Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Redress for Survivors (Historical Child Abuse in Care) (Exceptions to Eligibility) (Scotland) Regulations 2021 [Draft]

Wednesday 27 October 2021 Education, Children and Young People Committee About 10:00–10:15 Subordinate legislation 14 contributions · 4 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

14 contributions
Stephen Kerr Con The Convener · Central Scotland
link

The fourth item on the agenda is evidence from the Deputy First Minister and his officials on the draft Redress for Survivors (Historical Child Abuse in Care) (Exceptions to Eligibility) (Scotland) Regulations 2021. The Deputy First Minister is again supported by Paul Beaton, who is the head of the legislation and contributions unit in the Scottish Government, and Barry McCaffrey, who is a lawyer in the Scottish Government legal directorate. I invite Mr Swinney to speak to the draft regulations.

John Swinney
link

Thank you, again, convener.

Section 23 of the Redress for Survivors (Historical Child Abuse in Care) (Scotland) Act 2021 enables regulations to be made regarding certain circumstances in which a potential applicant would not be eligible to apply to the redress scheme. It was envisaged that that power would be exercised where exclusions were considered necessary and consistent with the underlying purpose of the scheme.

In keeping with that, we indicated throughout the passage of the act, including within the policy memorandum and our response to the stage 1 report, that regulations may be made in relation to short-term respite placements. The draft regulations before the committee are such regulations. Specifically, they provide that an application for redress may not be made

“by or in respect of a person to the extent that it relates to abuse that occurred when that person was resident in a relevant care setting”

to provide “short-term respite or holiday care” where that care was arranged by

“a parent or guardian and another person.”

The abuse of children in all circumstances and settings is wrong and harmful. However, the purpose of the scheme has been to respond to survivors who, when they were placed in care, lost the oversight and protection of their parents and families. As a result, they were often isolated and had limited or no contact with their families. By contrast, respite or holiday care was intended to be and always was short term, and the parental rights and responsibilities were not affected. That has been reflected on by some survivors whose parents had their rights removed, who have referred to themselves as “children of the state”, the state being charged with their care and protection when they were stripped of access to their families. Children who were resident on a short-term respite or holiday basis were not in that position.

I seek the committee’s support for the draft regulations to ensure that the scheme can be launched as soon as possible. Having the regulations in place will also allow us to set out clearly the exceptions to eligibility in advance of the scheme opening, which will allow for transparency and ensure that survivors are well informed.

Oliver Mundell Con Dumfriesshire
link

I listened carefully to what you said, Deputy First Minister. Because of the passage of time, it will not be immediately obvious how some short-term placements came about. Through my constituency work, I am aware of families that are really struggling, and it is often social workers, healthcare workers or other Government-funded professionals who step in and suggest that they should think about respite to avoid going down a different route and as a way of giving the family a chance to reset.

I wonder about the detail of some of the cases. I cannot imagine that accessing short-term placements was necessarily presented as a choice to all parents. What would happen in such circumstances? How would you weigh that up?

John Swinney
link

Mr Mundell raises a legitimate point. The definition in the draft regulations of the cases in question is very narrow. We are trying to distinguish circumstances in which the state’s actions fundamentally altered contact with the family and the family’s involvement. There is a significant difference between respite provision and some form of order that removes a child from a family setting. I do not think that the regulations would be relevant in circumstances in which a separate order had required a child’s removal.

At this stage and in the current context—this is absolutely consistent with what we have signed up to in terms of the independent care review in the context of the promise—the state wants to avoid as far as possible the separation of children from their families. Perhaps if we had learned in previous eras some of the lessons that we are now learning from the care review, we would have avoided many of the issues that we are having to confront in the redress scheme.

The regulations are focused on the concept of short-term respite and holiday care where the relationship with the family is not fundamentally altered by the actions of the state. I hope that that provides a distinction that reassures Mr Mundell.

Oliver Mundell Con Dumfriesshire
link

I recognise the policy reasons for the Government going down that route, but I still think that there will be a number of cases where orders are not progressed because families had taken advantage of short-term placements. Sometimes those were repeat placements, and individuals could have been subject to multiple, repeated incidents. It is a wee bit complicated in places, but I am happy to accept the explanation that has been given.

However, my real question is why you went down the exclusionary route and did not opt for a model that would allow each individual case to be considered. It is legitimate to be clear about the limits of the scheme and what the expectations are, but my point is about creating a space for people with exceptional circumstances, such as multiple short-term placements with the same abuser over a number of years. Such placements were probably encouraged by the state. Why would there not be provision for those people to have their individual circumstances looked at? Why did you go down the route of exclusion?

John Swinney
link

In a sense, Mr Mundell provides the answer to his own question. We feel it necessary to clearly establish the principles and purpose of the scheme. In essence, they are to address abuse that has taken place in care settings where the state had oversight of the care of the child—that is, the care of the child was not in the family context.

The issue of short-term respite and holiday care is in marginal territory. The example that Mr Mundell cites, of an individual who was placed repeatedly in a short-term respite environment, is a further development of that marginal territory. In those circumstances, Redress Scotland would be able to consider whether there was a characteristic of that exceptional nature that merited consideration. However, I feel that it is necessary for us to establish at the outset of the scheme clear expectations of its parameters, to enable clarity to be available to people from the start of the scheme.

Oliver Mundell Con Dumfriesshire
link

I will leave it there, convener. I appreciate the further detail.

Stephen Kerr Con The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Thank you. I believe that Fergus Ewing wanted to speak.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness and Nairn
link

Thank you, convener, but I did not indicate that I wish to ask a question at this point.

10:15

Stephen Kerr Con The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Deputy First Minister, is there anything that you would like to say on the instrument that has not previously been raised?

John Swinney
link

No, convener. That is all from me.

Stephen Kerr Con The Convener · Central Scotland
link

In that case, we move to our next agenda item, and I ask the Deputy First Minister to move motion S6M-01400.

Motion moved,

That the Education, Children and Young People Committee recommends that the Redress for Survivors (Historical Child Abuse in Care) (Exceptions to Eligibility) (Scotland) Regulations 2021 be approved.—John Swinney

Motion agreed to.

Stephen Kerr Con The Convener · Central Scotland
link

As with the previous draft instrument, the committee must now produce a report in respect of our consideration of the instrument. Is the committee content to delegate responsibility to me and the deputy convener to agree the report on behalf of the committee?

Members indicated agreement.

Stephen Kerr Con The Convener · Central Scotland
link

I thank the Deputy First Minister and his officials for their attendance today. We will have a two-minute suspension to allow them to leave.

10:16 Meeting suspended.

10:18 On resuming—

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report

No recorded division on this motion that day: decisions taken without a vote are not in the divisions feed.

  1. 09:30 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:45 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 35
  3. 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 14
  4. 10:15 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
  5. 10:15 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 3
  6. 10:15 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 2
  7. 10:15 Advanced Research and Invention Agency Bill Bill debate · 7

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.