heard not just by the Government but by the Parliament. Something tells me that the three aforementioned MSPs probably do not catch up regularly over a pint—albeit that Jackson Carlaw seemed to refer to their doing it more often than we think—but they can all take real pride in their collective efforts.
I also thank both the Finance and Public Administration Committee and the Delegated Powers and Law Reform Committee for their consideration of the bill.
Of course, all of us have rightly ensured that the most important thanks and gratitude have been given to those women who have taken the time to engage with the bill and to express their views on it as it has progressed, both in the focus groups and in the committee evidence, as well as in speaking to parliamentarians and ministers. Many of them have spoken to me directly and personally. It is fair to say that, without their courage, we would not be where we are today, and I thank them for that.
Gillian Martin made the important point that the women who are affected have probably told their stories time and again, which, unfortunately, has involved retraumatisation. I hope that, following our passing the bill, as it looks as though we are about to do, they will no longer have to share those stories.
The Government and NHS Scotland are working hard to improve the care that has been offered to those women. Many colleagues have referenced the national specialist mesh removal service in Glasgow. We will continue to see how we can improve that service—there has already been feedback on how it can be improved. Given Dr Gulhane’s clinical experience, I was heartened to hear him speak positively about the expertise and skills of the individuals at the national centre. However, I say again that, if there are improvements to be made, we will seek to hear that feedback from the women involved.
A number of members asked about the reimbursement scheme, seeking a reassurance that its administration will be as flexible as possible. I say again clearly, in my role as the cabinet secretary for health, that it is my expectation that each application should be considered on its own merits. My instruction is also clear that, when there is doubt about any aspect of an application, those who are administering the scheme will work alongside applicants and will apply common sense and good judgment. I do not expect that women who had mesh removal surgery done privately in America five years ago will have kept the receipt for their taxi from the hotel to the hospital. Therefore, I expect the scheme to be operated on a basis whereby those who make the claims are given the benefit of the doubt, appropriate judgment is applied and everything is done in a way that is consistent with our obligations on public finance.
On some of the other issues that colleagues raised, they are absolutely right. Undoubtedly, there are concerns about waiting times for referral to the national centre, as Paul O’Kane and other members mentioned. That is a fair comment. However, that service has been impacted like the rest of the NHS. I take Paul O’Kane’s challenge—that he and others will continue to scrutinise that referral—in the spirit in which it was intended. They are right to do so.
Carol Mochan made an important point about communication. I give her an absolute assurance that it is foremost in our thoughts that, prior to the scheme being ready to open, we will have in place clear communication about eligibility criteria, what is expected, how an application is made, how long a person will have to wait, and so on. All that work is being done at the moment.
Colleagues made other important points about the fact that there are on-going issues. It is not—as, I think, Carol Mochan said—the end of the road. Although the bill is an important step, which we all recognise, there are women who have not had mesh removal surgery, and we need to guide them as appropriately and as sensitively as we can through the other avenues for recourse that absolutely exist for them. This is not the end of the road, but it is an important chapter.
It is probably right that I give the last word to the women who fought so long to get us to this point today. We would not be here without them or without the campaigning of MSPs over a number of years. I will quote from a letter that was submitted by some of those women to members of the Public Petitions Committee. It said:
“These women have already suffered the loss of the lives they once enjoyed, their jobs, mobility, and marital lives. They have been left on benefits and dependent on others because they trusted they were receiving ‘gold standard treatment’. We do not believe they should have to suffer the loss of their life savings too.”
I whole-heartedly agree, and I feel confident that everyone in the Parliament believes that reimbursement of those personal costs is the very least that mesh survivors deserve. We are all here today with that unified purpose—to make sure that we do right by women who have suffered through no fault of their own.
I am delighted to close the debate. I hope that members will unanimously support this incredibly important bill.