I absolutely agree with the sentiments expressed by the cabinet secretary about the need to provide a system that protects the public, as far as we can. I will get to the nub of things, if I may, because I have made my remarks already, and I do not want to repeat them.
If we needed licensing simply because of the reasons that the police set out in their evidence to us, the regulations should have said that the licence will be granted unless there are good reasons not to grant it. One of those good reasons would have been that the applicant was not a fit and proper person on the basis of the police information. However, that is not what we are presented with. I made the point to the cabinet secretary that there are no criteria or rules; there is nothing to fetter the discretion of local authorities in their decision as to whether to grant or refuse a licence. I think that everyone would agree that, if a hoodlum, money launderer or drug dealer is laundering money through property—an issue that I think actually exists—there must be a means of dealing with that and he should not be given a licence to conduct such a business or any other businesses.
However, that is not what the regulations say. They do not delimit the discretion of local authorities to that particular issue. Moreover, I think that I have already proven, by reading out from the Scottish Government’s website, that the fit and proper person test does apply to a registration scheme. It applies to me, as a landlord, and rightly so. I am glad that it applies. Therefore, the case that we need a licensing scheme to deal with the police concerns seems to me not to have been made.
The second point that I want to make is this. Earlier, I alluded to concerns that, because the rules have not been specified and local authorities have unfettered discretion—paving the way for 31 different varieties of decision making, incidentally—businesses, many of which have operated for decades, may face the unilateral withdrawal and confiscation of their business by the decision of a local authority, which they cannot challenge on the basis of any clear rules.
Although I am no legal expert, I am aware of cases where the Scottish Government has failed because of breach of article 1 in the first protocol of the European Convention on Human Rights—namely, the provision that says that every natural person has the right to protection of their own possessions, except in the interest of public policy. If a clear public policy interest had been expressed in the regulations, that might have enabled the Government to say that it had acted reasonably. However, because there is none, it appears to me—although I am a non-expert—that there is a risk of arbitrariness, and the Wednesbury test, which I believe applies, seems to me to be at serious risk of being at issue.
11:30
I do not make that argument enthusiastically or lightly, but because I am genuinely concerned. I also point out that, as the cabinet secretary knows, the Association of Scotland’s Self-Caterers has already shared an opinion that it has had from an eminent firm of solicitors in Scotland. Although I have not seen the evidence myself, I have been informed that three other equally eminent firms of solicitors in Scotland have also opined on the issue. I stress that I have not seen whether it is their view that there is a prima facie breach and that judicial review might therefore be successful.
I put this to the cabinet secretary and to committee members as a matter of common sense. If there is a system in which someone’s property can be taken away and their business terminated, there should surely be a very clear set of rules to govern in what circumstances that can happen. It is all very well to say that the fears that have been raised are alarmist or scaremongering, but what are people to think if there is no clear set of rules in the regulations? Moreover, if there is the possibility of a licence being withdrawn but the licensing system can take several years to operate, there will be a long period of uncertainty between the application for the licence and the determination. What happens to bookings and cancellations during that period? What happens to the business if the licence is refused? None of that has been answered.
There are many other arguments that I could put, but I think that I have said enough to indicate that I am not a fan of the order. I say to the cabinet secretary that it is never too late to look at this again. If the order is passed today, as I suspect it will be, I hope that the cabinet secretary will—as she has promised—engage with the sector before the order comes to a plenary session in order to look further at the real concerns and at the real, serious and sincere alternative proposals. Such proposals, including the exemplar from Portugal, operate in Europe and are favoured by the EU.