Thank you for the opportunity to give evidence. The purpose of the draft order is to ensure that, in calculating the rateable value of specified properties after the order comes into force, no account can be taken of any matter arising on or after 1 April 2021 that is attributable to coronavirus.
Since the start of the coronavirus pandemic, more than 40,000 non-domestic properties have been appealed on the basis that there has been a material change of circumstances due to the pandemic. Typically, a “material change of circumstances” has been used to reflect either physical changes to a property, such as an extension or demolition, or certain major works in a specific area, such as the tram works in Edinburgh. The Scottish Parliament amended the definition to exclude changes in rent, in valuations generally or in values generally under the Non-Domestic Rates (Scotland) Act 2020, with effect from 2 April 2020.
The draft order further clarifies that definition in relation to coronavirus by specifying that, in calculating the rateable value of any properties in the 2017 valuation roll,
“no account is to be taken of any matter arising ... after 1 April 2021 that is directly or indirectly attributable to coronavirus.”
The use of that date is due to the fact that subordinate legislation cannot take us further back. Primary legislation is needed for that, and we confirmed in our programme for government our intention to introduce a bill on the matter in year 1.
The draft order applies only to the current 2017 valuation roll, which is consistent with our view that any impact of Covid-19 should be reflected at the next revaluation. Also, the order does not take into account whether a property should be included in the valuation roll. For instance, if someone started working from home as a result of the pandemic, the legislation would not affect whether their office space might be considered rateable.
The intention of the change in definition was to remove general economic factors from the category of relevant factors to consider in the context of valuation.
Although appeals have been submitted for more than 40,000 properties, that is less than a fifth of all non-domestic properties in Scotland and, as the Federation of Small Businesses pointed out, not many small businesses are among them. That may reflect our existing generous support package for small businesses, but it is likely that it also reflects the fact that well-resourced professionally advised property owners and occupiers are more likely to know about the material change of circumstances provisions and are therefore more likely to have appealed.
I am aware that some large firms under appeal have been successful during the pandemic. As was highlighted in evidence last week, there is a disconnect between how Covid has felt to businesses and how it has impacted on rents in the commercial property market. It is a hugely complex issue and Covid-19 appeals could take years to resolve. The outcome is also uncertain. It cannot be assumed that those appeals would be successful, or their outcome fair.
In light of that complexity and the provisions in the 2020 act, it seems to me that the question here is quite a dry and technical one. When is the right time for market-wide economic changes, including any effects of coronavirus, to be reflected in rateable values? We believe that the right time for such changes to be reflected is at revaluation.
We strengthened revaluations following the independent Barclay review of non-domestic rates in order to ensure that they more closely reflect market circumstances. First, we increased the frequency of revaluations from every five years to every three years and reduced the time between the tone date and the revaluation. Secondly, with the support of your predecessor committee, we delayed the next revaluation by one year to 2023 and brought forward that commitment to a one-year tone date. The tone date for the next revaluation will therefore be 1 April 2022 in order to give sufficient time for the property market to adjust post Covid.
Covid-19 has had a major impact on the economy, and we responded swiftly and on an unprecedented scale to support businesses through the pandemic. We introduced 100 per cent retail, hospitality, leisure and aviation relief in 2020-21, and we are the first Government to confirm a full extension of that relief to 2021-22.
The extension of the RHLA relief into 2021-22 takes the total level of support that the Scottish Government has provided to businesses since the beginning of the pandemic to £4.5 billion, which includes £1.6 billion of Covid-related reliefs. That demonstrates that the Scottish Government has acted quickly to support the business community when it most needed that support. We have been able to support businesses through the pandemic, but we must bear in mind that we must also continue to fund the public services on which we all rely.
I return to my opening comments. The draft order seeks to ensure fairness for all Scottish ratepayers while maintaining the integrity of the non-domestic rates system as well as the stability of the public finances. If the instrument is not approved, the non-domestic rates system and, therefore, the public finances will carry significant long-term risks for years.
I look forward to answering any questions that the committee has.