Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Classroom Temperature

Portfolio Question Time Education and Skills

Wednesday 22 December 2021 Meeting of the Parliament Questions 7 contributions · 4 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

7 contributions
Siobhian Brown SNP Ayr
link

To ask the Scottish Government what measures are being put in place to keep pupils warm while they are in classrooms over the coming months, given the need for adequate ventilation to mitigate the risks of Covid-19. (S6O-00579)

Shirley-Anne Somerville SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Education and Skills · Dunfermline
link

Our updated guidance for schools gives potential approaches to increase natural ventilation while balancing temperature and user comfort. Strategies will vary depending on local circumstances, but they can include partially opening doors and windows to provide ventilation while reducing draughts; opening high-level windows in preference to low-level windows to reduce draughts; purging spaces by opening windows, vents and external doors, for example between classes or during break and lunch; flexible uniform and staff dress policies to help to ensure that children, young people and staff can stay warm if doors require to be opened; and maintaining appropriate heating strategies.

Siobhian Brown SNP Ayr
link

Over the past few months, it has become apparent that ventilation plays an important part in reducing transmission of Covid variants. How is the Scottish Government ensuring that the appropriate risk assessments are conducted for indoor teaching environments?

Shirley-Anne Somerville SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Education and Skills · Dunfermline
link

As the member will be aware, the Scottish Government has provided an additional £10 million to local authorities, on top of the £90 million that was provided earlier on in the pandemic, for measures including on ventilation. She is quite right to point out that an important part of all the work in that area is adequate risk assessment. Our recently updated guidance, which I referred to in answer to previous questions, sets out an increased expectation that sufficient CO2 monitors should be made available across all local authorities to allow learning, teaching and play spaces to be assessed often to support on-going decision making by staff about balancing ventilation with temperature during the winter months. As a broad guideline, spaces should be assessed for a minimum of one full day per week under normal occupancy.

Michael Marra Lab North East Scotland
link

Let us be clear that what that means is “Open the window.” After two years, that is what the Government has come up with. Young people are learning in freezing temperatures, wearing hats, scarves and gloves.

Just in the past week, a teacher in Dundee told me that the red light on their CO2 monitor is on constantly. He has been told to ignore it and he now has Covid. At best, he will miss Christmas with his family.

Will the cabinet secretary begin the immediate procurement of high-efficiency particulate air—HEPA—filter machines for every classroom, so that that completely unacceptable situation does not arise for a third winter in a row?

Shirley-Anne Somerville SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Education and Skills · Dunfermline
link

If that teacher has indeed been told to ignore a red light, I strongly suggest to Mr Marra that, if he has not done so already, he encourages the teacher to contact his trade union.

Arrangements are in place to ensure that any member of staff who has concerns can have those concerns addressed at a local level. The Convention of Scottish Local Authorities has made it clear that trade union representatives can raise specific issues that cannot be resolved satisfactorily at a local level through the workforce issues group that COSLA chairs.

I point Mr Marra, once again, to the fact that our guidance on ventilation is based on expert advice. HEPA filters are not a replacement for natural ventilation—that point has been made clear in the expert advice that we have received.

I also point Mr Marra to the COVID-19 Recovery Committee, where there have been many discussions about the issue. For example, the committee heard evidence from Dr Shaun Fitzgerald, who said:

“My first port of call would be to try to use the infrastructure that is already there—namely, opening windows—and to be smart about the way that it is used.”—[Official Report, COVID-19 Recovery Committee, 4 November 2021; c 39.]

We are following the expert advice on the matter and will continue to do so. We are, of course, open to change if that expert advice itself changes.

Liam McArthur LD The Deputy Presiding Officer · Orkney Islands
link

Question 7 was not lodged. Graham Simpson joins us remotely for question 8.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. Justice and Veterans Questions · 1
  2. Victim Notification Scheme Review Questions · 6
  3. Modern Slavery and Organised Crime (Police Training) Questions · 7
  4. Victims and Survivors Views Questions · 7
  5. Victim Surcharge Fund Questions · 6
  6. Forensic Examination Services (Children and Young People) Questions · 5
  7. Justice Vision and Priorities Delivery Plan Questions · 4
  8. Management of Offenders (Scotland) Act 2019 Questions · 6
  9. 101 Phone Line (Waiting Times) Questions · 4
  10. Finance and the Economy Questions · 1
  11. Social and Affordable Housing (Draft Budget 2022-23) Questions · 8
  12. Retail, Hospitality and Leisure Businesses (Government Support) Questions · 11
  13. Scottish Fiscal Commission Report (Funding Shortfall) Questions · 12
  14. Small Businesses (Non-domestic Rates) Questions · 9
  15. Hospitality Sector (Financial Support) Questions · 9
  16. Employee-owned Businesses Questions · 5
  17. Draft Budget 2022-23 (Stakeholders) Questions · 6
  18. Education and Skills Questions · 1
  19. School Examinations 2022 Questions · 9
  20. Attainment Gap Questions · 6
  21. Science Subjects Uptake Questions · 10
  22. Science, Technology, Engineering and Maths Teachers (Rural Areas) Questions · 5
  23. Classroom Temperature Questions · 7
  24. Attainment Gap Questions · 6
  25. Water Environment Statement · 39
  26. Business Motion Business motions · 1
  27. Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 2
  28. Decision Time Decision time · 2
  29. Dumfries City Status Members’ business · 54

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.